toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Chestnut posted a question about repairing a chipped tooth and I thought about some of the questions that I get about my sharpening frequency and habits. For context: I am small, one man professional shop, dedicated to nothing in particular (such as being a dedicated cabinet shop) and one that does a bit of everything across the spectrum for both residential and commercial clients. I handle and work all materials: solid lumber, all sheet goods, laminates, plastics, etc. My sharpening bill in total for 2015 was $578. I don't sharpen saw blades, jointer, or planer knives myself. I use a local guy that does a great job of sharpening and repairing blades. He also does drop-off and pick-up which is rolled into the price of his sharpening, with a one week turn around. The only things I sharpen myself are chisels and plane irons. When I get my blades sharpened, they provide excellent results. When they start providing just good results, it is time to sharpen. Depending on the amount of work I am doing, and what material I am using, a blade might last a week or it might last a month before sharpening. I keep my blades clean. Depending on what I am working with, I might have to clean a blade every other week, or a 2x daily chore. Blades dedicated to working reclaimed material tend to get really beat up, but that is the nature of working with reclaimed lumber and so I am not as particular with them for sharpening, but I do have to keep them clean to keep them cutting. Most reclaimed material that I work with tends to be old yellow pine or fir which builds up fast on the blades. Blade cleaning ends up being a daily chore, sometimes 2x a day when milling a large volume of reclaimed material. Most all of the blades I have, I have owned for many years. That is except for the blades used for working reclaimed material, they last about 2 months if I am doing a lot of reclaimed work. I have a Garrett Super Wand metal detector (which works wonderfully) but it is impossible to remove all nails and metal. I have accepted the fact I am going to be hitting nails with my blades when working reclaimed material. About 13 years ago I sold off my Powermatic 54A with straight knives (I highly recommend this jointer) and went with an 8" Grizzly G0543 with the Grizzly helical cutter head. With the HSS straight knives I was sending them out once a month to have sharpened. With the carbide cutters on my Grizzly, I have been getting 6 years per cutting edge. I just turned the cutters to their 3rd cutting edge summer of 2015 and I have been very pleased with the performance of the machine, the helical cutter head, and the life and performance of the cutters. I have saved a lot of money in sharpening jointer knives over the years since going to a helical head with carbide cutters. June 2015 I upgraded my JET 15" planer with straight knives to a JET 20" planer with Shelix cutter head. I do not expect to get the same life out of the planer knives as my jointer since the jointer is typically used after the table saw and knives are cutting an edge that has been fresh cut. The planer knives tend to get exposed directly to surfaces that have contaminates which dull knives quickly. But, here has been my experience since the planer upgrade. I was sending out at least one set of planer knives per week, some weeks 2, averaging 5 per month with the projects I had in 2015. While the machine cost $3500 total for me to buy and install. It has increased my production by a solid 1/3 over the previous feed rate and I estimate I saved $600 in sharpening planer knives for the last 6 months of operation for 2015, based on the type of projects that I was getting at that time. This work was foreseen which prompted the planer upgrade. Since I went with the Shelix cutter head I have been running on the first cutting edge since June 2015. A couple of weeks ago I ran some cherry through the planer on the right half, which I reserve for rough milling, and it cut just as clean as the left half of the cutter head, which I reserve for clean milling. That pretty much covers my philosophy, habits, and experience for my shop when it comes to sharpening. Everybody's experience will be different. 1 Quote
Jason Hotze Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Thanks for the info Todd. I have a smaller Jet 6" joiner that I simply buy new blades because I can't find anyone local to sharpen and their only about 30 bucks. But I have found that they get tore up within a week or two to the point where they cut well but leave grooves in the boards from nicks. My Dewalt DW734 has a little bit better results in that the blades last a few months wit me mostly using pine, polled and maple. Occasionally oak. I have contemplated spending 200 vice the 60 to get a set of carbide blades for the planer but keep telling myself no because I want to upgrade when I get the money. I also found that they make a Byrd cutter head for the 734 but once again I think it's silly to put a cutter head in a planet that cost the same. I really wish there was someone local to take the blades too instead of buying new. It would make the cost of buying the carbide blades a lot more reassuring. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Quote
Brendon_t Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I have a set of carbide blades for my 8" jointer and they outlasted hss substantially. Quote
shaneymack Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Interesting post Todd. I have a byrd head in my jointer and planer and am just a hobby shop. Based on your experience, one side of my cutter should last me around 22 years ! lol What exactly do you mean by this: 41 minutes ago, toddclippinger said: I do not expect to get the same life out of the planer knives as my jointer since the jointer is typically used after the table saw and knives are cutting an edge that has been fresh cut. Is the jointer not your very first tool used in the milling process? I see my planer and jointer knives getting around equal wear due to the fact that they each see one rough surface during milling. 2 Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Author Report Posted May 9, 2016 Just now, Brendon_t said: I have a set of carbide blades for my 8" jointer and they outlasted hss substantially. I had considered getting the carbide knives for the 6" Powermatic and almost did. But about that time, I also hit a project that would pay for the jointer upgrade and I really needed the extra capacity for that project. The project also required milling a lot of curly maple, which a helical or spiral head cutter head does exceptionally well at. This entertainment center paid for the upgrade. All the solid maple was curly. The 2 main machines that allowed me to build this without struggling with tear out was the jointer with helical cutter head and dual drum sander. 2 Quote
shaneymack Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Totally amazing cabinet, Todd !!!!!!!!!! I love it. Do you have any other pics? Give us all you got, im sure others want to see more as well. And why the heck have you been holding out on us, this should be in the project journals ! 1 Quote
Chestnut Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I probably need to get my saw blades sharpened more often. My miter saw blade has been in the saw for the last 2 years and i haven't sharpened it. I guess with the small amount of work I'm doing it's hard for me to distinguish between great and good. 20 minutes ago, Jason Hotze said: . I also found that they make a Byrd cutter head for the 734 but once again I think it's silly to put a cutter head in a planet that cost the same. It seems silly but at least for the 735, it's a good planer and honestly how many tools do you own where the accessories cost as much as the tool? I can probably name a few, sure they are a different situation but getting a helical head planer for less than $1,000 is going to be difficult. Also there is a different world for contracted work and hobby work. I'm a hobby worker so justifying a jet 20" with brydhead is dang difficult, but a $400 is a LOT easier. I was debating the brdy head for my 735 but i ended up getting a DC first and am putting the cutter head off a few months. 1 Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Author Report Posted May 9, 2016 6 minutes ago, shaneymack said: Interesting post Todd. I have a byrd head in my jointer and planer and am just a hobby shop. Based on your experience, one side of my cutter should last me around 22 years ! lol What exactly do you mean by this: Is the jointer not your very first tool used in the milling process? I see my planer and jointer knives getting around equal wear due to the fact that they each see one rough surface during milling. Not only will your tools last a lifetime, but the cutting edge as well! Sometimes the jointer is used first on the edge of a board, sometimes I do a run on the table saw to do a little initial straightening. And sometimes I use my straight-line jig at the table saw which works for boards up to 12'. My work flow steps vary depending on the situation. But in the end it comes down to the jointer knives get less exposure to really bad crap in the wood compared to the planer. 1 minute ago, Chestnut said: I probably need to get my saw blades sharpened more often. My miter saw blade has been in the saw for the last 2 years and i haven't sharpened it. I guess with the small amount of work I'm doing it's hard for me to distinguish between great and good. It seems silly but at least for the 735, it's a good planer and honestly how many tools do you own where the accessories cost as much as the tool? I can probably name a few, sure they are a different situation but getting a helical head planer for less than $1,000 is going to be difficult. Also there is a different world for contracted work and hobby work. I'm a hobby worker so justifying a jet 20" with brydhead is dang difficult, but a $400 is a LOT easier. I definitely agree. That is why I felt that it was important to note my situation for context and an accurate measure. 8 minutes ago, shaneymack said: Totally amazing cabinet, Todd !!!!!!!!!! I love it. Do you have any other pics? Give us all you got, im sure others want to see more as well. And why the heck have you been holding out on us, this should be in the project journals ! I noticed a lot of guys don't have any projects uploaded. You can see some of my work at my Gallery Page. 14 minutes ago, shaneymack said: Totally amazing cabinet, Todd !!!!!!!!!! I love it. Do you have any other pics? Give us all you got, im sure others want to see more as well. And why the heck have you been holding out on us, this should be in the project journals ! Quote
Brendon_t Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I totally agree, segmented was the way to go with that beast. It's a beautiful cabinet btw. It looks like you got a great color match across all the maple there. Did you tint it all to match or was the lumber just that close? 1 Quote
shaneymack Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Incredible work Todd. I will check out your gallery page for sure. Just curious, how much does a cabinet like that go for? Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Author Report Posted May 9, 2016 Just now, shaneymack said: Incredible work Todd. I will check out your gallery page for sure. Just curious, how much does a cabinet like that go for? That one was $40,000. The materials alone were $12,000. Price also included the electrician moving and running some electrical, complete fabrication and installation of entertainment center. 7 minutes ago, Brendon_t said: I totally agree, segmented was the way to go with that beast. It's a beautiful cabinet btw. It looks like you got a great color match across all the maple there. Did you tint it all to match or was the lumber just that close? I got lucky, it all just matched. The solid maple and curly maple plywood all matched. I used Sherwin Williams T77-F57 pre-cat lacquer as the finish. Quote
Jason Hotze Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 wooow... Man I thought I had made it big time when I was able to get over a grand for my tables. But my tables also don't look like that haha. Excellent work Todd. Did you transition from construction style work to furniture or vice versa? I've heard that furniture guys have a hard time with built ins and construction style because of the differences between square and plum or true. 1 Quote
Ronn W Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I was inspired to get back into wood working after seeing the workmanship of the guy made our kitchen cabinets. Thanks for the fresh shop of inspiration. Beautiful! 1 Quote
Brendon_t Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 3 hours ago, Jason Hotze said: I've heard that furniture guys have a hard time with built ins and construction style because of the differences between square and plum or true. I would love to see a topic post about the intricacies of built in vs square furniture. I've got a few people who have asked to hire me to do built in's. I'm a bit apprehensive thus far. 1 Quote
shaneymack Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Todd, can you give us some details about those doors and the hardware? Do they have some sort of piano hinge in the center? What is the material you used in the frames? I checked out your site, you do some seriously kick ass stuff man. 1 Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Author Report Posted May 9, 2016 1 hour ago, Jason Hotze said: wooow... Man I thought I had made it big time when I was able to get over a grand for my tables. But my tables also don't look like that haha. Excellent work Todd. Did you transition from construction style work to furniture or vice versa? I've heard that furniture guys have a hard time with built ins and construction style because of the differences between square and plum or true. I went from handyman to construction, to remodel with a specialty focus on old houses. Working on the old houses allowed me to start enjoying the challenge of duplicating old style trim and designing built-ins that looked original to the houses. From built-ins I expanded to stand alone furniture and furnishings. When I started in the trades back in '97, it was common to see the old guys as they wore out move on to being the custom trim and cabinet installers or move out of the trades and be a rep for construction materials. As I matured in my skills, I saw myself migrate out of the construction and get more custom work. Being the contractor in charge of the project, I get to sell my own ideas and designs. My ideas have beat out designers and architects on several occasions. And I guess when the designers and architects start taking your ideas and using them elsewhere, you know you hit the big time. 57 minutes ago, Ronn W said: I was inspired to get back into wood working after seeing the workmanship of the guy made our kitchen cabinets. Thanks for the fresh shop of inspiration. Beautiful! Thanks! Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Author Report Posted May 9, 2016 46 minutes ago, Brendon_t said: I would love to see a topic post about the intricacies of built in vs square furniture. I've got a few people who have asked to hire me to do built in'simi. I'm a bit apprehensive thus far. I plan to cover that in a blog or video post in the future, but if you need some guidance in the mean time, let me know and I will fill you in. It takes some consideration to build in a project, nothing is ever square or plumb and there are a few techniques to deal with these issues. It also may involve some skills like dealing with wall repairs, matching textures on walls, and painting if it is built-in. That simply means you either have to know how to do it or who to hire to do it for you. There is nothing wrong with hiring someone, if they have specialty skills that you don't have, it is better to hire them. You may be responsible for the project but it does not mean that you have to know how to do it all or have all of the skills. I do a lot of those things myself, but I developed my skills over the years, but that does not preclude me from working with others and hiring help when I need it in the shop or on the job site. 6 minutes ago, Lester Burnham said: No joke. Amazing stuff. Very interesting. Thank you sir! Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Author Report Posted May 9, 2016 42 minutes ago, shaneymack said: Todd, can you give us some details about those doors and the hardware? Do they have some sort of piano hinge in the center? What is the material you used in the frames? I checked out your site, you do some seriously kick ass stuff man. The doors are split 2 on left and right. There is a piano hinge for the two doors to act as a bifold. The doors bifold and slide into the cabinet sides. I bought specialty hardware for that from a local cabinet shop supplier/dealer when I was working back in central Ohio. The doors are glued laminations made in my vacuum press and veneered with curly maple. This was the only way to make stock that would remain flat and stable. The face of everything is curly maple and curly cherry. The plywood boxes for everything was 4'x10' curly maple plywood which was very expensive. The shoji material is an acrylic panel with shoji material bonded to it. I sourced the material from Shoji Designs Inc. 1 Quote
Gixxerjoe04 Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 That is one hell of an entertainment center, screw woodworking, I want to do whatever the guy does who can afford to put that in his house haha. 2 Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Author Report Posted May 9, 2016 7 minutes ago, Gixxerjoe04 said: That is one hell of an entertainment center, screw woodworking, I want to do whatever the guy does who can afford to put that in his house haha. The entertainment center is in a Frank Lloyd Wright inspired house that my brother and I built in Ohio. We also designed a lot of the interior details. They have several of my high-end projects. Quote
shaneymack Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Wow I think there is more square footage in windows then there is in wall square footage ! Very cool. Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk Quote
gee-dub Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Well, your absolutely fantastic entertainment center design and build has distracted from your original topic. Since no one else has said so, let me say that your piece is beautiful and reflects the spirit of the house and location wonderfully . . . oh wait, I think some one else may have already said something . That breathtaking piece aside (although it is hard to stop commenting on it), thanks for a great insight into your sharpening schedule. Your intervals are a lot shorter than many of the folks here but, your determining factors and maintenance habits can be shared by all. I just got through doing the second flip on my jointer and the first on my planer. As someone who has a non-woodworking day job it is great to get the hard facts from someone who woodworks professionally. Your thread adds credence to some of the things I have done (when a great result becomes a good result its time to act) which is reassuring. Your thread can just as well be instructive / correcting for those that wonder why the tablesaw is not cutting "like it used to". I think regular cleaning of cutters buys you longer life between sharpening. Regular sharpening buys you longer life for your tools in general, produces better work and prevent accidents. The old adage about a sharp knife applies to sharp tools as well. Thanks for taking the time to share your experience and for using that beautiful piece as an example. 1 Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Author Report Posted May 9, 2016 3 minutes ago, gee-dub said: Well, your absolutely fantastic entertainment center design and build has distracted from your original topic. Since no one else has said so, let me say that your piece is beautiful and reflects the spirit of the house and location wonderfully . . . oh wait, I think some one else may have already said something . That breathtaking piece aside (although it is hard to stop commenting on it), thanks for a great insight into your sharpening schedule. Your intervals are a lot shorter than many of the folks here but, your determining factors and maintenance habits can be shared by all. I just got through doing the second flip on my jointer and the first on my planer. As someone who has a non-woodworking day job it is great to get the hard facts from someone who woodworks professionally. Your thread adds credence to some of the things I have done (when a great result becomes a good result its time to act) which is reassuring. Your thread can just as well be instructive / correcting for those that wonder why the tablesaw is not cutting "like it used to". I think regular cleaning of cutters buys you longer life between sharpening. Regular sharpening buys you longer life for your tools in general, produces better work and prevent accidents. The old adage about a sharp knife applies to sharp tools as well. Thanks for taking the time to share your experience and for using that beautiful piece as an example. Ya the thread did seem to take a side track there! You are spot-on about the sharp knife principle applying to woodworking as well. Things have to be forced more when blades are dull or dirty, blades overheat and distort, then bind, it can get dangerous. Dull knives on the planer offer more resistance, material doesn't feed smoothly, then wood is vibrating tremendously and shattering in the planer and pieces are flying out the ends. All things that I have happened in my shop when pushing dull cutting edges to their limits. One of the things that many do not realize, when you trash the teeth on blades, they have to be ground further down to get everything set proper again. If a person is attentive to getting blades sharpened when they loose that supreme cutting edge, they need very little grinding. The more grinding that needs to be done, the more the sharpening costs me. The cost of sharpening is not just a flat, per-tooth fee. It starts with a per-tooth charge then gets additional costs if there is heavy grinding necessary to get it proper. Quote
Merlau Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 thanks for your post todd, i too him and hawed over spending some extra dollars for a bryd upgrade on a 15" planer but after getting some work that allowed for the dollars.. it has been like Christmas ever sense.. i like to use a fair amount of figured woods and with straight blades you end up sanding down to final size because of tear out.. but with the bryd head installed i have saved time and actually enjoy planing lumber the noise being lower is one of the best improvements.. i can talk and plane lumber at the same time and understand each other.. before no way just hand signals.. have straight blades on the 8" jointer and have thought about carbide on that but havnt made the change yet.. thanks again todd 1 Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 10, 2016 Author Report Posted May 10, 2016 4 minutes ago, Merlau said: thanks for your post todd, i too him and hawed over spending some extra dollars for a bryd upgrade on a 15" planer but after getting some work that allowed for the dollars.. it has been like Christmas ever sense.. i like to use a fair amount of figured woods and with straight blades you end up sanding down to final size because of tear out.. but with the bryd head installed i have saved time and actually enjoy planing lumber the noise being lower is one of the best improvements.. i can talk and plane lumber at the same time and understand each other.. before no way just hand signals.. have straight blades on the 8" jointer and have thought about carbide on that but havnt made the change yet.. thanks again todd Congrats on your upgrade! The lower decibel factor is HUGE bonus! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.