Txtrnr Posted February 22, 2014 Report Posted February 22, 2014 Im in the market for a jointer. I was in my local woodcraft the other day talking to one of the employees. He told me getting anything bigger than 6" was a waste of money because I should be ripping everything down to 3-4" and glue back together. Is this sound advice? I'm looking at the powermatic 54HH 6" jointer. Quote
Trip Posted February 22, 2014 Report Posted February 22, 2014 First, Welcome to WTO... This is a wide topic and you’ll plenty of responses… Some even useful... Basically, your projects and workflow determine the tools that you’ll need… For some projects, a narrow jointer is fine while other projects will benefit from more capacity. For many, the 6/8 long-bed is the sweet spot for ‘full-sized’ furniture. However, some woodworkers get into bandsawn veneers where, a wider-capacity jointer comes in handy. The salesman’s observation is valid for some types of projects and workflow. However, making a blanket statement like that without knowing what projects you plan is not really helping the consumer… Personally, I like to saw my own veneers, so I have a wide jointer. If I didn’t have that interest, I could probably get by with a long-bed 8-inch just fine. When I got started, I purchased a six-inch jointer and dumped it within six months – for my first batch of projects (read as honey-do list), a 6-inch jointer was too limiting. Note: my first projects were: dining room table, a complete bedroom set (bed, bedside tables + high and low dressers), a bathroom vanity and set of built-in bookcases... The 6" jointer just wasn't working out... Take a good long think about your first five or ten projects – that should help you determine your need… Good luck. Quote
tim0625 Posted February 22, 2014 Report Posted February 22, 2014 First post!! Welcome! Can't help you. I have a Craftsman 6" (2 squirrels and a card scraper) jointer. It's good for the little stuff I do. I often just use my router table for jointing. Quote
Eric. Posted February 22, 2014 Report Posted February 22, 2014 I think the advice he gave you is ridiculous and downright wrong. If you're gluing up a 16" panel, would you rather use three or four boards or two? I know what my answer is. Less work, fewer glue lines. The most logical justification I've heard for buying an 8" jointer is that, because most FAS lumber comes in widths of 6-8", you'll create a lot more waste with a 6" jointer. And a 6" creates a lot more work, too. Quote
pghmyn Posted February 22, 2014 Report Posted February 22, 2014 That's probably the worst advice I've ever heard. If I was forced to rip everything down to 3-4" I would hate glue ups. I have an 8" jointer - perfect size for me. I can joint 10" wide boards easily with a little practice on cleaning up the over hang. That extra 2" really does help. In world of jointers, the bigger the better. In my opinion. Quote
rodger. Posted February 22, 2014 Report Posted February 22, 2014 +1 on Eric and SAMs advice. Another bonus to a larger jointer is longer infeed and out feed tables, which makes jointing longer boards possible. Quote
STL Woodguy Posted February 22, 2014 Report Posted February 22, 2014 Agreed, awful advice. Like Eric already said, most lumber I've used is between 6-8" and I very rarely had to cut boards down. Never regretted going 8", but I probably would have regretted going 6". Quote
..Kev Posted February 22, 2014 Report Posted February 22, 2014 All good advice here! In the end, it depends on your budget and needs. I have a 6" PM and am very happy with it, no regrets. I just couldn't justify the extra money to go to 8". That was my thinking, yours may be different. Quote
Trip Posted February 22, 2014 Report Posted February 22, 2014 ==>54HH 6" jointer ==>depends on your budget Ahhh, budget... Helical heads are a bit of a 'nice to have' on a jointer -- generally, more useful on a planer (but that's a different discussion). Point is, if the 6" is driven by $$, I'd trade the HH for the 8" long-bed... Don't get me wrong, I'm a fan of Byrd's products -- and it's nice to have a Shelix on a jointer. But the 8" width and a longer-bed may be more use in the long run (you can always retrofit a Shelix at a later date). Helical heads are all the rage at the moment, but there's been lot's of great furniture made before the helical head became popular.... Quote
knotscott Posted February 22, 2014 Report Posted February 22, 2014 I'd buy the biggest jointer I can afford and have room for. Not every sales person finished at the top of their class! Quote
schr00 Posted February 23, 2014 Report Posted February 23, 2014 I would go with an 8" if you can afford it. I have a 6" and I'm getting ready to move up to an 8" The 6" does a nice job but I waste wood since many boards are at 6-8". If you want a decent used 6" let me know I'm in Charlotte Quote
wtnhighlander Posted February 23, 2014 Report Posted February 23, 2014 I have a 6", and find it to be a limitation in many ways. plus, I really hate putting a glue line in a nice wide board with pretty grain. I say go for the 8" if budget allows.He who dies with the most tools ... leaves a great estate sale. Quote
jdbrown1998 Posted February 23, 2014 Report Posted February 23, 2014 I am currently saving for an 8" jointer. I am hoping to find one on craigs list for a reasonable price but if not...I will probably go with a Grizzly HH cutter 8". If it is used I would be willing to pay around $600 for it (depending on model and that is assuming straight blades) and then I would upgrade the cutter with an after market like SHELIX. That then brings me right back into the same range as you would pay for the brand new Grizzly so it would need to be what I would consider a top 2-3 brands to go used. Good luck and let us know how it turns out. Quote
dwacker Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Length is a big issue to prevent fall off fall off is even worse with a helical because you usually can't get the warp out in a single pass. I would not worry about a helical I took mine off as they cut depth was to limited. The nice thing about a wide jointer is you can shear cut figured wood and get the same help with tear out as a helical but even cleaner. 1 Quote
Dan S Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 I would not worry about a helical I took mine off as they cut depth was to limited.huh? I have never heard of this being a problem. How much are you taking off in one pass? Quote
dwacker Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 huh? I have never heard of this being a problem. How much are you taking off in one pass? Depends on how screwy the wood is sometimes 1/4". For miters or tapers I may cut off 3/4" just depends on the job. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Depends on how screwy the wood is sometimes 1/4". For miters or tapers I may cut off 3/4" just depends on the job. That is a big bite. I doubt any of us non-commercial guys would ever dream of taking that much in one pass. Quote
Dan S Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Depends on how screwy the wood is sometimes 1/4". For miters or tapers I may cut off 3/4" just depends on the job.At that depth of cut, I assume we are talking native hardwoods, and not very wide?He told me getting anything bigger than 6" was a waste of money because I should be ripping everything down to 3-4" and glue back together.That's horrible advise, as it depends on what your making, what your wood supplier carries and what species you are working with. I work a lot of Bubinga and Jatoba, and very rarely do I come home with boards that are under 10" wide. Quote
dwacker Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 That is a big bite. I doubt any of us non-commercial guys would ever dream of taking that much in one pass. Why? Why not get the use out a tool you paid money for? Jointers are great at long grain miters, rabbets, tapering table legs or any other sort of long grain taper. I just made a lamp with a tapered quadrilinear post 6 ft long with a 1" per side taper. Thats a 1/2" deep cut rather than dink around with a 6ft long table saw tapering sled for something that shouldn't take more than a minute or two. Search tapering on a jointer there is a video somewhere on youtube with the explanation and IIRC the guy was using a 6" steel city jointer. You can cut a rabbet in the long grain edge of any board many times faster and easier than you could even install a router bit. Cutting long grain miters and jointing in one pass is much more accurate and faster than your table saw. Im sure with a little thought most folks could come up with even more uses for a jointer. It has nothing to do with being commercial. Quote
pghmyn Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Why? Why not get the use out a tool you paid money for? Jointers are great at long grain miters, rabbets, tapering table legs or any other sort of long grain taper. I just made a lamp with a tapered quadrilinear post 6 ft long with a 1" per side taper. Thats a 1/2" deep cut rather than dink around with a 6ft long table saw tapering sled for something that shouldn't take more than a minute or two. Search tapering on a jointer there is a video somewhere on youtube with the explanation and IIRC the guy was using a 6" steel city jointer. You can cut a rabbet in the long grain edge of any board many times faster and easier than you could even install a router bit. Cutting long grain miters and jointing in one pass is much more accurate and faster than your table saw. Im sure with a little thought most folks could come up with even more uses for a jointer. It has nothing to do with being commercial.Ive used that tapering method on my 2hp 8" jointer. Straight knives. Worked beautifully and in minutes. Took off 5/8" per pass. I felt barely any resistance. Quote
Dan S Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Why? Why not get the use out a tool you paid money for? Jointers are great at long grain miters, rabbets, tapering table legs or any other sort of long grain taper. I just made a lamp with a tapered quadrilinear post 6 ft long with a 1" per side taper. Thats a 1/2" deep cut rather than dink around with a 6ft long table saw tapering sled for something that shouldn't take more than a minute or two. Search tapering on a jointer there is a video somewhere on youtube with the explanation and IIRC the guy was using a 6" steel city jointer. You can cut a rabbet in the long grain edge of any board many times faster and easier than you could even install a router bit. Cutting long grain miters and jointing in one pass is much more accurate and faster than your table saw. Im sure with a little thought most folks could come up with even more uses for a jointer. It has nothing to do with being commercial.tapering legs, and doing miters are special scenarios, so lets focus on flattening. I don't think iv'e ever taken off more than an 1/8" to get a board flat, and even then that was on 6.5' long SYP boards that I was making a benchtop out of. I wouldn't even bring home a board that required me to remove 1/4" to make it flat, as I don't want to throw that much money away in chips. Quote
sjeff70 Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 I'd like to hear what the original poster thinks so far about the responses. There're lots of people who are looking to buy old jointers that are 10 inches or more, myself included. I guess there's not a lot that can go wrong with them so people feel safe about it. But you have to at least consider the possibility of having to service one in the future. I don't have the desire to service an old machine. Consider availability of parts. It's my understanding you can't get parts or service for the Italian made Powermatic models like the FS305 that seem to be popular. I was looking at some Northfield machines but if they required service I would have to call a local company on a house call due to logistics. Byrd heads are very expensive for large jointers, but supposedly they are unnecessary as well. The older machines were made with more steel and are much heavier than the Chinese junk of today. I'm not sure how that makes a straight knife cut better than a shear cut, but I'm not real keen on having to set and sharpen knives often either. I'd like a jointer larger than 8 inches but I'm not sure I even need it if my focus is building period furniture. Is it worth the potential problems that come with older machines and what about having to do lots of sharpening and knife setting? The Byrd head is very attractive to me if only because of there being less maintenance. Quote
dwacker Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Byrd heads are very expensive for large jointers, but supposedly they are unnecessary as well. The older machines were made with more steel and are much heavier than the Chinese junk of today. I'm not sure how that makes a straight knife cut better than a shear cut, but I'm not real keen on having to set and sharpen knives often either. Sharp HSS knives always cut better than carbide short term but carbide has the ability to cut longer. If you have a wide jointer and your jointing narrower boards just pulling the tail off the fence will give you a shear but. If your cutting 8 or so inches wide on a 12 jointer there is plenty of room to make a shear cut. Shellix head are great if you need one but not a necessary item. Both have their advantages but neither is a be all head. Quote
sjeff70 Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 Sharp HSS knives always cut better than carbide short term but carbide has the ability to cut longer. If you have a wide jointer and your jointing narrower boards just pulling the tail off the fence will give you a shear but. If your cutting 8 or so inches wide on a 12 jointer there is plenty of room to make a shear cut. Shellix head are great if you need one but not a necessary item. Both have their advantages but neither is a be all head. I'm looking at the Shellix head purely for the maintenance aspect at this point. Even with one on a planer you still have to card scrape. That's how I currently see things. Did companies make the older, wider jointers with dovetailed and parallel beds? Or did they manufacture the wider ones only one way? I cannot look at a picture of a jointer and tell the difference. Quote
dwacker Posted February 24, 2014 Report Posted February 24, 2014 I'm looking at the Shellix head purely for the maintenance aspect at this point. Even with one on a planer you still have to card scrape. That's how I currently see things. Did companies make the older, wider jointers with dovetailed and parallel beds? Or did they manufacture the wider ones only one way? I cannot look at a picture of a jointer and tell the difference. The only old jointer Ive used was a northfield and it was dovetail ways. Everything else has been more modern olivers and PM's we had carpet planers in the plant so the northfield really just collected dust. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.