markhochstein Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 I have just acquired a Domino XL. Tonight I was cleaning the shop and when I got over to my hollow chisel mortiser I started thinking about whether the Domino can replace it. The first thing that came to mind was narrow mortises (since I bought the XL). Now, not having a lot of experience with the Domino yet I'm wondering how much I'll use the HCM. Can you think of any other operations that the HCM will perform that the Domino will not? Quote
tdale51@yahoo.com Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 I don't know the answer to this question but I'd be happy to store your HCM for you while you figure it out. I promise I would have a good home and I'll even let you Skype with it so it doesn't get homesick. Quote
RJsumthn Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 Thats a good observation and it is hard to think of something but mainly it still allows you to create traditional mortise and tenon joints. You might find a customer that wants traditional joinery. Quote
wdwerker Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 I have used a hollow chisel morticer to cut the recesses for Greene and Greene ebony pegs. Kinda need the square corners so the Domino wouldn't work for that. Or square pickets in an Arts and crafts project, where you need a single square mortice. But I use my Domino for every thing else tenon related. I make medium and xtra wide tenon stock in each domino thickness for use where 2 domino's wouldn't fit. Quote
G S Haydon Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 The Domino seems great for a lot of furniture applications. If you wanted to make some larger scale work like a windows or a door I would still want a mortice and tenon. Also I just like m&t joints, so adaptable and proven over hundreds of years. Quote
woodwhisperer Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 I wouldn't say obsolete so much as largely redundant. If you have a router, you still have a means for making traditional m&t joint. Frankly, between my router and Domino, my mortiser is collecting dust! Quote
Trip Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 ==> Frankly, between my router and Domino, my mortiser is collecting dust! exactly. after i got the domino, I eBayed my biscuit jointer -- -after the xl, i e-bayed my HCM... As for G&G plugs, that was a shortcoming -- then I saw lee valley had some square chisels precisely for that purpose. Basically, after reading Chris Schwartz's The Anarchist's Tool Chest -- I've been eBaying a lot of tools... Like Chris, I'm discovering just how many redundant tools there are in my shop to support my projects and workflow. It's nice to recover floor/shelf space... Quote
dwacker Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 I'm trying hard to stay away from the domino. It's sort of addictive and so quick and easy. I've gone back to traditional and might even replace the slot mortiser that burned in my old shop. Quote
Trip Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 ==> It's sort of addictive and so quick and easy. that's apt -- it's quite seductive... It's incredible just how fast you assimilate a domino into your workflow... I now automatically reach for the XL. For example, I'm building some outdoor benches today... Each bench has 30 floating tenons.... With the XL, it's a 1-day job to do 3 benches. With traditional M/T, it would take me an extra 4 or 6 hrs (at least) and push the project into the next day. At some point, I feel like the XL is a bit like cheating -- but on the other hand, I've got a honey-do list and things that improve my workflow efficiency are welcome in my shop. It's like buying a wide-belt or drum sander -- it kind of felt like cheating --- until I got that first panel out the back-end.... Quote
woodwhisperer Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 Yeah, selling off the mortiser is an attractive prospect. Only time I use it is to demonstrate. Can't remember the last time it was used for a project. Quote
Trip Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 ==> Yeah, selling off the mortiser is an attractive prospect. eBay/Craigslist is your friend... One thing I'm learning -- it's better to have fewer high-quality tools and really learn how to get the most from them rather than zillions of specialty tools that you use twice a year. I think the poster child was NYW -- remember the episode where Norm used a small PC circular saw (like 4.25") for cutting thin sheet stock??? I think I saw him use it twice over the years... Quote
G S Haydon Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 I guess it depends on your work, a hcm is an essential for me the domino might be the one collecting dust. Quote
Trip Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 that's my point -- your workflow, your projects and your mileage may vary... I find the domino XL to be 70% to 30% for the domino. Quote
dwacker Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 ==> Yeah, selling off the mortiser is an attractive prospect. eBay/Craigslist is your friend... One thing I'm learning -- it's better to have fewer high-quality tools and really learn how to get the most from them rather than zillions of specialty tools that you use twice a year. I think the poster child was NYW -- remember the episode where Norm used a small PC circular saw (like 4.25") for cutting thin sheet stock??? I think I saw him use it twice over the years... That saw cuts as nice as a festool if you use a forrest blade. I've had one for decades, wouldnt go without. Quote
Tpt life Posted April 28, 2013 Report Posted April 28, 2013 That PC circ is great for training your kids. It has been replaced on the job site by a whole host of battery units but this doesn't help your twelve year old son learn to tend a cord. I also worked with a custom cabinet man who never reached for a heavier circ unless necessary. Specialty tools exist for niche markets. We see fancy tools and think we fit the niche and all too often do not. But then, some niches do not open up until after a tool has been around awhile. And in this case something novel (domino) replaces multiple niche tools. When you figure out what is useless to you, I will gladly buy your second hand tools and follow your journey ten years behind you:-) Quote
markhochstein Posted April 28, 2013 Author Report Posted April 28, 2013 Interesting thoughts guys, thanks! Here's a couple of my own. Based on my initial use of the Domino XL I'm starting to look at it as a replacement for my HCM because 1) it can make deeper mortises than my HCM 2) it leaves a cleaner mortise entry and exit (for through mortises) 3) it has great chip collection 4) it's much faster to set up. I too like traditional M&T's. I'm thinking that I can still cut traditional tenons on my table saw as I always have if that's what is desired, but I can cut the mortises with the Domino XL and then just square up the corners. So far if has taken me very little time to square up the corners of a Domino mortise. So, I'm wondering, have any of you guys used a Domino as a mortiser for traditional tenons? My HCM is the Powermatic PM701 Benchtop model with an open stand. I have been very happy with the power, but it's still very finicky to set up properly. Quote
TerryMcK Posted April 29, 2013 Report Posted April 29, 2013 I couldn't justify a Domino at the moment (even though I NEED it - know what I mean?) so I won't be getting rid of my HCM any time soon. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.