wtnhighlander Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Why? Why not get the use out a tool you paid money for? Jointers are great at long grain miters, rabbets, tapering table legs or any other sort of long grain taper. Why? Can't speak for everyone, but my little 6" jointer is gonna choke on a 1/4" pass, even in soft woods. I do all the operations you mentioned, just in smaller chunks. Have to keep in mind, tools marketed for the hobbyist are often undersized / underpowered compared to professional equivalents. Trust me, if I had space & budget for a battleship sized 8" jointer, I'd have one! Quote
dwacker Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Why? Can't speak for everyone, but my little 6" jointer is gonna choke on a 1/4" pass, even in soft woods. I do all the operations you mentioned, just in smaller chunks. Have to keep in mind, tools marketed for the hobbyist are often undersized / underpowered compared to professional equivalents. Trust me, if I had space & budget for a battleship sized 8" jointer, I'd have one! 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Heh! That thing is twice as long, and probably 4 x more powerful than my benchtop Delta. Not that I wouldn't love to own it...He who dies with the most tools ... leaves a great estate sale. Quote
nod Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 these threads and comments are great. Of course now I have the new TS, I'm going to need a jointer. oh brother (smacks hand to forehead). gonna need a bigger garage... btw-thanks PB for that video. Always wondered how else you could do that. very cool Quote
Txtrnr Posted February 24, 2014 Author Report Posted February 24, 2014 I appreciate all the responses. I'm still trying to figure out what is the best way for me. I can afford the PM54 HH 6". If I step up to an 8" then money becomes an issue, not to mention more electrical work. I just installed 22 plugs in shop but it's all 110. The other thing I'm up against is this a 2 car garage. The jointer will share space with TS,BS,SCMS,DP,router, two lathes and a 16-32 drum sander. Quote
Tpt life Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Choking a jointer while tapering would be an indication of dull knives or an inappropriate feed rate. You are only dealing with about two inches of cut width and will only take as thick a shaving as the speed at which you feed. Quote
pghmyn Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Choking a jointer while tapering would be an indication of dull knives or an inappropriate feed rate. You are only dealing with about two inches of cut width and will only take as thick a shaving as the speed at which you feed.Exactly. You can go from literally making saw dust, or taking a thick cut shaving like off a scrub plane in just adjusting feed rate. If you have the same delta bench too that I previously used, it is a pretty decent jointer in regards to its size. Considering it is only 30" long and light as a feather. Still achieved perfect 90 degree corners and flat faces! But step up to a long cast iron bed, 6" or 8", and you will just smile when you use the machine. My jointer is a Grizzly, and I don't know about other brands, but mine has a built in mobile base. So, in your garage you can put it wherever you want in seconds. If you put in those outlets, running a 240v line is nothing special. You won't regret a bigger jointer. Quote
Trip Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 ==>If you put in those outlets, running a 240v line is nothing special. You won't regret a bigger jointer. You won't regret 240v either... As for a 2-car garage, many folks either started in or continue to turn-out great projects in a garage. Equipment mobility is one of the secrets to success. Using mobile bases is going to make your life so much easier in the long run... As for the original post, lots of folks get-by with a 6" jointer... But, 8" is really the sweet-spot for small/hobby-shop jointers if you work full-sized projects (see my previous post). In a nutshell, if it's down to $$, spend your budget on an 8" non-HH jointer... There are numerous threads on the pros/cons of HH, but at the end-of-the-day, HH is a 'nice-to-have', not a must have. Yea, it's great having clean stock post-jointing, but the odds are you're going to have to scrape/plane/sand anyway -- so having clean stock so far upstream may not save that much work in the long run. Quote
sjeff70 Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 The only old jointer Ive used was a northfield and it was dovetail ways. Everything else has been more modern olivers and PM's we had carpet planers in the plant so the northfield really just collected dust. I see. The more modern Oliver is pretty sweet and deservingly expensive. The new Oliver & PM are both made overseas, but Oliver uses Baldor motors and their 10" is just a little more than the 8" PM. Why don't we see more comparisons and interest between the two? Is Baldor still in the U.S.? Quote
Guest Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 ==>If you put in those outlets, running a 240v line is nothing special. You won't regret a bigger jointer. You won't regret 240v either... As for a 2-car garage, many folks either started in or continue to turn-out great projects in a garage. Equipment mobility is one of the secrets to success. Using mobile bases is going to make your life so much easier in the long run... As for the original post, lots of folks get-by with a 6" jointer... But, 8" is really the sweet-spot for small/hobby-shop jointers if you work full-sized projects (see my previous post). In a nutshell, if it's down to $$, spend your budget on an 8" non-HH jointer... There are numerous threads on the pros/cons of HH, but at the end-of-the-day, HH is a 'nice-to-have', not a must have. Yea, it's great having clean stock post-jointing, but the odds are you're going to have to scrape/plane/sand anyway -- so having clean stock so far upstream may not save that much work in the long run. Generally I agree with this but I bed length is also important. I bought a 6" PM because it has long beds. I am pretty sure the 8" models from Grizz and others at the same price have shorter beds. if you are edge jointing long boards for a table top or things like that, the long beds are really nice. Yes, I would like to face joint wider boards. But to me the difference between 6" and 8" is firewood and I do not fret about it. If I am buying a 12" or 14l" board that I need flattened, whoever I am buying from is usually happy to flatten it get the sale so not really an issue. In short, for me I'd rather spend on a well-built, accurate, and long bed 6" machine than compromise on those aspects to get a slightly wider capacity. Quote
Eric. Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 If you have the Powermatic 54A, your bed is about 10" shorter than the Grizzly 0490 (8" jointer) and you paid more. I have a Powermatic machine too so I've been down that road...you DO overpay for the Powermatic name. Yes it's slightly higher quality than Grizzly, but it's significantly higher in price. IMO you don't get what you pay for when buying Powermatic. For a one trick pony like a jointer, I think capacity is more important than quality. Once you get it set up and dialed in, it hardly matters what name is on the cabinet as long as that head keeps spinning. Quote
Guest Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 If you have the Powermatic 54A, your bed is about 10" shorter than the Grizzly 0490 (8" jointer) and you paid more. I have a Powermatic machine too so I've been down that road...you DO overpay for the Powermatic name. Yes it's slightly higher quality than Grizzly, but it's significantly higher in price. IMO you don't get what you pay for when buying Powermatic. For a one trick pony like a jointer, I think capacity is more important than quality. Once you get it set up and dialed in, it hardly matters what name is on the cabinet as long as that head keeps spinning. Ha, you are right, just double checked. I don't want to start a PM/Grizzly debate (although on another thread a bunch of guys were saying their Grizz fence won't stay square long enough to pass a board through). But at least I did not pay more than the 0490. I got the PM when they do their 15% off sale. So it was about $850 and shipping was free. Grizzly charges $150 and you have to schedule delivery from a freight carrier who may or may not show up within their delivery window or on their delivery day (this I know from experience, the carrier they used to deliver my planer, SAIA, missed 3 delivery windows on 3 different days then grizzly wanted to charge me for redelivery. All for a lunch box planer they could have shipped UPS). But you are right, the G0490 definitely beats on size and capacity. I guess I was just pissy about my planer experience when I bought the jointer so went PM instead. Quote
Eric. Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 I'm one of the guys with the fence that won't (or wouldn't) stay put. But I finally just put some ass into tightening it down and now it's fine. If I used my jointer for anything other than flattening, then that would be a huge PITA...but I don't, so I don't care. It's dead at 90* now, and I don't touch it. I live in MO so there's a Grizzly showroom within driving distance. I have buddies down in Springfield so if I plan to buy a machine I'll just go hang out for a weekend and pick it up while I'm there, so no delivery charge for me. Of course I do have to pay tax, though, so it's kind of a wash. But I've had nothing but good customer service experiences with Grizzly. Some QC issues, but they've always taken care of it. I don't wanna get into another brand debate either...but I just can't help saying it whenever it comes up...Powermatic is overpriced and overrated. And I own Powermatic, so I can say it. I'm also a few months away from buying one of their 14" bandsaws, too...so even though I beat them up, I still buy their stuff. I just firmly believe that Grizzly gives you the best bang for your hobbyist buck. You cannot beat their cost/value ratio. It ain't the prettiest, it ain't the best, but you get the most machine for your money, hands down. Quote
pghmyn Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 I just firmly believe that Grizzly gives you the best bang for your hobbyist buck. I can attest to that one. If I was making a living from my tools, it would be Powermatic (or better) all the way. --- EDIT: I guess I should ask, what size lumber do you typically use? Do you have access to a good lumber yard with wider stock without a huge premium? By wider, I mean anywhere between 8-10" as the common size. Or, do you plan on really only buying lumber 5-6" in width for the majority of your projects? I know my place has a sweet spot for 7-9" in the species and thickness that I regularly buy. But, there is equal amounts of 4-5" stock and 10" + stock ready for purchase, too. I prefer the wider boards, myself. When I made my desk table top I found a 11" wide x 120" 5/4 board. I cut it in half and glued it together. One glue line for a 19" wide table top instead of 3 or 4. Have you looked at JET? I see the 8" jointer with straight knives for $1,400 as well. Same price as the 6" Powermatic with helical head. The beds are shorter, which could be a big turn off. I can't say anything for the jointer, because I don't own anything JET. Particle Board has a full shop of Powermatic, including his 12" jointer (I think that is the size). He's been in the business a long time, and he obviously chose that brand and size for a reason. But, I paraphrase something he has said. He depends on his tools to start up at the beginning of the day and not stop until the day is over. Will your tools go through that punishment? I like my Grizzly tools, and so does ERIC. We have our quarrels, but nothing that couldn't be dealt with in a timely fashion. I know I've seen someone on here with a full shop of JET tools. And from the pictures he posted of a project, looked like the results were top notch. In the end, go with your gut feeling. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.