Recommended Posts

Posted

I searched and found a post on this topic that was a little old, but I would like to get some fresh opinions.

 

I guess this is really a two part question.

 

1) I have made integral MT's for practice several times, but I must say it is not something I really enjoy nor am I that great at it.  Do you see value in continuing to practice this before I start a real project with M/T's or should I just go the loose tenon route which appeals to me a little more.

 

2) Understanding that I just do this for a hobby, and while I could afford a Domino, there are so many other tools I would rather have.  What are the best tools/jigs for loose tenon joinery?  I have looked at the Mortise pal which is probably at the top of my list right now.  Before I make the leap and buy it, I would like more options and opinions.  Are there other good options I should consider or should I just suck it up and practice and really learn to do integral M/T before starting with loose tenons?  

 

 

While I don't use dowels all that often nor do they really appeal to me, it would be nice to have that option as well.   Since the mortise pal also does dowels, that is a big plus.  I have also read other places of people using the Dowelmax or the Jessem dowel jig for loose tenons, so I would love to hear thoughts on that if you have done it.  

 

Josh

Posted

Check out the leigh FMT, it's a pretty impressive machine. It does integral tenons, but could easy do loose tenons as well.

I think the quickest, easiest, and most accurate option for most situations is the domino. I don't have one yet, but will be getting one in the future at some point.

There are lots of other joinery options, depending upon your project. Book shelves can be attached to a case with dados, pocket screws, sliding dovetails, or a host of other options. While a M and T is often the BEST option, it is not the only option of many furniture projects.

I typically use integral tenons, cut flat on the TS with a dado stack. I also have a delta tenoning jig, but I don't use it that often just because I find it easier to do the dado thing. I cut my mortises with a HCM.

I wanted to learn more about hand tools last year, so I took a 3 hour lesson from tom fidgen on cutting tenons and mortises by hand. I learned a lot, and tried it a few times in projects. It takes practise, but is very satisfying and enjoyable work, much more so that running a TS. Tom can do ridiculously accurate and fast, which comes with his level of skill and practise. I would encourage you to explore this option if you have the desire.

As a bonus, learning to cut m and t by hand also comes with "mini lessons" in cutting to a line, how to start a cut with a handsaw, body position, etc.

Posted

Hi Josh, I use dowels some but mostly shop made loose tenons. Most of the time I use a 3/8" up cut bit for the mortise and have a lot of tenon stock already made up. I like to keep several feet on hand so it it at the same moisture content as the project material. It is easy to make the tenon stock, just get the thickness correct and then use a beading bit or round over bit to do both edges. Maybe not as quick as the Domino but certainly cheaper. As fas as I know there is no difference in the strength.

BRuce

Posted

I use dominos all the time and work great. Also I built three 5' wide gates and made my own floating tenons and also worked fantastic. If I would show the joinery, then of course the M&T is important.

 

the gates and doors I built with floating tenons are still in one piece after 5 years of the weather abuse (For glue I used West Systems epoxy).

 

Good luck with your decision. Any decision you come up with will be the right one. It is all about getting the work done and enjoying the process.p

Posted

All you really need is a router with a guide bushing, a good spiral cutting bit, and some scrap wood.

 

What you do is make a template that the guide bushing slides back and forth in (see the attached image). Then all you have to do is clamp, glue, or tape the template to the work piece and route out all the waste material. To make the actual tenon, just take a board of the appropriate width and thickness and round over the edges. The main benefit of doing it this way, is that you can make the mortise and tenon any size you want. 

 

 

 

post-818-0-41965900-1382288446_thumb.jpg

Posted

I have the Leigh FMT  http://www.leighjigs.com/fmt.php  It does a very good job. It does angled joints if needed. I suggest you watch the videos and think about the pieces you may want to make in the future as it is not cheap.  A plunge router that does not rack on the shafts is necessary.  However, it has not had much as much use as initially since I got a Domino - mostly for projects my wife wants yesterday.  The Domino is certainly faster. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I have the Leigh FMT  http://www.leighjigs.com/fmt.php  It does a very good job. It does angled joints if needed. I suggest you watch the videos and think about the pieces you may want to make in the future as it is not cheap.  A plunge router that does not rack on the shafts is necessary.  However, it has not had much as much use as initially since I got a Domino - mostly for projects my wife wants yesterday.  The Domino is certainly faster. 

Wow that thing is expensive.  I would probably just go for the domino.  

 

The Jessem zip mill looks pretty cool too. Thanks for the options guys.

 

 

All you really need is a router with a guide bushing, a good spiral cutting bit, and some scrap wood.

 

What you do is make a template that the guide bushing slides back and forth in (see the attached image). Then all you have to do is clamp, glue, or tape the template to the work piece and route out all the waste material. To make the actual tenon, just take a board of the appropriate width and thickness and round over the edges. The main benefit of doing it this way, is that you can make the mortise and tenon any size you want. 

 

I may try this route for awhile though and see how it works.  How do you guys make your loose tenons? With a round over bit?  Or is it easier to just buy them?

 

To be honest I feel like I really need to spend some time learning integral tenons, so I will probably do that as well before I buy a jig or a domino.

  • Like 1
Posted

I built a slot mortiser from plans purchased from Greg Paolini from his web site.

http://www.gregorypaolini.com/?page_id=96

This jig works quite well. I completed my new kitchen this year and all joinery on door rails and stiles used loose tenons and all mortises were cut using this setup. It could not have gone any faster. It is the closest I will have to a multirouter for some time. This was my second jig for mortising. The first jig requires the router to be plunged and moved across the workpiece. This works much better.

Posted

I may try this route for awhile though and see how it works.  How do you guys make your loose tenons? With a round over bit?  Or is it easier to just buy them?

 

To be honest I feel like I really need to spend some time learning integral tenons, so I will probably do that as well before I buy a jig or a domino.

I make my own with a round over bit, that way I can control the wood species and the exact size.

Posted

I have the Leigh FMT  http://www.leighjigs.com/fmt.php  It does a very good job. It does angled joints if needed. I suggest you watch the videos and think about the pieces you may want to make in the future as it is not cheap.  A plunge router that does not rack on the shafts is necessary.  However, it has not had much as much use as initially since I got a Domino - mostly for projects my wife wants yesterday.  The Domino is certainly faster. 

I just pulled the trigger on the super fmt, accessories and a router.  I’ll let you all know if works for me.  I thought about the domino but in the end I chose the fmt. -- Miles

Posted

Hope you enjoy it.  What router did you buy?  It's a very good tool.  Did you buy the full bit and guide set or just the basic that comes with it.  Looking forward to see your first project with it.  

Posted

I make my own Domino stock in different widths to fit the different settings available. They only sell the narrow width. I use my Domino to cut slots for bolt adjustments in jigs . It is so much faster and more accurate than my high end Lamello biscuit joiner.

Posted

Hope you enjoy it.  What router did you buy?  It's a very good tool.  Did you buy the full bit and guide set or just the basic that comes with it.  Looking forward to see your first project with it.  

My third Porter-Cable Porter-Cable 893PK and all the accessory (guide seets) and carbide bits.  Anybody want a jet bench top mortising machine?

-- Miles

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 56 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined