Recommended Posts

Posted

I have an order for 6 exact reproduction, hand made, 18th Century mantels with extensive reeding/beading (depending on who you are talking to, it's called one or the other).  The beaded panels are long strips made up of a bunch of smaller pieces joined together.  The beads need to mate perfectly where the pieces meet, so I decided it was a good time to make a shooting board, and get a shooting plane.

 

I ordered the Lee Valley, simply because it's $165 cheaper than the LN.  I'm not sure if the tilting handle will suit me, but if it doesn't, I'll send it back.  I don't like A2 (not an option with LV anyway), haven't had a PM-v11, and O1 is an old friend that I know will do what I want it to, so that's what I ordered.

 

I'll let you know when I get it going, but there are other projects ahead of this one, so it will probably be a while before we even think about starting this one.  I'll play with the plane a bit soon after it comes, see if I like it, and post here.

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

Tom, did you get this/put it to use yet? 

 

I've read plenty of reviews of hobbiests/weekend warriors loving it so I know its a sweet tool, but I'd be really curios to hear the value (in all its iterations) of a tool like this from someone who is making their living working wood day in day out.

 

Lord knows knows Graham wouldn't be caught dead with a tool like this ;) so I'll have to rely on your perspective.

 

Honestly, my LA jack meets all my shooting needs so its unlikely I'll pick one of these up, but I'm always curious to here different perspectives on nice tools.

Posted

Ha Haa, LMAO Chris  :lol:. I truly would Chris, the ball breaker here in the UK is the darn price (damn import taxes). For instance a bronze LN #4 would cost me $500+/- (£307). If I had the funds I truly would. The new quality price point option I have is http://www.workshopheaven.com/tools/Quangsheng_Planes.html which are essentially wood river. I pressed the button on a #4 just after my Birthday in January. What I appreciated most was the lack of refining, I just needed to tidy the cap iron. It was the fastest packaging to work experience I have ever had. Nicely weighted too.

 

Tom has a review of the plane in the reviews section, needles to say he likes it :-).

Posted

Cool. thanks for the headsup. I'll check out his review.  I have a WR 6 and have had it for probably 4 years. It probably my most heavily used tool (just becasue I love 6s).  Its a great tool.

 

Hell, even I haven't spent that kinda money on standard bench planes, because well, as much as I'd like to have hand LN/LV 4 or an LN 7, and as nice as they are to use, there is nothing they can do that I can't do with my vintage planes. I'll probably pick some up some day but they are not a priority.

 

I HAVE spent a boat load of dough on joinery planes/specialty planes. I consider my LA jack a specialty plane btw, becasue I mostly use it for shooting.  In fact the only premium tool I have that I use as a regular bench plane is my LV Small BU Smoother, which I use well, as a smoother...I heart that plane.  Its a No. 3 minus the bloody knuckles.

 

and, man if I had to pay your prices you better believe that most my specialty/joinery planes would be vintage records and not LVs.

Posted

I've read that too, but I've never noticed it to be an issue...or really noticed it at all. Though  being 6'2",  I have somewhat large hands/long fingers.  Not huge...but probably a little bigger than average.

 

What I can tell you about the WR and its brothers is that if it ever falls off your bench and hits concrete it will be just fine. Mine has hit the concrete twice. Once when I first got it and a second time a couple weeks ago.  Last time it chipped the horn a little, but a little rasp work on the tote and a couple swipes of sandpaper to knock of any potential burrs from the impact and it was good to go.

 

I always kinda wanted and LN/LV 6, but at the same time I give the 6 such heavy use its kinda nice to have plane that I don't feel bad about abusing a little.

  • Like 1
Posted

For me at least tools are there to be used, the dents and dings are a good thing in my book :).

 

Indeed.  I'm actually always kinda relieved when I put the first ding in a new tool.  When its a brand new expensive tool the first ding always hurts. BUT after that first ding than I can stop worrying about it and just enjoy using it :)

  • Like 1
Posted

I have an order for 6 exact reproduction, hand made, 18th Century mantels with extensive reeding/beading (depending on who you are talking to, it's called one or the other).  The beaded panels are long strips made up of a bunch of smaller pieces joined together.  The beads need to mate perfectly where the pieces meet, so I decided it was a good time to make a shooting board, and get a shooting plane.

 

I ordered the Lee Valley, simply because it's $165 cheaper than the LN.  I'm not sure if the tilting handle will suit me, but if it doesn't, I'll send it back.  I don't like A2 (not an option with LV anyway), haven't had a PM-v11, and O1 is an old friend that I know will do what I want it to, so that's what I ordered.

 

I'll let you know when I get it going, but there are other projects ahead of this one, so it will probably be a while before we even think about starting this one.  I'll play with the plane a bit soon after it comes, see if I like it, and post here.

Congrats Tom. You have (inadvertently) purchased the better of the two shooting planes. I have both, and either would satisfy anyone, but the Veritas just shades the Lie Nielson #51. The reason for this is that the Veritas is a BU design and this is capable of both a lower angle cut, and the configuration is gentler on the blade, which then lasts longer. The second advantage of the Veritas is the PM-V11 steel. I must tell you that O1 steel is poor on a shooting plane in comparison. The PM-V11 steel holds an edge several times as long. Get the new steel!

These shooting planes do require a specific design in the way of a shooting board. In particular, a side fence is necessary to guide the plane as the handle is at the rear.

I have a full review here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/LVShootingPlane.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Posted

Thanks Derek.  That's the best side by side test I've seen for the different steels.  I'll order the new steel iron iron too, on my next LV order.  My main reason for buying this is fitting many small pieces of 1/4" thick Heart Pine with reeding, where adjoining pieces need to have the same reveal between beads as the reeds in the individual pieces.  I'm sure I will enjoy using it for other things too.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 55 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined