Recommended Posts

Posted

I finally got this DVD from Lie-Nielsen with Chris Schwarz. He goes into great detail about which tools you need to do the type of work you want to do.

Chris also does a great job explaining how to use the tools for the greatest efficiency. To my surprise, Chris also touches on what we are calling the hybrid approach. He does a great job of comparing the powered tool vs the hand tool to describe which tool is the Coarse Medium and Fine tool.

In short if you don't have this DVD, you may be missing some key points on how to become a more efficient woodworker.

Posted

A more detailed review would give away most of what the DVD discusses.

I wasn't trying to be vague, but I didn't want to give away the point of his message. A spoiler, if you will :)

I will say that he uses the #5 for coarse, the #7 for medium and a #4 smoother for the fine when discussing the face of the board. He chooses these planes based on the size of the material he is working. And he does a good job of explaining why he chose these planes.

He also covers joinery, edge work and curves.

The DVD is very straightforward and any woodworker will find something new. I really wish I had this DVD when I started.

  • Like 1
Posted

==> A more detailed review would give away most of what the DVD discusses.

+1

 

I'll just add that Chris covers prepping the irons to accomplish each task and discusses camber at some length.

 

 

To further define Chris's terminology: coarse = rapid stock removal; medium = flattening / joinery prep; fine = prep for finishing.

 

Note: He admits that in his shop, coarse is primarily stationary power tools...  He doesn't use a scrub plane...

Posted

A more detailed review would give away most of what the DVD discusses.

I wasn't trying to be vague, but I didn't want to give away the point of his message. A spoiler, if you will :)

I will say that he uses the #5 for coarse, the #7 for medium and a #4 smoother for the fine when discussing the face of the board. He chooses these planes based on the size of the material he is working. And he does a good job of explaining why he chose these planes.

He also covers joinery, edge work and curves.

The DVD is very straightforward and any woodworker will find something new. I really wish I had this DVD when I started.

 

Rumbled  :)! I was only angling toward a review similar to the review shows shown on the woodwhisperer site. 

 

It sound like older reference books made up to date and accessible by a very accomplished woodworker/writer. The edge work sounds interesting, rebates/rabbets, grooves and molding/moulding I assume? Dang, I need to wait for your article don't I :). Looking forward to it. 

  • Like 1
Posted

Camber or is it chamber, my English is bad, or is it two separate things?

Camber :) Chris also speaks about using the scrub plane to reduce the width of the board.

Posted

Rumbled :)! I was only angling toward a review similar to the review shows shown on the woodwhisperer site.

It sound like older reference books made up to date and accessible by a very accomplished woodworker/writer. The edge work sounds interesting, rebates/rabbets, grooves and molding/moulding I assume? Dang, I need to wait for your article don't I :). Looking forward to it.

If you have a specific issue/question I'd answer it for you!

Posted

Thanks Mel,

 

Nothing springs to mind but I look forward to the review. The Schwarz makes a very compelling, interesting and informative narrative in the material I have sampled so far. I'm sure this will be no exception.

Posted

Could even be a cool article for James with his e-mag.

 

 

 You Know I am going to like that idea! Actually we could even turn it into a blog post and Melvin could write the article! This would be a great way for me to introduce him as a contributor. 

  • Like 1
Posted

 You Know I am going to like that idea! Actually we could even turn it into a blog post and Melvin could write the article! This would be a great way for me to introduce him as a contributor. 

 

Well, it seems like I have my first assignment :)

  • Like 1
  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

Anyone have this DVD and feel like they've got all they can from it?

I'm thinking about buying it, but it seems Amazon doesn't ship this particular thing internationally (global village my a****).

 

Couldn't find any on ebay.

 

Cheers.

Posted

Keep in mind that DVDs are "zoned".  That's probably part of the reason Amazon won't ship it.  The good news is that while the DVD player you bought at the store might not play it, the DVD software in your computer probably will.

Posted

==> That's probably part of the reason Amazon won't ship it.

 

Then there's NTSC/PAL -- not sure how that's handled these days -- will a PAL player auto-convert an NTSC/DV/D1 source?  Since it's an up-rev, I don't see why not... but then again, I've never lived in a PAL country...

Posted

Yeah there's no real issues with pal/NTSC these days. Either the player will convert or just about every tv I've seen for the past five years or more will accept either anyway. But the computer will play it anyway.

Posted

==> Yeah there's no real issues with pal/NTSC these days.

 

thanks...  always wondered about that...  Since everything is shifting to 16:9, I figured that the problem would solve itself over time...

Posted

I think the most important key to this DVD is the principle that 90% of the work is done with the coarse tool (whatever you use), 8% of the work is done with medium, and the fine is the last 2%.  This is at the heart of efficient working and when working by hand you need all the efficiency you can get unless you are in it for the cardiovascular work out.

Posted

==> I think the most important key to this DVD is the principle that 90% of the work is done with the coarse tool (whatever you use), 8% of the work is done with medium, and the fine is the last 2%.  

 

And the setups that get you there...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 50 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined