Recommended Posts

Posted

While working on my current project I've been trying to figure out what tool upgrade would improve my efficiency in the shop.  As I've gone through the stages of the build I have debated where I need to upgrade the most.  I feel like my time in the shop gets wasted on some timely parts of a build and then I rush through joinery and shaping, leading to mistakes.  I think the time suck and the least pleasurable points of a project for me are milling and sanding.  I don't really enjoy finishing, but I just use ARS 95% of the time anyway so it's not difficult.

My wife has essentially given me the green light for a big tool purchase when she gave me the go ahead for a new jointer.  As the project has progressed though, and as I stare at a pile of parts for two of those kitchen helper things, I'm not too sure the jointer is where I should go.  I think the time suck and the least pleasurable points of a project for me are milling and sanding.  I don't really enjoy finishing, but I just use ARS 95% of the time anyway so it's not difficult.

I currently have a 6" Ridgid jointer.  It works, and works better than you'd expect.  Lately the knives have shown signs of being dull, but ultimately I don't have problems most of the time making boards flat and square.  If I buy a new jointer it too will be 6", I don't have 220 and don't really have plans to add it.  So would a longer bed and Powermatic quality really help me that much?  I'm not too sure now.

So my head goes to a drum sander.  My hesitation comes to size...I know this group's love for the Supermax, but I'm not sure I can fit it in my shop without cramping my space too much.  Are there any smaller drum sanders that are worthwhile?  The Jet 10-20?  Either of the smaller Grizzly sanders? 

 

Posted

Yeah, I know the DS won't eliminate the random orbit, but I would hope it would make quick work of leveling and removing tear out, etc., to speed the process along. 

 I'll think about rearranging the shop to accomodate.

Posted
1 hour ago, bleedinblue said:

I feel like my time in the shop gets wasted on some timely parts of a build

What specifically is the time wasted?  Time performing a step? Or are there steps you think you can eliminate (or minimize - like sanding)?

I'm all for a DS...awesome tool I hope to have some day - but there could be other things needed to improve your efficiency.  If you find you're walking back and forth a lot or futzing with where to put things - maybe a slightly different layout would be helpful.  If you're going to move things around to make space for a DS, see if the layout can make your time spent at any project phase more efficient.

 

  • Like 1
Posted
21 minutes ago, bleedinblue said:

I'll think about rearranging the shop to accomodate.

One thing to remember is there is a lot of potential storage space under the footprint of the SuperMax.  So look around the shop, have you got things in a storage cabinet that might go in the stand you build for the sander?  And maybe removing that storage cabinet will give you room for the DS.

Posted

Hmm. I COULD move my finishing supplies to a cabinet under the sander and eliminate one cabinet, allowing me to move my dust collector back a couple feet. 

5 minutes ago, 21meyer said:

Supermax is releasing a 16-32 model but I have not checked to see the footprint. I have the 19-38 and am happy with it but it does take up a fair amount of floor space especially if you don't build a cabinet stand.

 

http://www.supermaxtools.com/products/wood/16-32-drum-sander-71632/

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Holy crap.  I've been saying they needed a smaller model but had no idea one was in the works.  I'm practically sold. 

Posted
3 minutes ago, 21meyer said:

According to the email I received, they are going to retail at $1199.

I just found that an edited my post. Awesome info. 

I seriously may just pre-order it. 

Posted
17 minutes ago, Jfitz said:

What specifically is the time wasted?  Time performing a step? Or are there steps you think you can eliminate (or minimize - like sanding)?

Ehhhhhh, it's just the time the milling and sanding takes seems to be longer than it should.  I just got frustrated during this project with the time it is taking and the errors I have made, so it has me re-examining my work flow. 

Posted

The 16-32 looks like a great tool for the small shop.  Folding tables, smaller footprint, etc.  I have wished for more than the 19-38's 4" height restriction and the 16-32's 3" would probably push me to the larger machine (I already have it).  The value of certain capacities and features will vary with the woodworker and what he uses the tool for.  There are other ways to do things for those rare moments when I exceed the capacity of some machine.

If the 19-38 had come with folding tables I would be a little happier, not much  Of course, then I would have lost that extra storage ;-)

573fa1eb25b6d_Supermax19-38(15).jpg.3a14afd6836b71c128f773652b0a767f.jpg19-38-stand(25).jpg.d919a367adadcebc724a84b9407c4036.jpg

  • Like 1
Posted

I'm still working toward incorporating my smoother into my work flow.  It's not as automatic as I had hoped, I need to dedicate time to practice.  I have the plane, I just have to start incorporating.  Same goes for card scrapers. 

Posted
8 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Hold your nose, take the plunge.  The only way through it is through it.  Music and a couple beers during a relaxed evening makes it not as terrible.

Words of wisdom.

 

Posted

Don't get me wrong guys, I obviously know sanding is part of the game and can't be eliminated.  For this project as an example though, I started with 80 grit on the ROS just to clean up remaining glue squeeze out and to level out slightly off set joints.  It took me about ten minutes per, and there were four of them..so right there was almost an hour just to get them sanded up to 80.  

I could have passed these through a DS a few times to quuckly get them up to 120 or so, the rest of the ROS work would be a breeze.

20170718_135502.jpg

Posted

Instead of an expensive machine (don't get me wrong - I still think you should get a drum sander...), you could look at different ways of accomplishing the same task.  Hand lanes pop to mind - I bet with a No 80 cabinet scraper and/or a decent jack plane, you could have eliminated squeeze out and leveled the joints in a fraction of the time.

 

Posted
28 minutes ago, Jfitz said:

Instead of an expensive machine (don't get me wrong - I still think you should get a drum sander...), you could look at different ways of accomplishing the same task.  Hand lanes pop to mind - I bet with a No 80 cabinet scraper and/or a decent jack plane, you could have eliminated squeeze out and leveled the joints in a fraction of the time.

 

Yeah, I know.  I have some Liam Nielsen gear and like I said above, I'm working at incorporating them more.  I'm struggling at that though. 

Posted
35 minutes ago, Jfitz said:

Instead of an expensive machine (don't get me wrong - I still think you should get a drum sander...), you could look at different ways of accomplishing the same task.  Hand lanes pop to mind - I bet with a No 80 cabinet scraper and/or a decent jack plane, you could have eliminated squeeze out and leveled the joints in a fraction of the time.

 

Yeah I agree...if I didn't have a drum sander I would have tackled the initial stages with a smoother, block plane, card scraper.

Also make sure you remember...120 grit on the drum sander is not 120 grit on a ROS.  It's much more aggressive and leaves deep scratches.  When you go from 120 DS to the ROS, you'll still have to start at 80 grit to get the 120 DS scratches out.  You can try a higher grit on the DS but I've always found it way too prone to loading and burning at anything higher than 120...and extremely slow.  So I've settled in at 120 and that's where I keep it.  Changing belts to do sequentially higher grits on the DS is almost more time consuming than just dealing with it with the ROS...unless you have a ton of parts or giant panels.  For me, the drum sander has very little to do with surface-prep, and everything to do with post-planer and panel glue-up clean-up...if that makes sense.  It's just preparation for surface preparation.  A truly intermediate step.  I'm not poo-pooing the drum sander at all...it's a very useful workhorse...I'm just trying to classify its usefulness accurately.

And again, that's why I keep pushing the smoother...because it eliminates three entire grits of sanding, and it's much more enjoyable making shavings for an hour or two than it is standing and sanding for several hours.

  • Like 1
Posted

Helical head for your jointer?

Took me forever to sand the kitchen helper. I can't remember how long, but I know my wife couldn't believe I was still sanding each evening.

Posted
5 minutes ago, legenddc said:

Helical head for your jointer?

Took me forever to sand the kitchen helper. I can't remember how long, but I know my wife couldn't believe I was still sanding each evening.

Try two at once :D

There is no way I'll put a helical head on this Ridgid, I guess unless I find one deeply discounted.  A $400 head on a jointer with probably less than $400 doesn't seem like a good investment. 

Posted
26 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Also make sure you remember...120 grit on the drum sander is not 120 grit on a ROS.  It's much more aggressive and leaves deep scratches.  When you go from 120 DS to the ROS, you'll still have to start at 80 grit to get the 120 DS scratches out.  You can try a higher grit on the DS but I've always found it way too prone to loading and burning at anything higher than 120...and extremely slow.  So I've settled in at 120 and that's where I keep it.  Changing belts to do sequentially higher grits on the DS is almost more time consuming than just dealing with it with the ROS...unless you have a ton of parts or giant panels.  For me, the drum sander has very little to do with surface-prep, and everything to do with post-planer and panel glue-up clean-up...if that makes sense.  It's just preparation for surface preparation.  A truly intermediate step.  I'm not poo-pooing the drum sander at all...it's a very useful workhorse...I'm just trying to classify its usefulness accurately.

This is all good and accurate information.  I haven't acquired the smoother skill set yet but as far as everything else this system works real well for me.  I like most don't care to sand but being able to run it through the drum sander at 120 a few times and then start at 80, 120, 150 and 180 with the ROS makes it a pretty tolerable task because the drum sander has done the heavy lifting.

Posted
1 minute ago, bleedinblue said:

Try two at once :D

There is no way I'll put a helical head on this Ridgid, I guess unless I find one deeply discounted.  

I'm just trying to spend your money!

I can't imagine doing 2 at once. Mine was ambrosia maple and my first time using rough wood.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Chet said:

I haven't acquired the smoother skill set yet 

At least I'm not alone!  Even with a quality plane and a super sharp blade direct from Tom, anything wider than the body of the plane gets tracks and gouges. 

1 minute ago, legenddc said:

 

I can't imagine doing 2 at once. Mine was ambrosia maple and my first time using rough wood.

It's not a hard project at all, but I confused myself with Domino layout.  I think each one has a half dozen plugged mortises...that really frustrated me.  Now it's down to round overs and lots of sanding.  Yes, I'll try to incorporate the smoother, lol. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 33 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined