nateswoodworks Posted November 14, 2013 Report Posted November 14, 2013 I received my new old #8 today and since Lee Valleys free shipping runs out tomorrow I am planning on ordering a new iron for it. All my others have Hock irons and I have been very happy but with the new steel from LV I was considering going that way this time. I know there was a lot of hype when they first came out but I was wondering what people think now that they have put them through the test for a bit? Also, do any of you sharpen yours with oils stones, if so how does it com pair to 01? My #5 came with a A2 iron and honestly I don't like it, it takes quite a bit longer to sharpen, it does last longer but I dread it when it needs to be honed (I did recently get a new soft Arkansas so hopefully that will help). Thanks for any info!! Nate Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted November 14, 2013 Report Posted November 14, 2013 Derek Cohen has a comparison that might help you - http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/FourChiselSteelsCompared.html Quote
nateswoodworks Posted November 14, 2013 Author Report Posted November 14, 2013 Derek Cohen has a comparison that might help you - http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/FourChiselSteelsCompared.html Thanks, I had forgotten about that post. My main concern is sharpening on my oilstones. I know early on Schwarz stated that your can sharpen it on oilstones but I recall hearing that it was a P.I.T.A. a couple of times as well. Quote
derekcohen Posted November 14, 2013 Report Posted November 14, 2013 Hi Nate I have not tried oilstones and so cannot comment on their viability with PM-V11. What I do know is that an oilstone dressed regularly with a diamond stone does cut better than one not so dressed. An oilstone should cope with PM-V11 as well as it would cope with A2. If you have experience of A2, then you can work it out for yourself. Regards from Perth Derek Quote
ChrisG Posted November 14, 2013 Report Posted November 14, 2013 This came up on my other forum so I started experimenting. Here's what I found/said: "Initial impressions (and these are just impressions after an hour or so of screwing around). Yes, you can sharpen PMV11 on oil stones (as well as A2). The key to best results (no suprise here) is to keep the amount of steel you work small (so keep your hollow grind fresh or your secondary bevel small). Fresh off the grinder, my vintage Pike #1 arky raised a burr on PMV11 just fine, but on the 2nd honing after just a bit of bevel growth (honing out of hollow) it got too slow for my taste. SO I then tried the med india. The medium india cut the PMV11 nearly as well as it cuts 01 honing on a hollow grind that's flats have started to grow a bit, but is far from being honed out completely. Surgical black arkansas seemed to follow up the washita just fine, but I felt like the final edge off of the surgical black on PMV11 was not as good as the edge it gives to vintage high carbon steel or 01. Honing compound cut the PMV11 as well as it cuts anything else. Put a polish on the edge w/o issue in no time at all and gave a great overall final result The other thing I felt with PMV11 on oil stones is that it actually honed a little easier than A2 because it didn't hang on to its burr as long as A2 does. Finishing up A2 on natural stones can sometimes be frustrating because the burr can have a tendancy just to flip back and forth rather than get honed off. Intial conclusion. PMV11 can do just fine with oil stones natural or synthetic, but best results are achieved by: 1) keeping the amount of steel you work small 2) Using synthetic india (AlOx) stones to raise a burr as an initial step 3) finishing with synthetic honing compound for the best edge. Overall, so far I found that achieved the best combination of speed and edge, by starting with something coarse (med india), then following with a medium bridging stone (soft ark or washita), before finishing with honing compound. You can start with the medium stone (washita) but results slowed down to quickly OR if you start with and india you can skip the medium stone if you are willing to raise to tertiary bevel (3rd additional micro bevel of final step, but the 2 stones plus compound seemed best overall in this case. Again, just some initial thoughts after a bit of experimentation. PMV11 actually did a lot better than I expected it would on oil stones...certainly as good as A2, maybe better if the ease of burr removal is real and not just in my head. (I reserve the right to retract all of this if I change my mind after further experimentation...again those were just my initial impressions after about an hour of messing with PMV11 on oil stones. Also, while modern steel like PMV11 can do just fine on oil stones it is my personal belief that the oil stone user [natural arkky stones in particular] pair best with high quality vintage high carbon steel and thus if one is to mainly use such stones, they would likely be happiest if most of their tools are vintage)" And some additional experimenting/comments: "Did a bit more playing this morning and tonight with the PMV11 and oils stones. Nothing really different to report. Certainly very honable on both natural arks and synthetic AlOx stones. Certainly slower than vintage or 01, but certainly doesn't seem slower than A2. And again, I think its little easier than A2 because of the burr thing. Cutting speed compared A2 is probably about that same. If you keep your bevels small or your hollow fresh there's very little loss of speed compared to simpler steel on oilstones. As the area being honed grows the speed definitly slows more in comparison to vintage or 01. That's all there really is to is. I'd still rather hone anything other than vintage steel on water stones (including modern 01), but do it right and you can certainly hone PMV11 on oil stone without problem. No time to do a Derek-esc photographic write-up, but its probably not necessary. If you are comfortable honing A2 on oils stones you will certainly be comfortable honing PMV11 on oils stones, no question of that in my mind. If you don't like honing A2 on oil stones, than PMV11 may frustrate you as well, but there is chance it may do better for you in terms of honing...and if nothing else you'll need to hone it less often." 2 Quote
nateswoodworks Posted November 14, 2013 Author Report Posted November 14, 2013 Thanks Chris! I found a post on another site a bit ago that says basically the same thing, I'm thinking I will stick with O1 Hock. Thanks again. Nate Quote
rodger. Posted November 14, 2013 Report Posted November 14, 2013 I have some V11 blades, and I quite like them. Too fidgen also did an article on the new steel, so check it out on theunpluggedwoodshop.com Quote
ChrisG Posted November 15, 2013 Report Posted November 15, 2013 I have some V11 blades, and I quite like them. Too fidgen also did an article on the new steel, so check it out on theunpluggedwoodshop.com Yeah, I love V11...I left that part out of my "honing it on oil stone thing", but Derek has pretty much covered it. It really is excellent steel...takes a very fine edge very very easily...just not as easily on oil stones, and holds it very well. It the only western steel I know of that can take and hold an edge as finely as quality Japanese white steel. Very nice stuff....hold exceptionally well at 25 degrees too....like most steels though below 25 is crap shoot for anything other than the lightest work. I haven't and won't run out and replace my 01 or A2 blades with it, but any future plane/blade purchase from LV I make will definitely continue to be V11. I was somewhat skeptical about it at first, but it really is very very nice steel. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.