Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Question about a workbench

Featured Replies

I only have one bench right now that doubles as an outfeed table to my table saw. It is 24" x 48" and made of one MDF and 2x4's. Works for now.

 

I have been debating in my head what I should have as my full time surface. I am in no way a hand tool enthusiast. Never have, and never will be. I will utilize a few hand tools here and there like a block plane, chisels, dovetail saw, etc. But that is about my extent of that.

 

My main question is, should I make a torsion box type bench or a slab type bench? What are the pros and cons to both? I've never had either.

I only have one bench right now that doubles as an outfeed table to my table saw. It is 24" x 48" and made of one MDF and 2x4's. Works for now.

 

I have been debating in my head what I should have as my full time surface. I am in no way a hand tool enthusiast. Never have, and never will be.

 

 

Never say never.  My advice would be to build a traditional bench...one that can handle any work-holding needs and will last a lifetime.  I had fun building my bench, but I never want to do it again.  And I'm glad I won't have to.

I've been building the Roubo from the guild build since October or so. (Along with a ton of other projects that keep interrupting the Roubo building fun.)

 

Anyway, the Roubo in the guild is a great skill builder. Plus Marc is an entertaining and informative teacher. When you finish (if you finish in my case) you'll have a hybrid workbench that will not only last a lifetime, but be equally at home with hand tools as well as power tools.

 

Just my 2 cents.

I am in no way a hand tool enthusiast. Never have, and never will be. I will utilize a few hand tools here and there like a block plane, chisels, dovetail saw, etc. But that is about my extent of that.

 

Famous last words.  :)  I definitely favor power tools over hand tools, but do a lot of hand tool work as well.  The Chisels and Block plane were my down fall.  While I mill nearly all my boards on the jointer and planer, there have been times I have pulled out the #5 and #7 to flatten one side of the board as it was too wide for the jointer, and then surfaced it with the planer.  I would strongly recommend a traditional bench.  If I had to do it over, that is what I would do.

Never say never.  

 

My policy with hand tools aways say never. :) Never owned a hand plane never will. I do admit to owning one chisel / can opener. :)

My policy with hand tools aways say never. :) Never owned a hand plane never will. I do admit to owning one chisel / can opener. :)

 

I couldn't imagine woodworking without a plane.  Though, I've never been one to discount something I've never tried either.  Being open to all experiences is what makes life great. 

My policy with hand tools aways say never. :) Never owned a hand plane never will. I do admit to owning one chisel / can opener. :)

 

PB you are a legend, BTW you need special permission to post in the hand tools section you woodworking cyborg.    :D

 

pghmyn, 

 

To echo almost everyone else a traditional bench is a great plan. I would like to add a vote for a British style bench. Easy to make, used by joiners in the UK for hundreds of years. All I have to do is finish my daughters bedroom decoration and built in wardrobe and mine will begin. I have the wood staring at me every day reminding me to start. 

My policy with hand tools aways say never. :) Never owned a hand plane never will. I do admit to owning one chisel / can opener. :)

seems odd but hey different strokes for different folks

  • Author

The only other hand tool I can see in my future that would be the most useful to me is a jack plane. Shooting miters, and using the technique to flatten boards wider than my jointer.

 

I've seen an overwhelming response toward the traditional bench. But, can I make a roubo with a removable top? I really like this design by Rob Cosman:

  • Author

Wow, what a fantastic piece of work! I would be afraid to use it though. 

I could do without the birdseye and mahogany, though. Although, if I was to add some accents, it would be walnut.

Wow, what a fantastic piece of work! I would be afraid to use it though. 

 

Lol.. I built a bench in my shop that's not nearly as nice as this one and I've always got it covered with something cause I don't want to give it it's first beauty mark!

I could do without the birdseye and mahogany, though. Although, if I was to add some accents, it would be walnut.

 

If I were to add some accents it would be saw marks, hammer blows, screw holes  :D.

 

On the removable Roubo bench top you could do I guess, How often would you want to break it down? I think that kind of design is best permanently together? Eric1978 might be able to give you the heads up on how the "Guild Roubo" is attached to the legs. FWIW Eric & Vics Roubo builds are the nicest benches I've seen  For me they get the balance right between awesome finish and letting the bench take a dink or two.

I have to agree, if you can only have one bench, go for the more traditional joinery bench. The torsion box is a great flat surface for assembly and such, but won't stand up to the abuse a slab can take. As a cost effective alternative, I am considering a variation of this design:

http://lumberjocks.com/shipwright/blog/series/5516

Seems like it would be very flat and stable, but able to take some abuse. The vise design is really cool, too.

  • Author

If I were to add some accents it would be saw marks, hammer blows, screw holes  :D.

 

On the removable Roubo bench top you could do I guess, How often would you want to break it down? I think that kind of design is best permanently together? Eric1978 might be able to give you the heads up on how the "Guild Roubo" is attached to the legs. FWIW Eric & Vics Roubo builds are the nicest benches I've seen  For me they get the balance right between awesome finish and letting the bench take a dink or two.

I only need to break it down once. When I am no longer living at my current location. I am in a basement and if I build a bench with the legs permanently attached, there would be no way of taking the bench to my new location.

Both slabs on the split-top Roubo come off easily.  They rest on tenons atop the legs and are secured to the stretchers from beneath with lag bolts (Spax screws, whatever).  If you go the Benchcrafted route, it comes with the knock-down hardware, and Marc covers how to install it (though his was permanently assembled, as was mine).  So you can take that particular bench apart into pretty small pieces if you really need to.  Only downside to the split-top Roubo: it ain't cheap.  But that's truly the only downside.

  • Author

Both slabs on the split-top Roubo come off easily.  They rest on tenons atop the legs and are secured to the stretchers from beneath with lag bolts (Spax screws, whatever).  If you go the Benchcrafted route, it comes with the knock-down hardware, and Marc covers how to install it (though his was permanently assembled, as was mine).  So you can take that particular bench apart into pretty small pieces if you really need to.  Only downside to the split-top Roubo: it ain't cheap.  But that's truly the only downside.

I do not plan on buying the Benchcrafted hardware, just way out of my price range. I was looking at the Veritas hardware, but that is expensive too. Maybe I start with the more important/useful vise and install the other later?

 

I really like the idea of a split top bench. How wide are each of your top components?

 

edit: Graham, I will be using Maple for my bench. $4.00/BF for 12/4 and $2.80/BF for 8/4. It is pretty cheap for me.

You could get a copy of Schwarz's book to get an overview, pros/cons, etc of many bench designs...

Yeah Graham, you could certainly use cheaper lumber, and like pg said, the hardware is pretty pricey by itself...I think it's like $800 or more, can't remember exactly...I tried not to think about it too much.  I spent more on the hardware than I did on my lumber.  But you could definitely modify the basic form of the split-top and just use different hardware.  I'm pretty sure a few guys did exactly that.  It's no longer gonna be a Cadillac with the cheaper hardware, but it would still be an awesome bench.

 

The top is 24" deep, so subtract the gap-stop...I think each slab was something like 11&1/8 or 11&1/4.  

I do not plan on buying the Benchcrafted hardware, just way out of my price range. I was looking at the Veritas hardware, but that is expensive too. Maybe I start with the more important/useful vise and install the other later?

 

I really like the idea of a split top bench. How wide are each of your top components?

 

edit: Graham, I will be using Maple for my bench. $4.00/BF for 12/4 and $2.80/BF for 8/4. It is pretty cheap for me.

You lucky devil!

 

"$800" that's a nice price tag! Get's what you pay for.

 

If you want an overview on some alternative ideas take a look at http://www.theenglishwoodworker.com/shop/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=81&zenid=f20o9tbn312qon22rs8cu21q72 . The owner of the site (Richard) is a really helpful chap. I liked the look of his traditional face. I dropped him an e-mail and he's going to give me sizing and details so I can make my own. He even did this knowing I was not going to use his hardware. Legend.

I needed a workebench, and I built this solid guy. Now, it's not nearly as nice a roubo, but it is solid, flat, and heavy.

The base is solid maple and the joinery is pinned half laps. The vice is from lee valley, and I put a dog hole in the jaw. The top is 3 layers of laminated MDF with maple edging. The finish is water based polycrylic.post-6372-0-95323200-1372812852_thumb.jppost-6372-0-81237000-1372812896_thumb.jp

Someday I will build an "eric1978" bench, but for now this one is great!

  • Author

Yeah Graham, you could certainly use cheaper lumber, and like pg said, the hardware is pretty pricey by itself...I think it's like $800 or more, can't remember exactly...I tried not to think about it too much.  I spent more on the hardware than I did on my lumber.  But you could definitely modify the basic form of the split-top and just use different hardware.  I'm pretty sure a few guys did exactly that.  It's no longer gonna be a Cadillac with the cheaper hardware, but it would still be an awesome bench.

 

The top is 24" deep, so subtract the gap-stop...I think each slab was something like 11&1/8 or 11&1/4.  

 

$800.00 is just a little out of my price range for my bench ;) I have a budget to abide by ride now, and I plan on spending the money on a spectacular foundation before I add any top notch doo-dads.

 

Do you have it so the expansion and contraction of the top moves toward the center?

 

You lucky devil!

 

"$800" that's a nice price tag! Get's what you pay for.

 

If you want an overview on some alternative ideas take a look at http://www.theenglishwoodworker.com/shop/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=81&zenid=f20o9tbn312qon22rs8cu21q72 . The owner of the site (Richard) is a really helpful chap. I liked the look of his traditional face. I dropped him an e-mail and he's going to give me sizing and details so I can make my own. He even did this knowing I was not going to use his hardware. Legend.

I will be looking at the webpage tonight. Bookmarked it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.