Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Insulation in the midwest

Featured Replies

My garage is detached, no insulation, walls, etc. I'm in IL and winter sucks. I want to be able to decently heat the garage and keep coolish in the summer. I went to the energy star website and it said R40-R64 minimum for IL. Lowes site said R22, and I don't know what the US gov site says cause it was built in 2002 and won't display here at work - which, fyi, is a US government office building.

 

So this tells me someone is out of their mind. You guys with shops in similar climates, what are you running? Lowes has R30 unfaced insulation, 15" x 25' for $13 (though their website seems to indicate you have to buy 12, hopefully not.) I know if I buy that then I would need to put up the plastic for vapor barrior.

 

They don't even sell above R30, so not sure where that R40-R64 comes from.

 

Appreciate the advice.

I had closed cell foam sprayed on the walls of my basement shop.

It's so well insulated now I have no issues heating or cooling the space.

If you can afford it have it sprayed.

I'm in the Midwest as well, and get COLD winters and HOT/HUMID summers. My shop is in my garage.  It's a smallish 2 story detached that I designed and built myself.  Walls are 2x4 studs, rafters are 2x6's.  I have 2 opening skylights, 2 windows, a side door and of course the garage door, which is insulated wood.

 

I put kraft faced 3.5 inch insulation in the walls, and foil-faced 6 inch insulation in between the rafters, over formed styrofoam chases that you put in rafter bays to allow air to move from the soffet vents in the eaves to the ridge vent, and thus prevent ice dams or dry rot in the roof decking.  Shingles are composite.

 

Once the insulation was placed, I covered the walls with StorWall--a 3/4 inch thick PVC wall storage panel system, and the gabled ceiling was sheathed with 3/4 inch plywood.

 

So, with 3.5 inch insulation being R 13-15, the wall would probably be R value 15-20, when you figure the siding, underlying sheathing, insulation, and StorWall.  The roof will be R20-25, as 6 inch insulation is R19.

 

I put a Mitsubishi Mini-split system in the shop/garage.  It's incredibly quiet and amazingly efficient--SEER of 20-25, depending on which system you use.

 

With this setup The shop can very easily be maintained at 70 degrees in the summer and 65 degrees in the winter, and it has added perhaps 20 to 40 dollars to my monthly energy bills, depending on the month.

 

So, R40-64 certainly would be nice.  If you're building new construction and make your rafter bays 20 inches deep and walls 1 foot thick It'd be no problem.  But I think my case demonstrates that you can do okay with considerably less.

Insulate as much as you can afford, you won't be sorry!!!

  • Author

I'm in the Midwest as well, and get COLD winters and HOT/HUMID summers. My shop is in my garage.  It's a smallish 2 story detached that I designed and built myself.  Walls are 2x4 studs, rafters are 2x6's.  I have 2 opening skylights, 2 windows, a side door and of course the garage door, which is insulated wood.

 

I put kraft faced 3.5 inch insulation in the walls, and foil-faced 6 inch insulation in between the rafters, over formed styrofoam chases that you put in rafter bays to allow air to move from the soffet vents in the eaves to the ridge vent, and thus prevent ice dams or dry rot in the roof decking.  Shingles are composite.

 

Once the insulation was placed, I covered the walls with StorWall--a 3/4 inch thick PVC wall storage panel system, and the gabled ceiling was sheathed with 3/4 inch plywood.

 

So, with 3.5 inch insulation being R 13-15, the wall would probably be R value 15-20, when you figure the siding, underlying sheathing, insulation, and StorWall.  The roof will be R20-25, as 6 inch insulation is R19.

 

I put a Mitsubishi Mini-split system in the shop/garage.  It's incredibly quiet and amazingly efficient--SEER of 20-25, depending on which system you use.

 

With this setup The shop can very easily be maintained at 70 degrees in the summer and 65 degrees in the winter, and it has added perhaps 20 to 40 dollars to my monthly energy bills, depending on the month.

 

So, R40-64 certainly would be nice.  If you're building new construction and make your rafter bays 20 inches deep and walls 1 foot thick It'd be no problem.  But I think my case demonstrates that you can do okay with considerably less.

 

Oh I see so that 40-64 number is walls + insulation + whatever, not the actual insulation R value.

 

Right on though. I think I'm on the right path at R30, since it's only $3 more than R15 at Lowes. Errr.. and 14-15 shorter of course.

Check out estebubba's shop build thread...with his level of insulation he barely has to even heat the shop and he's been saying it's been staying cool this summer.   page he shows what he did in the walls and had a high value blown in which he talks about in the thread as well.

R-19 in the walls and R-38 in the ceiling

There's not a place in America that doesn't need insulation.  As much as you can afford!  It balances the inside and keeps the outside....out!

R-19 in the walls and R-38 in the ceiling

 

This is what I went with also.  My shop is 24 x 32 w/ 10' ceilings.  I run a 18,000 BTU window air conditioner in the summer and have a 5000 watt heater for the winter.  I can set the temps for whatever and the insulation holds it there.  I might even have a tad more than R-38 in my ceiling because I bought 10% more than i thought I needed but ended up blowing it all in.  I also sealed all gaps with expanding foam.  It's amazing how much efficiency you can lose through drafts around windows and doors.

  • Author

This is what I went with also.  My shop is 24 x 32 w/ 10' ceilings.  I run a 18,000 BTU window air conditioner in the summer and have a 5000 watt heater for the winter.  I can set the temps for whatever and the insulation holds it there.  I might even have a tad more than R-38 in my ceiling because I bought 10% more than i thought I needed but ended up blowing it all in.  I also sealed all gaps with expanding foam.  It's amazing how much efficiency you can lose through drafts around windows and doors.

 

Are you able to just go buy a can of expanding foam? Or you had a pro come in and do that?

Are you able to just go buy a can of expanding foam? Or you had a pro come in and do that?

 

Yep, your local home centers carry them.

  • Author

Well looks like I'm going to be limited as I wanted to buy materials for one wall of the garage this weekend. Looks like my studs on that back wall are 24" oc. Lowes has no insulation in stock for that, Menards has a couple but I don't think anything higher than R13 really. It's hard to tell because their site really has no concept of how to build a search engine. I should go apply to be their web guy.. does it work to say "Hey I noticed your site is a giant pile of crap, I can help.."

 

I think I'm ok with R13, but I was hoping for R19 at least.

 

I did discover the R30 that I saw at lowes is really meant to be stuff that you lay down on top of existing insulation in an attic. Probably way too thick for my 3.5" studs and at 15" unfaced, that means I'd have to cut custom widths and then do whatever you do to keep it from falling to the bottom.

 

Anyway, ripped down the 1/2" plywood that they just nailed up on the wall last night. So it's started..

The only 40-60 sidewall quotes come from ICF systems. The best windows offer about R-6. Garage doors are not much better. TIODS nailed some old recommendations when he quoted 19 walls and 38 ceiling. If you want to pay for spray foam, or if you want to sheet the exterior with rigid under the siding you can do better. If you blow the attic, you can blow to a depth of 50-60. You figure your budget and the return on investment. Air infiltration will offset some insulators value and skew the figures so just go for the best practical in your budget. Any will be a huge improvement.

Remember, any higher numbers in like media require a deeper wall. You cannot stuff R-30 fiberglass into an R-19 wall. It will over compress and destroy the insulative value.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.