Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Table saw blades??? Is the Woodworker II worth the $?

Featured Replies

I love my woodworker ii it's a massive step up from all the diablo blades I used to use. I save them for rough work MDF and crap sheet goods now. The Freud fusion is a big hit though on amazon

  • Replies 53
  • Views 15.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • It was actually an experience with a poor quality blade that prompted what some would consider an unusual obsession with saw blades... it just really ticked me off that it was no better than a stock b

  • A link belt won't take a set like a standard v-belt can, which can cause thumping and vibration.   They're very smooth running.  They can stretch a little over time, but the pressure from the outboard

  • And you might consider a thinner blade!  They work better on under powered saws.

Posted Images

==>if your getting loads of build up on blades with hardwood then its generally a heat issue causing the wood to bleed. Not enough power, feed rate, fence alignment or just a dull blade something along those lines anyways will cause wood to burn or gum up a blade. For general woodworking with hardwoods and plywood a blade should need cleaning right about the time it needs sharpening.

 

Exactly right…

 

I sharpen when I notice build-up and/or burning. I [maybe] need to clean a blade once between sharpenings – just maybe… When I notice premature buildup/burning, I check for square --- in every case, it’s down to miter-slot and/or fence alignment. On a left-tilt saw, I set 5thou cast-off (give-or-take), so blades go a long time between sharpenings and rarely (if ever) get buildup/burning until they are truly dull…

 

 

==>Is the Woodworker II worth the $?

I’m not sure folks actually get it… All blades (well, most anyway) perform AOK when new or just back from the sharpening service (assuming you use a competent one)… The value equation behind Forrest blades that they'll perform AOK longer than the rest of the field (between sharpenings) and they can be sharpened more times when they do go dull… Along with better plate stock and hand-tuning, the carbide is higher quality (C4 = stays sharper longer) and there is more of it (thicker cutters = more sharpenings)… I've got nothing against the sub $100/blade club (got plenty of them for DIY), but we're talking apples-to-oranges against Forrest and other premium blades...

... ==>Is the Woodworker II worth the $?

I’m not sure folks actually get it… All blades (well, most anyway) perform AOK when new or just back from the sharpening service (assuming you use a competent one)… The value equation behind Forrest blades that they'll perform AOK longer than the rest of the field and they can be sharpened more times… Along with better plate stock and hand-tuning, the carbide is higher quality (stays sharper longer) and there is more of it (more sharpenings)… I've got nothing against Freud (got plenty of them for DIY), but we're talking apples-to-oranges against Forrest...

 

I really can't support the superior carbide argument for Forrest compared to other premium blades.  20 years ago, they stood alot taller in the crowd, but they now  have a handful of valid competitors.  Credit Forrest for setting the bar high, but it's simply more crowded at the top than it used to be.   I'm sure Forrest uses the best grade of carbide available, and substantial pieces of it at that, but there are only a handful of carbide suppliers in the world, and the top companies all have access to the same carbide that Forrest does.  (Cermet is actually the next logical material of choice in the future, but it remains too expensive for the consumer market)  Forrest's carbide tips are ample, but the teeth on the TS2000 are notably larger (they claim 35% larger), as are the teeth on the Super General and some of the Amana Tool blades.  The last I knew Forrest sharpens to 600 grit, which is excellent, but Ridge Carbide claims to sharpen to 1200 grit, which is likely over kill, but it supports my point.  The WWII, Tenryu Gold Medal, and TS2000 are fairly similar designs and are very similar performers.  Blade wear boils down to the carbide quality, the geometry of the blade, the suitability of the blade for the task, the initial sharpness, and above all the setup of the saw, material, and user technique involved. If edge wear tests were conducted in a controlled experiment, I don't understand why Forrest would have an advantage....they would fare quite well, but I'm actually pretty sure they wouldn't have any edge life advantage over the TS2000 and Gold Medal (the Super General and Freud Fusion use a Hi-ATB grind that gives them a performance advantage, but an edge life disadvantage to some degree).  Those premium blades all definitely have an edge wear and performance advantage over lesser blades that use inferior carbide and less sophisticated design, but I'm not seeing where Forrest corners the premium market any longer. 

Pete,

I actually have that belt. It was on the saw when I got it. What are the advantages of that belt over a standard belt?

Reduced vibration and improved power transfer both.

 

==>Is the Woodworker II worth the $?

I’m not sure folks actually get it… All blades (well, most anyway) perform AOK when new or just back from the sharpening service (assuming you use a competent one)… The value equation behind Forrest blades that they'll perform AOK longer than the rest of the field (between sharpenings) and they can be sharpened more times when they do go dull… Along with better plate stock and hand-tuning, the carbide is higher quality (C4 = stays sharper longer) and there is more of it (thicker cutters = more sharpenings)… I've got nothing against the sub $100/blade club (got plenty of them for DIY), but we're talking apples-to-oranges against Forrest and other premium blades...

 

Your correct but its difficult to look at the economics involved with any cutters in a more so hobby forum. If you think about how many times you will see. " I have X router bit and its Y years old" or "I have X saw blade and its Y years old". Sharpening services that work on a contract basis will charge more for some blades than they will others and Freud is one of the more expensive. Forrest and Royce Ayr are among the lowest because they hold their edge longer. If I owned a sharpening service that charged by the blade I would probably suggest Freud. 

Most don't actually use their tools very often or use them so little the economics really never come into play. The economics are going to be all over the board. When I had my first shop with 6 guys and two sliders those two saws got a fresh blade every Monday. When I became semi retired and worked out of my home shop with a conventional saw I could get two weeks out of a Forrest or Royce Ayr blade. Since the kids took over we have 14 guys and only one slider but it doesn't get used for a whole lot and a blade will last 6 months but the spiral cutter use is through the roof we buy them 100 or so at a time. The router table will go through 60 to 70 per month. When I worked at the plant we used big people pusher saws and those got fresh blades every shift three shifts a day. It took a tool room with 5 full time guys to keep up with the cutter needs of the plant. Today just dinking around on a piece here and there I'd guess I'll go through probably one maybe two Forrest blades if I'm lucky before I crap out so the economics are pretty much meaningless. 

If I went through 60 or 70 spiral bits a month I would hate woodworking.

Reduced vibration and improved power transfer both.

 

They compress around the small drive pulley easier and thats the "magic". If your motor pulley is the larger of the two they wont do a thing. If you buy notched belts they will last longer and do the same thing for half the price.

==>if your getting loads of build up on blades with hardwood then its generally a heat issue causing the wood to bleed. Not enough power, feed rate, fence alignment or just a dull blade something along those lines anyways will cause wood to burn or gum up a blade. For general woodworking with hardwoods and plywood a blade should need cleaning right about the time it needs sharpening.

 

Exactly right…

 

I sharpen when I notice build-up and/or burning. I [maybe] need to clean a blade once between sharpenings – just maybe… When I notice premature buildup/burning, I check for square --- in every case, it’s down to miter-slot and/or fence alignment. On a left-tilt saw, I set 5thou cast-off (give-or-take), so blades go a long time between sharpenings and rarely (if ever) get buildup/burning until they are truly dull…

 

On this topic since I was one of the people asking...this inspired me to really finely check setup on my saw since I actually have accurate rules and a nice set of digital calipers.  It was about a 1/64" tighter at the back of the blade than in the front...so I was definitely pinching and causing a variety of my issues.   Total PITA trying to get it aligned on the little saw, but I got it to about 1/128" wider at the back now...maybe a bit too much out but it's not like I'm running super long pieces...and certainly an improvement from before.

On this topic since I was one of the people asking...this inspired me to really finely check setup on my saw since I actually have accurate rules and a nice set of digital calipers.  It was about a 1/64" tighter at the back of the blade than in the front...so I was definitely pinching and causing a variety of my issues.   Total PITA trying to get it aligned on the little saw, but I got it to about 1/128" wider at the back now...maybe a bit too much out but it's not like I'm running super long pieces...and certainly an improvement from before.

 

I wouldn't worry about it. It used to be standard practice to toe the fence out at the back .003 anyways. It wont have any noticeable affect.

  • Author

Thanks for such a great discussion on saw blades. I know that this topic has been done over and over in this forum, so I appreciate how many experts have participated. I ended up going with the Tenryu Gold Medal blade. It seems to be just as highly rated as the WWII, yet much more affordable. My local woodworking tool retailer had it on sale for $87. Seemed like a good deal so I got it. I haven't used it yet but when I do, I will be sure to post my opinion. Thanks again - Mike

post-3388-0-61807500-1423111678_thumb.jp

==>I ended up going with the Tenryu Gold Medal blade

Tenryu/GM’s a good blade… I’ve got friend whose advice I respect and he loves them --- but he’s got a right-tilt saw… I’ve got a left-tilt, so Tenryu is really a non-starter for me…

 

==>1/64" tighter at the back of the blade than in the front

That would do it... Get lots of burning and build-up that way...

 

==>used to be standard practice to toe the fence out at the back .003

I bounce back and forth... I usually use a bit of cast when starting a ripping session... Don't really have a justification -- just that's what I was taught...

 

==>difficult to look at the economics involved with any cutters in a more so hobby forum
So, the value equation on premium blades is there, but a hobbyist doesn’t have the duty cycle to realize it?  That’s an interesting observation…  So, if you get eight to ten sharpenings on a top-shelf blade, how many years would that take for the average hobbyist? I suppose it depends on how we define ‘average hobbyist’, but suspect you’re right… However, I plan a long career as a professional hobbyist :) But yea, the Freud may be the way to go for the occasional user…

 

==> I'm not seeing where Forrest corners the premium market any longer
There are certainly other top-shelf blades, but OP asked specifically about Forrest… I also used Forrest as a surrogate for all top-tier blades because I’ve got experience with their products.  I’ve also got some Freud and a few others… There are quite a few good blades being made today… I’ve updated the post to be a bit more inclusive…

 

==>Blade wear boils down to the carbide quality, the geometry of the blade, the suitability of the blade for the task, the initial sharpness, and above all the setup of the saw, material, and user technique involved
Agreed… Alignment, sharpness, geometry, etc are all more important than the brand – but I’m taking those out of the equation because we’re taking about like-for-like setups… I assume when we compare blade design and implementation, the saw is properly setup, the blade is sharp, the appropriate blade for the application is mounted, etc…

 

==>superior carbide argument for Forrest compared to other premium blades
I should have been clear ---- I was referring to C-4 vs C-3, not one C-4 against another… I get all my blades sharpened at Forrest (except FT, but that’s a different story) so I’m comparing like-for-like grindings. All the blades cut AOK to start, but the C-4 blades tend to retain a sharp edge longer than those with C-3… But you point is correct; comparing grades of C-4 is useless outside of industrial applications…

I will say I am quite pleased with my Diablo blade from Home Depot.

  • Author

"...I’ve got friend whose advice I respect and he loves them --- but he’s got a right-tilt saw… I’ve got a left-tilt, so Tenryu is really a non-starter for me…"

Triple H,

Maybe I'm a little slow, but is the "right-tilt vs. left-tilt" thing kind of like a Chevy-Ford thing where I should be sensing some sarcasm or is there really a difference?

==>is there really a difference?

There’s a difference – actually, several differences… There are pros/cons to each approach. Many cabinet shops have both a left-tilt and right-tilt to leverage the strengths of each design…. Now, how does this apply to Tenryu blades?

 

Google is your friend…

 

Hint: How are Tenryu blades different from Forrest blades? Both are top-shelf, cut great, have C4 cutters, etc, etc. But in what way are they different and why might the tilt of the arbor matter*?

 

 

 

 

 

*Actually, I should ask about mounting direction, but that’s too big a hint… :)

 

 

 

PS... I’m going to have to expand my $0.10 ‘easy answers found here’ beyond Eric :)

  • Author

==>is there really a difference?

There’s a difference – actually, several differences… There are pros/cons to each approach. Many cabinet shops have both a left-tilt and right-tilt to leverage the strengths of each design…. Now, how does this apply to Tenryu blades?

Google is your friend…

Hint: How are Tenryu blades different from Forrest blades? Both are top-shelf, cut great, have C4 cutters, etc, etc. But in what way are they different and why might the tilt of the arbor matter?

PS... I’m going to have to expand my $0.10 ‘easy answers found here’ beyond Eric :)

Google was definitely my friend. It has to do with the fact Tenryu blades are not a full 1/8". Therefore, on a left tilt saw, since the blade is fixed to the left side of the blade, the distance between the blade and the fence will vary if I switch between Tenryu blades and other, full kerf blades. On a right tilt saw, the right side of the blade is fixed, so the distance between the blade and the fence is fixed, regardless of which blade is in the saw.

Did I get that right?

==>distance between the blade and the fence is fixed, regardless of which blade is in the saw.

Hole in one!

 

There are some other pros/cons, but soon we'll get into angels and pins (actually, that's a pretty good analogy* -- more to do with tool scholasticism than quantifiable pros/cons)... Many cabinet shops have a dedicated right-tilt saw for dadoing...

 

You're first observation was quite on -- it's mostly a 'you say tomato' sort of thing... If you do a lot of dadoing, work mostly in narrow stock, do a lot of precision joinery, etc then some of the differences can come into play... But for 90% of workflow operations, there is little (if any) difference... Left is the current fad -- more related to preceived differences in safety profile than anything else...

 

 

*OK, for double bonus points -- what do angles/pins have in common with triangles/unicorns?

Google was definitely my friend. It has to do with the fact Tenryu blades are not a full 1/8". Therefore, on a left tilt saw, since the blade is fixed to the left side of the blade, the distance between the blade and the fence will vary if I switch between Tenryu blades and other, full kerf blades. On a right tilt saw, the right side of the blade is fixed, so the distance between the blade and the fence is fixed, regardless of which blade is in the saw.

Did I get that right?

 

DING, DING, DING, DING!  :)

 

In case it matters to you, I will also say that Forrest and Ridge Carbide are made in NJ, USA.  The Tenryu Gold Medal is made in Japan, plus they offer lesser lines that are made in China.  

==>distance between the blade and the fence is fixed, regardless of which blade is in the saw.

Hole in one!

 

There are some other pros/cons, but soon we'll get into angels and pins (actually, that's a pretty good analogy -- more to do with tool scholasticism than quantifiable pros/cons)... Many cabinet shops have a dedicated right-tilt saw for dadoing...

 

You're first observation was quite on -- it's mostly a 'you say tomato' sort of thing... If you do a lot of dadoing, work mostly in narrow stock, do a lot of precision joinery, etc then some of the differences can come into play... But for 90% of workflow operations, there is little (if any) difference... Left is the current fad -- more related to preceived differences in safety profile than anything else...

 

Just buy a Martin, tilts both directions. :)

I've stuck with Forrest for probably 25 or 30 years for good blades simply because I know what I'm getting with them, and I've

never gotten one that I didn't like.

==>Martin, tilts both directions

I've heard Martin swung both ways, but I thought he wanted to remain in the closet*…

 

 

 

 

*Apologies in advance...

Forrest and Ridge Carbide are made in NJ, USA

RC was founded by members from Jim Forrest's staff -- well, ex-members...

all add my 2 cents.

 

Freud Industrial blades are just as good as Forrest, in pretty much every respect, the Diablo & Avanti lines not so much.

I use a Freud Industrial as well.  It is a great blade.

Hey man it's woodwork'en. it's a table saw, blade spins..... spinning blade cuts wood. :P

 

I buy the 29.99 Freud Diablo 40TPI at Home Depot for cross cuts and the Freud 24tpi for rip cuts. Never an issue. If the blade gets pitch build-up. Simply spray the blade with orange cleaner and go over the "teeth" :D  with tooth brush, pitch comes right off, good to go. 

 

I had a Tenryu 40tpi thin kerf blade once. Don't buy it. The blade had too much deflection. Those blades need a stiffener. 

 

-Ace-

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.