Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Planes and chisels oh me oh my

Featured Replies

I have seriously been debating on the better way to start my starter set. I figure, correct me if this is stinking thinking, I can put a lot of money into planes and chisels or a lot of money into a sharpening system. Figure sharpening will have to take priority on this.

Going with water stones, low grit diamond etc. figure this and low cost planes from kobalt and maybe 60 or 70 dollars for a bench chisel set from woodriver will be between 300 and 400.

On the other hand could buy everything needed for sharpening over the next two months, then one high quality plane or chisel one month at a time.

Want to start learning and using these as soon as possible though. Anyway ant advice will be much appreciated thanks.

A lot of people get by just using sandpaper to sharpen. Pretty cheap. Obviously, it won't be as sharp as diamond stones or water stones, but it should get you by until you gather up your plane collection and can save for something a little better for sharpening.

That's just one point of view though. I'm sure an argument can't be made the other way.

I'll try Pat :)

I'd say that if you don't have the planes you need to get the job done efficiently, then it doesn't matter how sharp they are. Ya know, if you only have one plane, it can be the sharpest ever and you'll still be frustrated.

Here's my suggestion. I'd get the combo Japanese stone from woodcraft for around $30. I have one and I still use it. Yes, there are other much better stones out there. But it gets the job done, and will also give you a good feel for the stone before buying a dedicated stone for $100 or more. And I never feel as though I need different stones until I read these forums. I always put some in my amazon cart, go back to the shop and use mine and buy something else later.

Pat made a good point. I used sandpaper for awhile before I bought that stone. Do yourself a favor and pick up a sharpening jig. The ones for around $15 are good. The Veritas jig is nice and is on my list, but I get by without it just fine.

Agree with Mel..  I have the inexpensive stone that gets me by.  I used a piece of granite and sandpaper for a while as well.  I do have the Veritas sharpening jig but, the ones Mel suggests will work just fine.  

 

The sharpening system is much easier (cheaper) to upgrade a little at a time.  

The most important factor that exceeds all other priorities:

 

No matter what media you purchase to sharpen, no matter what chisels or planes you purchase....... the most important factor is knowing how to use the tools properly and how to sharpen. The basics are so important with hand tools, that if you dont know and apply them you will quickly become frustrated with your results, putting a bad taste in your mouth as far as hand tools go. I bought cheap chisels and a block in the beginning. I did not know how to properly use, or how to tune or sharpen. I learned on these tools as soon as I developed the hunger for hand tools. Now I buy the best, but more important than the quality is having your go-to sharpening method down to a science, as well as your fundamentals. Without either, you will butcher your work with even a Lie Nielsen plane. I sharpen with  Ohishi 1000, 3000 and 10000 water stones. I lap my stones with a DMT dia-flat plate. I keep my stones wet and flat. I do my initial sharpening with a veritas jig to establish square cutting edges. From then on, I sharpen my primaries free hand on some of my blades, and micros with the jig to get consistent registration. Now that my system is down to a science, I can take my stanley fat max chisels, put an edge on them and chop dovetails. I can also use my Ace hardware dovetail saw to make the cuts. Not as much fun as using the LN saw, but you get the point :)

That book has left an impression hasn't it Mel. I have not read it yet but I'm guessing 0% bs and preaching 100% Essential Woodworking? What does the author suggest?

  • Author

I am taking a class on planes at Woodcraft soon. Basically I simply do not have room for a planer and drum sander in my shop space. Even if I did still think a person can get a more polished result with hand planes than a power planer. What I'm looking for are planes to. smooth rough cut hardwood, smooth out bandsaw chatter from redrawing and so on.

So basically I need advice on the following:

Which hand planes do I need to fill the rolls of a planer, joiner and drum sander?

What should I look for on E-Bay as concerns name brand, year and so on?

If I do go LIe-Nelson or another premium manufacturer who is the absolute best and buying one a month which ones first and next and so forth.

Are the less expensive planes really bad and what makes Lie.-Nelson worth so much more than say the Kolbalt planes?

Thanks for the advice.

  • Popular Post

Taking classes at Woodcraft: Good.

Buying Woodcraft planes and chisels: Bad.

 

They'll do the job, but without any luxury.  Tell me what kind of vehicle you drive and I'll tell you what kind of planes to buy.  If you have a 2014 FX4 with heated leather seats and those auto roll-out running boards...you ain't gonna be happy with the Wood Rivers.  If you drive a 1982 Dodge with a lean and mismatched wheels...go for it.

 

Your core planes for taking a rough board to finish-ready are the jack plane (#5), jointer plane (#7 or #8), and the smoother (#4 or #4 1/2).  If you're working with really gnarly boards and you're truly intending to do ALL your rough milling with handplanes, you'll probably want a scrub plane, too.  And if you're truly intending to do ALL your rough milling with handplanes, you definitely don't want Wood River planes.

 

Which to buy first?  Depends on what you're trying to do.  If you're looking to turn rough into ready, you pretty much need all three I listed.  Kind of like how a powered jointer is pretty much useless without a planer and vice-versa.  That aside, I'd go #5, #4, then #7 or #8.  You'll also want a low angle plane for end grain, a block plane, router plane, shoulder plane, and a rabbet plane for joinery work.  That would be my list of essential planes.  Beyond that it just depends on how crazy you are and how many hours of your life you plan to waste doing things like a caveman that a machine could do in a fraction of the time.

 

Oh, and to answer your original question...I agree with the guys...spend your money on quality tools first, and buy some cheap stones to get you by for now.  The double-sided Nortons are another economical option.

 

Ideally you'd buy the quality stones up front, too...so you don't have to buy stones twice, which you eventually will.  Think long-term.  You need a tool?  Buy it once.  It will last you forever if it's not crap.

 

If you just can't stand the smell of multi-hundred-dollar pieces of metal, don't buy new garbage...find old Stanleys and Records at flea shops and garage sales and learn how to refurbish them.  It's hard to find good deals on good old planes on ebay anymore because of their resurging popularity.  Graham can give you pointers for both finding the good antique planes and how to make them new again.  Some folks dig that.  It ain't for me.

 

Very soon after I post this, someone is gonna chime in saying how he has Wood River planes and he loves them and you gotta be a moron to plunk down the change for LN or Veritas tools.  Listen to him if you want.  He may be happy with what he has because they're perfectly adequate, or it could be that he simply doesn't know the difference.  My advice would be to not take advice from someone who has never used "regular" and "premium" side-by-side.

That book has left an impression hasn't it Mel. I have not read it yet but I'm guessing 0% bs and preaching 100% Essential Woodworking? What does the author suggest?

The book is great so far. I haven't read the whole thing yet. Truth is, I don't find pleasure in reading books. My attention span is limited. They usually have a bunch of bs used as filler.

This one is to the point, and the best I've seen as a total instruction on hand tools use. I've been too busy to sit back and read it as much as I want to.

I have always gotten frustrated using average planes, old craftsman and Stanley's lower quality products. I recently spent the $ for a Veritas low angle block plane and sharpening jig. It amazes me how easy the jig makes accurate sharpening and how the quality plane creates such beautiful results with very few adjustments.

I still do the majority of my work with power tools but now I enjoy the hand tool work for finishing touches. Quality bought once will provide a lifetime of use.

I use a mixture of ceramic and diamond sharpening stones but even the wet/dry sandpaper method creates good results with a decent jig to hold the angle.

  • Popular Post

Bill, I fear you will be no further forward after the end of this thread.

 

Take a step back for a moment. Take a look at ~ERIC~'s projects here on the forum, they are awesome.

 

Look at Steve Duncan's (wdwerker), awesome.

 

Visit my website, it's half decent stuff too.

 

Fact is none of us feel limited by our tools yet we all like different Jazz.

 

On chisels dont go lower than a set of Irwin M444 blue chip.

 

Sharpening mediums, they are all good, Norton India is just fine and less than $30.00

 

On planes, even if you like the vintage vibe buy one new decent plane Wood River or better. I have 1 x UK version of the wood river in the #4, it's just fine. I'm lucky I don't get the silly wood river lever cap on my uk version, just nice and clean. Then if you want, go vintage, at least you have a bench mark to compare with.

 

On saws, hardpoint for the first. I know it's not cool but for the same reason I mention decent planes a disposable hardpoint saw will show you what sharp is.

 

After that, make some stuff. Don't be worried about not having the right tools. We all buy stuff we end up passing on, most what chimes with us is not always what others would think "best". Love the tools but dont get obsessed or bogged down, get into the woodworking :)

I'll help make it a little easier.  Get these chisels.  I do this for a living, and these are my go-to chisels.  They take an edge as good as almost anything else, and hold it as good as any.  If you look in Fine Woodworking magazines at the articles where you see people making things, you see the blue handles in the pictures.

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/121259426812?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649

 

There is absolutely no need to spend several hundred dollars on a plane.  At least, not to start with. I use old Stanley and Record planes almost every day.

 

Sharpening is the single most important thing in working with hand woodworking tools.  Get a guide. Nobody can get the sharpest possible edge quicker by hand than with a guide, and no beginner will ever be able to get a maximally sharpened edge by hand.

 

  Waterstones are the quickest at getting a sharp edge, and oil stones won't work good enough on harder steels like A2, but Oil Stones don't require flattening the stones anything like as often as water stones. If you decide on waterstones, you absolutely have to have some system to flatten them with.   If you are using the Marples chisels and Stanley or Record irons, oilstones work just fine.  They just take 5 times as many strokes as waterstones.  I don't recommend Diamond stones to start with, because you will not develop the feel you will with water or oilstones, and this feel becomes an important thing later on when you do hone by hand.

 

Your abiltiy to get to the point of doing good work will depend directly on how sharp you are able to get a cutting edge.  Read everything you can find on the subject, but you can find what you need to know right here on these Forums.  Then make your decision.  Also realize that sharp enough is dangerously sharp.  Dangerous as in it will put you in the ER in a heartbeat.  You do get used to handling them though.  

Hi Bill, welcome to the forum. Perhaps an ideal time to folks to add responses to

 

I would, but I’m not allowed to. It’s probably for the best.  ^_^

I use several old Stanley planes that were less than $40 each and love them.  If you go that way, make sure the soles are reasonably flat (usually not a problem on #4s and shorter planes, but can be on longer planes,) and purchase aftermarket irons (LV, Hock, etc.).  The less expensive newer planes will be more frustrating than useful.  You also don't need a full set of chisel to do great work. Start with a 1/4 and 1/2 good quality chisels (Marples are fine) and learn to sharpen them.  I have tried a lot of different media from sand paper to diamond and while some are better that others, the method (how you hold the tool, how you move through the grits, understanding the "wire edge", sharpening angles, that type of stuff) of sharpening is most important part and that can be learned on almost any media. So put your money in better quality tools.

  • Author

Thanks for all the advice. Thinking about buying one quality plane for now and a set of the marple chisels and work from there. Most of my projects are small (scrollsaw, toys, and such), so I'm not thinking about prepping a mature cottonwood tree or even a large trunk or limb.

I know drum sanders and power planers can turn an all day job into a 10 min job. Me, I prefer the journey. This is a hobby and I'm not in a hurry so why rush through some of the more enjoyable parts of the journey. Doing some of the prep work by hand gives me more of a sense of accomplishment. Anyway beside Lie-Nielson who makes premier planes?

Again thanks for all the good advice.

Veritas  planes from Lee Valley are another fine choice. For smaller work and more general usage, I would recommend a low angel block plane.  The are just so dang handy.  If you want a larger plane you might consider a low angel jack form LN or LV, but first I would get a block plane (60-1/2). 

One other thing.  The Marples chisels are now made by Irwin.  I have both and prefer the actual Maples brand.  Ebay or flea markets should be good sources.  I fine a lot of decent chisels (and other tools) at estate sales,.....oop, I might have just let the cat out of the bag....

To be honest, the sharpening vs. tools question seems to me to be a false premise.   I think you can get set up with 3 stones (1000/4000/8000), a jig, and various cheap accessories that will do a fine job for less than the price of a single premium hand plane.   The higher quality stones probably need some developed skill to really appreciate, or last longer, or cut faster, or some combination of the three.

 

The 'tools first' route has no bottom (DAMHIKT).   That said, I agree with the comments about getting a single good plane, a #4 or a Low Angle Jack would be my choice, simply so that you can have an immediate sense of how it is supposed to work.   I tend to buy Veritas low angle, and go with classic Stanleys for the bevel up planes, but a L-N #4 is a lifetime tool that will never be replaced.

Well said.  When I was first staring in 1973, I had some hand-me-down tools.  The first investment I made was a set of Smith's Arkansas stones and an Eclipse.  It was probably luck that I went that way as much as any other reason, but it turned out to be a good move.  I think Smith's was the first company that answered my inquiry letter-no internet then.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.