Pwalter5110 Posted November 5, 2013 Report Posted November 5, 2013 With Christmas around the corner my wife wanted a couple of ideas on what to get me. I told her a Festool Domino, and she laughed as if I was joking I started looking at a couple hand tools that I would like to start using more and one would be a dovetail saw. Veritas has a couple dovetail saws but I don't know which would be better for a guy that has never really cut anything with a handsaw before. They have 14,16, and 20 teeth per inch. Just knowing how I am, I am sure whichever saw I get will be used a lot more than just with dovetails. For example, notching shelves around table legs. I know you SHOULD use 2 different saws, but the reality of it is, at least for now, I don't see the purpose. Again, I have never cut anything with a handsaw and I don't fully understand why one saw can't do more than one job. So any help would be appreciated. Quote
Chuck Melton Posted November 5, 2013 Report Posted November 5, 2013 Pat, This article on the Bad Axe website explains saw tooth geometry in great detail http://www.badaxetoolworks.com/Filing.htm I'd also consider a set of veritas carcass saws. I bough some a few weeks ago and they are quickly replacing power tools for a lot of tasks. I found with a little practice I was able to get great cuts in less time and with less hassle than using power tools. The basic answer to your tpi question is the the 20 tpi will cut slower but smoother than the 14 tpi. It will also be very hard to sharpen. The 16 tpi is for crosscutting and will be harder to cut dovetails with as you really should use a rip filed saw. I actually have a 14 tpi veritas dovetail saw being delivered tomorrow. I agonized a bit on the tpi and settles on the 14 tpi first as I don't see myself doing extra fine work anytime soon that would really benefit from the 20 tpi. Quote
Pwalter5110 Posted November 5, 2013 Author Report Posted November 5, 2013 Chuck, thanks for the info. Unfortunately the link doesn't work. Possibly because I am on a mobile device. Do you think a carcass saw would be a better all around saw to start with? Will it do a good enough job cutting dovetails as well as more general tasks? Quote
geadon Posted November 5, 2013 Report Posted November 5, 2013 Paul Sellers wrote about this last December: My recommendation for anyone needing a first bench saw to get started with is the Veritas 14 teeth per inch dovetail saw. This saw will cut dovetails as well as tenon shoulders and tenon cheeks. Though it is not designed for large work, I regularly cut 4″ wide tenons with no problems. This would be a good saw as it is sharpened and ready to go with rip-cut pattern that readily crosscuts with a light hand just as well. http://paulsellers.com/2012/12/questions-answered-which-handsaw-for-a-beginner/ Last year (before reading Paul's advice) I bought the 14 tpi dovetail saw for myself. I have found it satisfactory, both for rip-cuts and crosscuts, though I must admit that this is the first and only quality handsaw that I have owned. I recently wanted to make a cut that exceeded the depth capacity of the saw, so I started with the dovetail saw and completed the cut with a coping saw, but this is a case where I would have found a carcass saw useful. I imagine that a dedicated crosscut saw would be better for crosscuts, but I believe that skill is limiting me more than equipment at this point. And, as you suggest, working with separate cross/rip saws seems like a hassle compared to working with one general purpose saw -- for me there would need to be a clear and fairly significant advantage to justify the expense and hassle of working with two separate saws. Quote
PaulMarcel Posted November 5, 2013 Report Posted November 5, 2013 I got the set of three Veritas saws when they were released so there was a promo pricing that made it a bit like getting one saw free at today's prices. The 14 tpi is great for most dovetail work. The 20 tpi is nicer in thinner stock. I usually make drawer sides thin so I use the 20 tpi most. If it's a Christmas gift, maybe get a hybrid dovetailer from Bad Axe. Really nice saw. The Veritas is pretty hard to beat in the bang-for-buck department. A Bad Axe hybrid saw: 1 Quote
ChrisG Posted November 5, 2013 Report Posted November 5, 2013 Anything 14 to 16 will work very well for the vast majority of dovetail work. For the Veritas saws you'll want 14tpi rip...the 20tpi rip would probably frustratingly slow for all but the thinnest drawer sides and the 16tpi is a crosscut...you want rip for dovetailing. If most of your dovetailing will be 3/8" to 3/4" stock then 14tpi is definitely the way to go. As far as why one saw can't do the job...well it can. But if you are cutting crossgrain with a rip the cut won't be as clean, because the geometry of rip filed teeth doesn't cleanly sever the wood fibers. For a small toothed rip saw like a dovetail saw you actually can do a pretty clean job crosscutting though, just using a slightly lighter touch, and if need a really clean cut you can just score the fiber with a knife, which you would want to do regardless of the what saw you are using if you are making a really precision cut. Quote
Jfitz Posted November 5, 2013 Report Posted November 5, 2013 I have the 20 ppi which I like a lot, but it does cut pretty slowly. As Paul-Marcel said, it's useful for thinner stock. I plan on adding the 14ppi at some point for working with thicker (3/4"+) boards. Quote
RenaissanceWW Posted November 5, 2013 Report Posted November 5, 2013 I have used a lot of dovetail saws and invariably I end up back on the coarser pitch versions. Dovetails are not marquetry and we don't need to be nearly as accurate so a 20 ppi saw is just annoying in anything greater than 3/8" thick. For this reason (and a few others) my Gramercy saw sits in a drawer. 14 ppi strikes a good balance of fine finish and ease of sharpening. Finer pitched saws are just plain hard on the eyes to sharpen. If going for a first and possibly single saw (for a while at least) I would go with a carcass saw. Yes the tooth geometry will produce a cleaner cut across the grain and blah blah blah, but the biggest issue you will find helpful is the longer plate. Many makers insist on making their dovetail saw dinky little sub 10" plates. Bad Axe started making a longer plate saw and it makes a world of difference. Shortly after this I bought a sash saw to replace my carcass saw because the extra length of the plate was a revelation. It is something to think about but to the original question, I wouldn't go finer than 14 ppi Quote
ChrisG Posted November 5, 2013 Report Posted November 5, 2013 I agree with what Shannon (RenaissanceWW) says about going with a longer saw. I recommended the 14ppi dovetail saw based on the options you listed but really, for a first saw I would reccomend the 12tpi rip carcass saw. The extra length is helpful and 11" is by no means huge. My first dovetails saw was the LN version of that saw...( an 11" 15ppi rip carcass) and I never regretted having the extra size. Today my main dovetail saw is a 10" and I like 10" a lot but anything smaller is too dinky. The 11" carcass will work great for dovetails (12tpi/13ppi is still fine enough) and it will be far more versatile. Quote
Pwalter5110 Posted November 5, 2013 Author Report Posted November 5, 2013 Thanks for the info everyone! I was actually looking at the veritas carcass saws, and I think if I get both the rip, and crosscut carcass saw I think they should hold me over for most tasks. Quote
pghmyn Posted November 5, 2013 Report Posted November 5, 2013 Thanks for the info everyone! I was actually looking at the veritas carcass saws, and I think if I get both the rip, and crosscut carcass saw I think they should hold me over for most tasks.Nothing wrong with that you will love the veritas saw. 1 Quote
Trip Posted November 5, 2013 Report Posted November 5, 2013 LN has their progressive pitch dovetail saw... It's gotten quite a bit of buzz... I've tried it (actually, i think i may even own one) and it's certainly a good way to get up to speed on hand-cut dovetails... Lot's of positive reviews out there... Chris Schwarz had some very positive things to say about it in his blog --- I think that's why I may have bought it... http://www.wkfinetools.com/contrib/cschwarz/z_art/dovsaws/dovsaws-1.asp Quote
ChrisG Posted November 6, 2013 Report Posted November 6, 2013 I think if I get both the rip, and crosscut carcass saw I think they should hold me over for most tasks. I think this would be a wise purchasing decision. Quote
Pwalter5110 Posted November 6, 2013 Author Report Posted November 6, 2013 Well the order was placed . My wife told me I will be getting them before Christmas bc I have to make an end table that matches a coffee table I made her a few yrs ago! I should put this in another post, but everyone has been so helpful already I will put it here. I already have hand planes, an older stanley No.7, an older craftsman jack plane and a lower quality groz smoother. If I were to upgrade one I feel like I should upgrade the smooth plane. Should I go with a low angle smoother? Also, would something like a No.4 work on a shooting board, or should I use a larger plane? I am trying to incorporate hand tools into woodworking to raise the quality of my projects. Quote
G S Haydon Posted November 6, 2013 Report Posted November 6, 2013 Your on the right track Pat. A #4 will work on a shooting board just fine but most prefer a #5. A LA smoother is great but I would still lean to a normal bailey style smoother. Quote
ChrisG Posted November 6, 2013 Report Posted November 6, 2013 A 4 will work for shooting small pieces ( heck a block plane can work well for shooting), but I find the vintage no. 4s get challenging to shoot with as the wood gets hard and wider. A 5 or 6 will work a good bit better. For a Low-angle plane even a 4 size will shoot quite well. Not just because the cutting angle is lower, but mostly because they are much easier to grip on there sides which makes it easier to apply force. Its tough to beat a low-angle/bevel up plane for shooting. If you want a plane that will do double duty as a high quality smoother and an excellent shooter a low angle smoother is probably the way to go. Personally I do the vast majority of my smoothing with vintage 4s, and use a Low angle jack for shooting, as the extra size weight makes it even easier to use for plowing through end grain. Again though, that's not a need. I used to use a no. 6 for shooting which also worked quite well, but again I find the LA/BU planes much easier to grip on there sides than bevel down' planes. For the needs you describe a low angle smoother with a 2nd blade would probably work quite well Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.