Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Tip #5 – Have a Moxon, get an Oilstone...

Featured Replies

  • Popular Post

Well it’s Friday – How about a tip or two to start the weekend!

Now, this isn’t official tip – it’s something I’ve just started doing, so it’s a work in progress --- so maybe a proto-tip?

BTW: if you don’t know what an Moxon vise is, visit Benchcrafted’s site and consider getting one... In the words of Tony the Tiger, “They’re Great!”... http://benchcrafted.com/MoxonVise.html

Now before everyone gets excited and just assumes I’ve started in on the red wine before 10:00am, yes, I’m talking about oilstones!!

Some background is certainly required: Took a carving class... The instructor talked about a, ‘continuous sharpening’ workflow... The idea is to never let your carving tools go dull (requiring you to interrupt your flow, resharpen the tool, and then pick up where you left off)... To make this happen, you keep a fine polishing stone and strop next to the carving vice... After ten minutes with a tool, you hit the bevels with a few strokes, and continue carving as if you never stopped (you typically do this on hand switches)... The honing becomes part of the carving workflow... Now, this is a bit oversimplified and periodic ‘formal re-sharpening’ still needs to happen, but incorporating honing into the carving workflow extends the period between re-sharpening sessions and you don’t have to stop in the middle of a project... That’s the point...

 

Tip5-1.jpg.27f0de68dac522987d9eec7ddc98e

 

So, a couple of weekends ago, I was preparing to dovetail a batch of drawers (nine) and stopped to consider how similar batch dovetailing is to carving: a small number of tools used for an extended period of time... I decided see if ‘continuous sharpening’ could be extended to batch dovetailing... I setup an extra-fine Arkansas stone next to the Moxon vice...  As I went along, I hit the stone after every drawer – we’re talking two or three swipes on the back and bevel (fifteen seconds max)... The idea seems to work... I was able to dovetail for an entire afternoon without stopping to pull-out the waterstones... So maybe it’s a tip??

Note: sharpening carving tools is a different animal from single-bevel bench tools, and I don’t want this proto-tip to degrade into a sharpening tutorial... So let’s just ignore strops, single-bevel vs double bevel tools, etc...

Why an oilstone? First, the edge starts sharp... And it’s frequently honed during the workflow, so you never need to remove much metal. Therefore the slow cutting speed of oilstones isn’t a factor. Second, I don’t like water around my bench – especially with a dozen measuring, marking, dovetailing, etc tools within easy spritzing distance... So an oilstone is the better solution – for me...

Note: I’ve posted about a similar process using MDF and diamond paste... I’ll keep doing this for the one-off touch-up (when an edge has started to dull and don’t want to stop what I’m doing to break-out the waterstones). In this case, the edge has become noticeably dull. Sine many of my bench tools are A2, cryo-A2, PMV-11 or D2 and I need to remove some steel, oilstones are just too slow... Diamond paste is very fast and a better fit for the job... Also, the ‘continuous sharpening’ method is incorporated into the dovetailing workflow, so it’s not a one-off... Why not use diamond paste for 'continuous sharpening'? Well, it's too expensive a consumable for ‘continuous sharpening’ -- sort of like diamond lapping film becomes for Scary Sharp...

Happy dovetailing...

 

PS, before someone asks, here is how the Moxon is held fast to the Roubo...

Tip5a-1.jpg.900813d023ae5c7e10c4fbf81d7e

BTW: The Moxon's chop is 1/4" wider than the face, so it extends below the lip of the Roubo. The chop registers the vise to the front of the bench...

 

<edit>

A few small notes:

I purchased the BC Moxon kit, but built a dovetailing vise (the platform that you clamp your tail board to) and rear support...

The BC Moxon vise is 24" wide... That's just too cumbersome for me... Mine is 16" wide...

I followed the BC recommendations for Roubo-build holdfast locations (Jameel is very smart), but added one 3/4 hole to allow two holdfasts to hold the Moxon in place. I suspect if you build the 24" Moxon, then his default Roubo holdfast plan will accommodate it...

 

Excellent ip, Trip. As usual! I think the dovetail vise extension is also a great addition. I will be adding it to my Moxon before doing another dovetail.

 

  • Author

==>dovetail vise extension

Extremely useful addition... You won't be sorry... Unless you built the 24"Moxon, then maybe you will be... :)

I get the, "Use a plane on it's side" to register the tail board... But, I want to secure it while transferring the pins. And the, "Hold the tail board and plane with your left hand while marking with your right" doesn't sit well with me... I don't want that board to move at all... Maybe it's just me...

 

  • Popular Post
1 hour ago, TerryMcK said:

Great tip Trip. Keep them coming.

I must order one of those Moxon kits.

Or you could make one from pipe clamps as I did.

102_1317.JPG

102_1319.JPG

I am curious how the "dovetail extension" works on the Moxon vise. Please explain. A picture illustrating this be very helpful.

Regards from Perth

Derek

23 minutes ago, derekcohen said:

I am curious how the "dovetail extension" works on the Moxon vise. Please explain. A picture illustrating this be very helpful.

Regards from Perth

Derek

I don't know if this is exactly what Trip means, but there are some examples towards the end of this video:

 

 

 

Thanks. There is about 20 seconds of the dovetail extension table being used. It re-affirms my concerns about the design in practice, and why I use a different method.

I began using a version of the Moxon vise before Chris Schwarz made it popular (there is a "$5 vise" on my website, written up in 2008), but was inspired by the. bench-top location when Chris did write about it. My version had a few advances over his.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/MoxonDovetailVise.html

Then Jameel brought out his screws and kit. There is no doubt that his screws are first class (I have his wagon vise), but I do not like his Moxon design on two counts. 

The first is the the screws for the Moxon vise project from the front - not too far out, but I would find a way to bump into them! My preference is that the screws enter the chop and project at the rear of the vise, where they are out of the way.

The second is the dovetail extension - when you transfer marks from tails to pins on through dovetails, you will cut up the chop. I continue instead to use a design of my own, and some here may be interested to see this, and decide for themselves ...

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/ModsfortheMoxon.html

Keep in mind thatI have cut many hundreds of dovetails over the years, and I would prefer to use the design that works the best. I am not convinced about the dovetail extension table, and I suggest that those starting out think critically about any recommendation, and not leap into something just because it is fashionable.

Regards from Perth

Derek

  • Author

==>I do not like his Moxon design on two counts.

Always more ways to skin a cat...

Don't want to tout BC's Moxon, because I've no experience with any other... The tip is more about continuous sharpening while batch dovetailing... I happen to use BC's Moxon...

Why did I go Benchcrafted? We'll I was doing the Roubo build at the time, and figured to leverage the shipping costs for Roubo hardware plus I figure Jameel's a smart guy, so I decided to try his Moxon... So far, I like it... Seen no reason to change... Yet... If I do, then I'll post a tip about Moxon vises... :)

 

==>screws for the Moxon vise project from the front - not too far out, but I would find a way to bump into them!

I find I don't bump into the wheels... Maybe others with BC's kit can chime in, but it's never been an issue for me... If you're dovetailing a wide board that extends right up to the edge of the screw -- yea, it could be an issue... I can see what Dave's getting at... But then again, I could make a cheap&dirty wider Moxon in about an hour and return it to the scrap bin at the end of the project... Dave's point could be why Jameel's design is for a 24" wide vise...

 

==>you will cut up the chop

Many use a deep slashing stroke when transferring pins -- I don't... I use a scalpel grip and just scribe the cheeks of the tail, not beyond... I tite-mark the tail ends... If I used the slashing stroke technique, then I'd probably cut the chop... I also use the 140 trick, so my pins board extends a bit above the chop... So I really don't cut into the chop all that often... Maybe others do... Don't know... But then again, it's a vise... It's supposed to get a few battle scars... If the cosmetics ever bothers me, I'll run the thing across the jointer -- that's how I flattened the face and created the 90d surfaces to begin with. Note: I removed the wheels and used ACME nuts to hold the chop in-place...

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.