Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi wood-people. I am new to wood-working and I have spent the better part of this year working on projects and learning up using videos and articles online to get started learning the basics. I'm approaching the end of my 2nd table project and it looks pretty good. Since January I've been able to acquire a table saw, thickness planer, and a jointer. Despite having all these there's one problem I continue to have and that is making long boards (in this case a 48" board) completely flat. I always get close but my boards always wind up with about a 1/16" cup in them. I think it might be I'm not using my jointer right. It's my newest tool.

Any tips and advice are much appreciated. Thanks in advance.

Posted

What's your jointer?  How wide and how long are the beds?    What's your current technique for using it?   With a cup (meaning the board is curve along the width), the usual approach is to run it through like a frowney face so that it is resting on two points.   If you run it through like a smile, you risk it rocking back and forth.

Posted

Yeah more information needed but I thought I'd let you know you have the best handle in the history of handles.  Congrats on that.

I'll just throw this out there, though...if you're jointing 4/4 stock or thinner, and you're pushing DOWN too hard on the board as you joint...it's just gonna spring right back to bowed.  I assume you meant "bow" and not "cup."  You have to let the cutterhead do the flattening, and leave your muscle out of it.  If you're having trouble pushing the board across the beds without excessive force...wax.

Posted

Vyrolan, I picked up this little porter-cable from Lowes: https://www.lowes.com/pd/PORTER-CABLE-10-Amps-Amp-Bench-Jointer/3059865 . I am running it through cup-side down as per the instructions. I think it's just difficult for me due to the length of the board.

Eric, you're a wise man. I'm trying not to push down too hard. The jointer came with some push blocks and the instructions said apply pressure to the jointed side of the board once it passes over the cutting knives. It also said the same thing you did about not pushing down too hard. If I had to guess I think what is happening is my board is long enough and the jointer tables short enough that the board is passing across the surfaces and maintaining its angle. When I'm done each end is 1/16" or less difference from the center.

gee-dub, I'm going to watch that now.

giphy.gif

 

Posted
27 minutes ago, Meatwad said:

Vyrolan, I picked up this little porter-cable from Lowes: https://www.lowes.com/pd/PORTER-CABLE-10-Amps-Amp-Bench-Jointer/3059865 . I am running it through cup-side down as per the instructions. I think it's just difficult for me due to the length of the board.

Sorry, but that's your problem...  Those tiny jointers aren't very good and your technique needs to be really good to have any success.   With such short beds, even your 4' boards are really too long for it.

For technique, I'd recommend Marc's video and also Matt's video.

  • Like 1
Posted

If the board has a bow, you don't start by pushing the whole board through.  You start with the highest part of the bow over the cutterhead, and then run that end across.  The next step will most likely be to turn the board around, and do the same thing the other way.

You can straighten any length board on any length jointer.  Every board requires its own strategy. Sometimes you may need to only run the last few inches of a board for the first pass.  You need to sight the board and plan your strategy for that board of how to get rid of the parts that keep the board from being straight.

The longer the jointer, the easier it is to work with almost any board, but the jointer still doesn't do the work you need without a plan of attack.

With the power unplugged, lay a strip of wood on the outfeed table that goes over the blades,  move the cutterhead back and forth, and see if the knives just brush the bottom of the strip, or push it up.  If the knives are too high, they will raise the strip off the outfeed table, and could make it very hard to straighten a board without leaving a cup.

Posted
5 minutes ago, Tom King said:

You can straighten any length board on any length jointer.  Every board requires its own strategy. Sometimes you may need to only run the last few inches of a board for the first pass.  You need to sight the board and plan your strategy for that board of how to get rid of the parts that keep the board from being straight.

The longer the jointer, the easier it is to work with almost any board, but the jointer still doesn't do the work you need without a plan of attack.

Well said Tom.   That's why I linked Matt Cremona's video above in particular.   He really goes into "what exactly does the jointer do?" which is important.  I think the better someone understands how the jointer works and what it does, the better they are able to use that information to devise an appropriate strategy for each board.     That all said, I agree wholeheartedly with "the longer the jointer, the easier it is to work". :-)

Posted

I know Tom is right, but in my personal experience with that jointer, I know it's easier said than done. That jointer was good for about 40" and under.  I got rid of it as soon as possible and replace it with a 72"  bed 8" cutter Delta clone for under 400.

  • Like 1
Posted

Thanks for the help guys. I know it isn't the best jointer but I having a big bench jointer is just something I don't have room for. Maybe one day when I'm rich I can buy a place and get a little shop going. Right now I do everything out of my garage.

This discussion raises some other questions: How effective would it be if I made an extension table for this jointer? Which side should it be on? Would it have to be perfectly level with the infeed/outfeed?

Posted
2 minutes ago, Meatwad said:

Right now I do everything out of my garage.

A garage is plenty of space for an 8" or bigger jointer...as long as you use your meatwad and get your wife's CAR out of your SHOP. :)  Just ask @Llama and he'll give you some pointers.

I personally find the jointer to be one of - if not the most - critical tools in a shop.  It's the beginning of every project - the starting point - and if you're unable to get boards perfectly flat and square from the get-go, you'll be fighting an uphill battle through the entire build.  Which if nothing else takes ALL the fun out of woodworking...and ultimately results in an end product of lower quality.  Gappy joinery is U-G-L-Y.

Cheap jointers also happen to be extremely difficult to calibrate properly, so not only are you sacrificing capacity, you're putting yourself in a position that presents enormous frustration.

I'd rather have a high-quality 8" jointer and a contractor table saw than a tiny, cheap jointer and a 5HP SawStop.  Dead serious.

7 minutes ago, Meatwad said:

How effective would it be if I made an extension table for this jointer?

Good luck with that.  It could help support boards, but it won't contribute to creating a more precise machine.

  • Like 2
Posted

Ha, Eric, right now I have my tools and my motorcycle on my side of the garage and my car is outside. The other half of my garage belongs to my wife and I'm not going to invade it.

Do you have any links to what you think a good jointer would be? A good compromise between performance, size, and cost?

Posted
29 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Just ask @Llama and he'll give you some pointers.

Tell her to park outside. :) 

5 minutes ago, Meatwad said:

A good compromise

Can't help here. Read my signature :) 

  • Like 1
Posted

Listen to @Eric..  I couldn't agree more that the jointer is the most important tool in the shop.  

As far as a good compromise...hate to open a can of worms, but grizzly is probably your best bet.  I would characterize it as the low end of the "acceptable quality" machines.  And that sounds like an elitist insult, but I own a grizzly jointer.  So did Eric before his pooped the bed on him.  When mine poops the bed I will upgrade.  In fact, if you were in Boston instead of Arkansas I'd probably propose a deal where we'd both win.  But a grizzly jointer is absolutely an acceptable machine to start with.  Took me 2 hours to calibrate mine and it hasn't moved out of calibration in 4+ years now.  (the fact that mine has the spiral cutterhead instead of straight knives helps with that).  

In my opinion it's going to be hard to get a jointer that's going to give you anything but frustration for under $800, unless you head for the used market, which is certainly an option but a whole different can of worms.  

  • Like 2
Posted
25 minutes ago, Meatwad said:

The other half of my garage belongs to my wife and I'm not going to invade it.

Well, my condolences.  :)  The agreement in my house...she gets the closets, I get the garage.  I also have to dig her car out when it snows.  Small price to pay.  Unless your wife drives a Porsche, Audi or BMW...no car deserves to eat up valuable shop space.  Modern finishes on cars are no joke.

 

tumblr_ncl8weQ3DO1sksdxao8_500.gif

 

26 minutes ago, Meatwad said:

Do you have any links to what you think a good jointer would be? A good compromise between performance, size, and cost?

Eh, I hesitate to give you specific models.  It's not my job to decide what's best for you or to spend your money.  I have a PM PJ-882HH.  It replaced a Grizzly G0490...and there's a world of difference between them.

Posted

To be more specific, here's a grizzly 6" model with a spiral cutterhead.  The beds are 46" long which is perfectly adequate for most projects.  The spiral cutterhead will make calibrating and maintenance much easier.  This could serve you well for many years, as mine has for me so far, and Eric's did for him.

Looks like you're about a 4 hour drive from their showroom in Missouri.  Might be able to save on shipping if you're willing to make a (long) day trip to pick it up.

Posted
2 minutes ago, bgreenb said:

Looks like you're about a 4 hour drive from their showroom in Missouri.  Might be able to save on shipping if you're willing to make a (long) day trip to pick it up.

But if you pick it up at Grizzly you have to pay tax.  Which makes the shipping cost a wash, and you can save yourself the trip.

  • Like 1
Posted

I'll add that in addition to being arguably the  most important machine, the jointer is also the machine that is the hardest to calibrate and keep calibrated, especially a straight knife version.  In my own personal budgeting priorities, I would prefer to pay up for a premium jointer and compromise elsewhere (as an example, pay the $2k+ for a nice 8" PM jointer, but hold onto my dewalt 735 benchtop planer which is an outstanding value and suits my needs 95% of the time).  

Posted
11 minutes ago, bgreenb said:

To be more specific, here's a grizzly 6" model with a spiral cutterhead.  The beds are 46" long which is perfectly adequate for most projects.  The spiral cutterhead will make calibrating and maintenance much easier.  This could serve you well for many years, as mine has for me so far, and Eric's did for him.

Looks like you're about a 4 hour drive from their showroom in Missouri.  Might be able to save on shipping if you're willing to make a (long) day trip to pick it up.

When you say the beds are 46" long is that measurement the combination of the infeed and outfeed table? In other words is the whole matchine 46" wide? That would at least give me a good idea of something to look for.

All the help is appreciated.

Posted
2 minutes ago, Meatwad said:

When you say the beds are 46" long is that measurement the combination of the infeed and outfeed table? In other words is the whole matchine 46" wide? That would at least give me a good idea of something to look for.

All the help is appreciated.

Correct, total length of the beds.  Keep in mind that what Tom King said is correct - you should be able to flatten a board adequately with any length bed (after all a jointer plane is only 20-24" long), it's just much more difficult.  My grizzly jointer has a 72" bed and I definitely appreciate the extra length.  

Posted

Yes 46" bed length in total.

It's a slippery slope because then you realize you could get a G0656W for less than a hundred bucks more.  It's got straight knives (opposed to spiral head on the G0452Z) and dovetail ways (same as the G0452Z)...but a lot more capacity.  Then you realize for a few hundred more you can get an 8" Grizzly with a spiral head and parallelogram beds.  Then you realize for a couple grand more you can get the PJ-880HH.  Then you realize you can sell your house and your car and your wife and get Mel's unit. :D Somehow Mel managed to get his without selling his wife.  He did have to sell his house though. LOL @Llama

  • Like 1
Posted
1 minute ago, Llama said:

Ah... yes... My unit :)

Really not fair to bring mine up in this conversation :) 

It's not really fair to bring it up...ever. LOL

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   4 Members, 0 Anonymous, 50 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined