Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

My table saw arbor nut is now dangerous and scary

Featured Replies

My first posting here- I am stuck with an issue I am hoping you (someone) can help me with.

It started perhaps four months ago - I was thinking the arbor for my older Craftsman 10” direct drive contractor table saw (model 113.226880, if interested. The manual was printed in 1994)  was bent (blade wobble), I replaced the rotor and bearings in the motor. (FYI -You are being spared the long, but more detailed, version.)

After getting things back together so the motor runs again, I find that the arbor nut works itself very loose each time I turn the saw on/off, and it seems like it might travel completely off the arbor. Scared-y Cat here can easily visualize the blade following the nut off the arbor, hitting the floor, then rolling toward the operator faster than he can run away.

Unfortunately, I have not been sure when the arbor nut works itself loose - whether when the motor is on or once the motor is turned off. It is somewhat of a guess, but I think that if it loosens while ‘on’, then perhaps it is some form of vibration or lack of friction amongst the parts on the arbor. On the other hand, if it loosens once the saw is turned off, then I suppose the reason is that there is too much play in the nut, allowing it to rotate faster than the arbor (the arbor/rotor having more mass and the bearings having a bit more friction) Either way, once the nut loosens on the arbor, it takes more than a minute for the motor to come to a stop - without the blade mass assisting in the slow-down (?). During the 'on' phase, I am sure the nut should not be able to work its way loose, but I wonder if it can loosen during that time then allowing it to be seen unscrewing after the motor is turned off.

Tonight, I spray-painted the inside threads of the arbor nut to give it some hold, but it didn’t work.

Here is the current configuration for anyone who might be willing/able to give me some ideas on how to fix this and perhaps suggest what this new problem is caused from:

On the arbor shaft, next to the motor housing and the bearing, is a collar I put on to replace the nut that originally had been on the shaft. That nut, as well as the original rotor shaft/arbor, each had a hole where a spring pin was placed to keep the nut from traveling along the arbor shaft. I drilled down into the new arbor shaft a bit and made a new set screw that goes down into that hole and keeps the collar from traveling. I don’t ‘think’ my new collar is a problem unless I need to roughen the outside edge some….maybe?

Next on the arbor is the original blade washer (I think it can also be called a blade stabilizer). It’s about 2 and 1/8 inches in diameter. Next is the blade. I checked to make sure it is facing the correct direction and that the motor is still rotating the correct direction. Next is the other original blade washer. Finally, is that arbor nut that seems to want to abandon its post (nice pun?).

I have a few more ideas on how to tighten up the arbor nut without over-tightening it. These mostly involve throwing money at it. I am writing today in hopes of getting help from you and then throwing some smarts at it.

Option 1) Purchasing a pair of 4” Amana blade stabilizer to replace my original blade washers.

Option 2) Purchasing a 3.5” Woodtek Saw blade Stabilizer set, which looks like replacement blade washers (aka-stabilizers?).

Option 3) Purchasing a set of 5” blade stabilizers, which I think are usually used for thin kerf blades and for giving a truer cut.

Option 4) Adding an extra nut to be used like a jam nut. I suspect this possibly a really bad idea. Torqueing the two nuts together would likely take less pressure off the blade, allowing it to move more freely, right?

Option 5) Figure there might be something in the relationship between the new collar and the two washers that might allow flexing in the washers or maybe the collar side is too smooth.

You can see I am running out of ideas. I have even wondered about whether there is some sort of 5/8” nylon lock nut that I can replace my arbor nut with.

Any ideas?
Thank you in advance.
 

CJ Compton

Four Rusti Strings

 

I am at work. So I only skimmed through your question. In theory, as you turn the saw on, it should have a tightening effect on the arbor nut. Your tighten to the right while the motor spins to the left. My first thought is the diameter of the nut and arbor arnt the same. If one is just slightly larger than the other, the nut will thread on and "feel" tight, but it won't actually be.

  • Author

Pat,

 

I agree with you that the rotation of the arbor should tighten the nut. I hadn't given much thought to the arbor - nut size relationship. I am sure I am using the original nut, and I have not had any reason to think the arbor was off-sized. With that thought, I wonder now if the arbor threads could possibly have been cut too deep - but thread-cutting is not something I know much about.

 

Since you mentioned that, I thought I would tell something that happened to me years ago. I was given the idea that, to properly tighten your arbor nut, you should put the nut on part way and then turn the saw on. The motor would then tighten the nut to the blade just 'right'. I am fairly sure I won't be trying that again anytime soon. It did tighten, but the effort I had to put into getting that nut back off would hardly justify that technique's use. Such learning experiences are rarely forgotten.

 

Thank you for taking the time (at work....) to send your response. If you have any other thoughts later, I would be happy to hear. For now, I am giving thought to whether there is an issue with the arbor threads.

 

ty

CJ

 

I don't think your threads are cut too deep. I doubt the nut would thread on if it is a different thread pitch. I am thinking your arbor is something like 11mm X 1.25 and the nut is 12mm X 1.25

 

The nut will thread on. But it won't hold on tightly. 

 

BTW I am only making up the above numbers. I don't know what an arbor typically measures, but I know it is a lot more than 11 or 12 mm

This is probably a crazy idea...  When you replaced the rotor and bearings, is there any chance that you replaced the arbor with one threaded in the other direction?  That would cause the saw to loosen rather than tighten in operation.

  • Author

"Boatworks Today", Thank you for the laugh !!. BTW, which side of the nut is the stem and which is the stern?

 

Beechwood Chip, Yes, I do think I remember giving a look and some thinking about the direction the threads will pull the nut. (Also, since I don't consider myself very good with what I call 'three-dimensional thinking', I usually close my eyes when figuring the direction to turn screws that are not sitting up and open to view. That works much better for me than trusting my eyes, thinking that might make some sense to some.) However, I do plan to take a close look to see if perhaps I was sent a backwards threaded arbor - and somehow didn't figure it out..

 

Now, my good news that will hopefully last - the last few times I turned my saw on, the nut has been staying on. If my threads are backwards, then I simply have it on tight. I still plan to double-check that. Pat, after your thoughts in your first post regarding this, I checked the diameter of the arbor at the threads. My micrometer showed about one thousandth of an inch small. I suspect that is within tolerences. Having checked that, I decided to take all the parts, including the blade, off and to give them a nice solvent cleaning. I sprayed the washers, nut, blade, and arbor threads with a 50% Simple Green - 50% water solution. I used a nylon brush to clean out the treads, and also a scotch bright pad for the washers, etc. I even used the scotch brite to scrub my new collar in hopes of roughing up the zinc (I think). For now, I am cautously optimistic. Next step is to get rid of the huge wobble in my blade. I don't know the reasons for blade wobble, but from what I have read, a decent pair of blade stabilizers may fix that. If the nut cooperates, then at least I am caught up to where I was when I began this project.

 

I am hoping to soon cut wood with this table saw again. I rather miss having it running.

Thank you all.

CJ

 

WTNHighlander. I just saw your message. Is a cup washer one of the two identical washers that each sit on opposing sides of the blade? Yes, they are a shallow cup shape, and I think that is what you are talking about. I have heard that sometimes the washers that come with a saw are stamped metal and are not that great. At present, I am planning to replace them in hopes of getting rid of the wobble I mentioned above. Thank you. CJ

CJ, how comfortable and competent are you mechanically and with table saws? The layering of problems you are having even after the corrective steps you have taken raise red flags for me. Please proceed with extreme caution.

Lots of good advice here. You may also want to post at ridgidforum.com. Lots of people on there that rebuild machines and such - they should be able to offer advice as well.

  • Author

Update: It's almost midnight here. I have spent most of the day playing with this thing... That's not exactly right. Last evening, I went to Menard's and bought a dial indicator base for my MasterGase dial indicator. I wanted to check the arbor, collar, and blade for true to see if one of those was my problem. The base has given me plenty of grief today. The magnet does not even hold the indicator up, A scrap hard-drive magnet helped me get the job done.

 

What did I learn today? The collar I put on to replace the original collar is too loose to use. Wiggling it, you can even feel just a bit of play. I then took another look at the original collar that sat next to the motor. It fits perfectly. However, some difficult angle measuring showed me that the collar end was (yes, past tense) approx one full degree off of the desired 90 degrees. A bit of quick math gave me an estimate that matched my visual  back and forth wobble distance. Now, if I had read the posts in various locations of the internet that, yes, an arbor can be bent, but usually it is something else.... Again, If I had read and heeded that before this fix, then I could have saved myself a lot of grief and would be further on my ToDo list (that's the way I write it) than I currrently am.

 

I don't expect to post anything on this after this one. That original collar has already been to the Barnes #5 metal lathe and new measurements already show improvement. A fresh start tomorrow, and great expectations....

 

Lastly, since I really do like refurbishing and rebuilding various things, I do plan to check out the site that Franklin Pug sent me. It is late, but I think I will go check it out now. I am curious.

 

Thank you.

CJ

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.