andrew-in-austin Posted February 14, 2016 Report Posted February 14, 2016 I don't own a drum sander yet, but I plan to, and I have been looking at both the open ended models, which seem to be very popular with the hobbyist woodworker, and closed at both ends. I don't understand the desire to have an open end sander. Yes, you could run 38 or 44 or 50 inch wide boards by doing half, then the other half, but does anyone -really- do this? Between the possible out of adjustment on the open end, and having to support a super wide board, IMO it does not seem like a good idea. Do an of you sand boards that wide? Obviously a drum sander closed on both ends has less width capacity, but at, for example, 26", do you really need more than this? Lot's of these also have dual drums, which I would think would speed up the whole sanding process, and perhaps eliminate the need to change paper until it is worn out. And I would expect that keeping it calibrated is far easier with both ends closed. Cost advantage seems like a toss up. Woodmaster 26" capacity single drum is $3059, but made in USA. Grizzly G1066Z is dual drum, 24" capacity, and $2050, seems like a good deal. The supermax ShopPro 25 might be a little weak at 1.75HP, but very good price at $1875. The supermax 25x2 had dual drums, 5HP, and costs $2690 -that seems like a very good deal. For those who bought an open end sander did you consider a closed-at-both-ends sander? Quote
Brendon_t Posted February 14, 2016 Report Posted February 14, 2016 You answered most of your own questions and for the rest of the answers, it's our WTO favorite. It depends on Your Work and what You Build... i have a opened end, 18/36. I use single width 90% of the time but when I need that other 10% it's there so yes! people actually do do that. another thing to look at is, do you have the electrical circuit capacity to run a 4 or 5 hp machine plus your dust collector system? Quote
wdwerker Posted February 14, 2016 Report Posted February 14, 2016 I have had the original Peformax 16/32 open end sander for at least 16 to 18 years. And I use it almost every day. Only had to adjust the drum back to parallel about 3 times. Yes 90% is within the 16" width but having the 32" capacity has paid for itself. I have even made 2 - 24" wide sections, sanded them then glued up a 48" top. Using dominoes in the joint it was aligned close enough to sand the seam with an orbital. Quote
Chet Posted February 14, 2016 Report Posted February 14, 2016 I have the SuperMax 19/38 and think it is a beast of a machine at $1395. And yes just like stated above, not all the time, but there are times when I am glad I had the extra wide. I would bet that if you bought a closed end, "sure a shootin'" in no time at all you would have a need for the added width. Mine is 1.75 HP and would think that 5 HP is some serious over kill. Quote
andrew-in-austin Posted February 14, 2016 Author Report Posted February 14, 2016 For those that go beyond 16 or 19 inch capacity, have you ever sanded something wider than 25"? I can only think of a large table that would need that, and like Steve stated, doing it in two sections, might be easier to work with anyway. Quote
Chet Posted February 14, 2016 Report Posted February 14, 2016 I liked Steve's idea when I read it. But having said that when I was building my Nicholson bench I ran the top through a couple of times each way before I started to flatten it with my Jack Plane. I just wanted to get rid of most of the glue line and what not it was a wrestling match to get it through because of the weight but my grandson helped and and all went well. I was just at 25 inches with that. In the long run you have to get what you are happy with in your work flow and the types of projects you see in your future. But I don't think that something that 5 hp is really necessary. Even the Powermatic that Marc just got is still just 1.75 HP. Quote
wdwerker Posted February 14, 2016 Report Posted February 14, 2016 Chet makes a very good point. Sanding large glued up panels is a wrestling match. If you don't see yourself doing it a closed end machine makes better sense. If you do want to do it you need to set up an infeed, outfeed and return table around the machine. I use a combination of saw horses and a couple of shop tables on wheels. I shim and chock the wheels to provide a level playing field . I guide the panel or sled ( for flattening wide boards) through the sander run around and guide it out then slide & rotate it for the next pass. For really long or wide pieces having a second person on the outfeed side is a big help. Set up bright lights at a raking angle so you can see any flaws while sanding. I use a pencil to mark lines over the whole surface and sand until they are gone, especially with the coarser grits to flatten a surface. I keep firm hand pressure pressing down and forward to prevent the board from slipping on the feed belt. That causes the drum to dig a dip in your board that takes a lot of effort to remove. Quote
Trip Posted February 14, 2016 Report Posted February 14, 2016 If you have (or can develop) a relationship with a local cabinet shop, then get a closed unit... For the one panel per year too large, just pay the $20 to have it surfaced... 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.