zeboim Posted August 4, 2015 Report Posted August 4, 2015 Hello, new woodworker here.I bought a used corrugated jack plane and a block plane from ebay to start out. I notice that they don't cut as easily as I've seen in videos, so I tried adjusting the angle of the iron and didn't really get the results I was looking for. I checked to ensure that the bases were flat and they look good, so I'm thinking that the irons need sharpening. Now I'm not good at sharpening IN THE LEAST! I'm practicing, but I still kind of suck at it, so I was thinking of getting a lie nielsen iron and putting them into the second hand planes. It seems like a cheaper alternative to buying one of their $300 planes and this way I will have the original irons to practice sharpening that bevel. I do plan on getting a better quality plane in the distant future.So my question to the fine villagers here, are plane irons universal or are, say, lie neilsen irons proprietary to their planes?Thanks for the input,Troy Quote
Tpt life Posted August 4, 2015 Report Posted August 4, 2015 (edited) Worm can alert:1) Learn to sharpen, you will be glad you did. 2) No, not all irons are interchangeable. The adjusment mechanisms vary and planes are different widths. Make sure if you buy that the iron will match your plane. Edited August 4, 2015 by C Shaffer Quote
ponderingturtle Posted August 4, 2015 Report Posted August 4, 2015 Lee Valley and Ron Hock sell irons for stanley planes. Ron Hock will also make custom irons though they are going to be more expensive. Though a member here had a quote for one of $80 or so, so not unreasonable for one offs. Quote
zeboim Posted August 4, 2015 Author Report Posted August 4, 2015 Worm can alert:1) Learn to sharpen, you will be glad you did. 2) No, not all irons are interchangeable. The adjusment mechanisms vary and planes are different widths. Make sure if you buy that the iron will match your plane. I'm definitely going to keep the old irons and continue learning to sharpen. I just figured I could get an iron that I knew was in good quality and condition in the meantime.Lee Valley and Ron Hock sell irons for stanley planes. Ron Hock will also make custom irons though they are going to be more expensive. Though a member here had a quote for one of $80 or so, so not unreasonable for one offs.I will check them out. Thanks to both of ya Quote
RichardA Posted August 4, 2015 Report Posted August 4, 2015 They don't cut as easily as you've seen in video's! It's about sharpness, and hand tool experience.. Old planes are as good as new planes... It's about being sharp and adjustment and experience....... Quote
Brendon_t Posted August 4, 2015 Report Posted August 4, 2015 They don't cut as easily as you've seen in video's! It's about sharpness, and hand tool experience.. Old planes are as good as new planes... It's about being sharp and adjustment and experience.......yup. You can't buy a new iron every time it gets dull. You gotta get that sharpening down. A lot of old planes have very thin blades, in that case, I would say to call hock. The thick blade makes the feel much different IMO. Quote
Tpt life Posted August 4, 2015 Report Posted August 4, 2015 I went a different route. Thicker irons in old planes often require filing the mouth. I get just as good a result with a Hock chipbreaker on the old Stanley iron. It supports the edge very well on a smoother where a close breaker is desired. The only fettling it required was a let out of the cap iron retaining screw to account for the greater depth. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.