Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Finish for a joiner's bench?

Featured Replies

I was given my great-grandfather's English joiner's bench that he brought with him from Liverpool in 1904. It's was used by him for work and then kicked around for decades. I am cleaning it and want to know what type of finish I should use (not a hard finish like poly, etc). I know there are different types of oils with different qualities or even a wax finish. What would be typical? What oil qualities would be best for something like this? Thanks!

  • Author

Thanks! I've got the mineral spirits ready. What is it about the Danish oil vs other oils that makes you recommend it?

  • Author
  • Popular Post

It wasn't filthy. I've given it a general cleaning and will move on to the next phase. Everything works beautifully. Unfortunately, the base got some wet rot in a basement and broke.

IMG_8705.JPG

IMG_8706.JPG

That's a very cool relic.  I have my great grandfather's bench which is probably similar in age, and it's one of my most prized possessions.  It's not a proper bench like that one but it has all the character.

Honestly I would have recommended not cleaning it at all because the patina is 110 years of awesomeness.  But too late for that I guess.  I'd leave it raw.  Maybe a coat of BLO if you just have to put something on it.

  • Author

Oh it HAD to be cleaned. It was filthy with decades of neglect and dirt. Couldn't even touch it. I don't actually know much about benches like this. I've been told it's a very nice one- solid maple. Hoping to find someone who can build the base in the style of he original. Haven't used BLO before- isn't it hard to work with? Do you work on yours or just show it off?

8 minutes ago, gabernat said:

Oh it HAD to be cleaned. It was filthy with decades of neglect and dirt. Couldn't even touch it. I don't actually know much about benches like this. I've been told it's a very nice one- solid maple. Hoping to find someone who can build the base in the style of he original. Haven't used BLO before- isn't it hard to work with? Do you work on yours or just show it off?

 

I have a traditional workbench that I do all my woodworking on, so I use G-Gpa's as my "utility bench."  It has more charm than usefulness but it's got drawers and a horizontal surface and a machinist's vise so the space it takes up is justified.

BLO couldn't be easier to use...wipe on, wipe off...like Daniel-son.

 

0RaNdnp.jpg

  • Author

I thought it was volitile and had to cure. Nice bench! Gotta have a vise...

IMG_8707.JPG

10 minutes ago, gabernat said:

I thought it was volitile and had to cure.

It does take a while to cure but it's "dry" within a day or two unless you absolutely pour it on.  Not sure what you mean by "volatile" unless you're referring to its tendency to burn people's houses down when BLO soaked rags are tossed in a pile...and it will...so do be careful with that.  But it's no more horrible in terms of VOCs than any other finish, and less so than most.

DO is another option like Steve said.  It's basically BLO with a little varnish added.  But you said you didn't want a film-forming finish.  Not that DO will build much of a film...but it does have some plastic in it.

  • Popular Post

That's a bad ass bench. I'm so happy this post didn't go the way of "I just sanded this back to pristine, now what?" You can't buy a patina like that. 

One thing to consider or keep in mind; in the hundred years that bench hes been used it's probably had  lots of grease spilled on it, metal shards sitting in the pores, and decades of snot on it. All of those can and likey will transfer to a work piece sitting on it while working. A simple bench appliance that clamps into the vise to give you a clean surface to work after surfacing and before finish is cheap insurance against an oil stain or metal shards rusting under a finish.

  • Author
15 hours ago, Eric. said:

Not sure what you mean by "volatile" unless you're referring to its tendency to burn people's houses down when BLO soaked rags are tossed in a pile...and it will...so do be careful with that.  But it's no more horrible in terms of VOCs than any other finish, and less so than most.

DO is another option like Steve said.  It's basically BLO with a little varnish added.  But you said you didn't want a film-forming finish.  Not that DO will build much of a film...but it does have some plastic in it.

Ha yes exactly! So don't be dumb and you won't die- got it ;)

Definitely want to stay away from a film like that. Thanks for the info!

  • Author
15 hours ago, Brendon_t said:

That's a bad ass bench. I'm so happy this post didn't go the way of "I just sanded this back to pristine, now what?" You can't buy a patina like that. 

One thing to consider or keep in mind; in the hundred years that bench hes been used it's probably had  lots of grease spilled on it, metal shards sitting in the pores, and decades of snot on it. All of those can and likey will transfer to a work piece sitting on it while working. A simple bench appliance that clamps into the vise to give you a clean surface to work after surfacing and before finish is cheap insurance against an oil stain or metal shards rusting under a finish.

Thank you! Its age is what makes it amazing. It's horrifying when people strip things down like that. What the point, then? My goal is to make it clean enough to use comfortably and preserve the kicks, knocks and stains in a way that looks good but natural. My g-grandfather was a master cabinet maker. It was never used for metal work so it was saved that. But yes, old adhesives, hardened paint, oils, etc.

Despite the fact that your great grandfather was English and lived in Liverpool, that's actually a Scandinavian bench.  An English joiner's bench has a large apron on the front with numerous holdfast/dog holes, and typically either a single face vise or a crochet.  A Nicholson bench is the classic English joiner's bench.

 

english_joiners_bench_img_8439.jpg?w=600

 

A Scandinavian bench like yours has a thick top and the traditional L-shaped tail vise...and a comparatively spindly looking base.

 

klbench1.jpg

 

A Roubo (French) bench has a similar style top to the Scandinavian design but it differs in the base and the vises.  The Roubo has become an extremely popular and trendy bench to build in the last decade, and I would guess that 75% or more of modern woodworkers build this style because of its versatility.

 

(this one is mine :))

 

HoJGm2X.jpg

 

So while I personally prefer the aesthetics and function of the Roubo over the others, I would recommend building a proper Scandinavian style base for your g-gpa's bench in order to keep it as traditional and historically accurate as possible.

Personnally, I would not apply any finish on sides in contact with wood (top, vices and valet). I used my first workbench with no finish at all for few weeks, and that was great. Then it was a real deception after oiling it (Thung oil). Sure the grain was enhanced and the wood protected, but the surface was slippery. After a while I sanded it all over and retrieve good sensations with the workbench. Just my two cents. Note the top does not wear that much compared to the sides.

  • Author
3 hours ago, Eric. said:

Despite the fact that your great grandfather was English and lived in Liverpool, that's actually a Scandinavian bench.  An English joiner's bench has a large apron on the front with numerous holdfast/dog holes, and typically either a single face vise or a crochet.  A Nicholson bench is the classic English joiner's bench.

 

english_joiners_bench_img_8439.jpg?w=600

 

A Scandinavian bench like yours has a thick top and the traditional L-shaped tail vise...and a comparatively spindly looking base.

 

klbench1.jpg

 

A Roubo (French) bench has a similar style top to the Scandinavian design but it differs in the base and the the vises.  The Roubo has become an extremely popular and trendy bench to build in the last decade, and I would guess that 75% or more of modern woodworkers build this style because of its versatility.

 

(this one is mine :))

 

HoJGm2X.jpg

 

So while I personally prefer the aesthetics and function of the Roubo over the others, I would recommend building a proper Scandinavian style base for your g-gpa's bench in order to keep it as traditional and historically accurate as possible.

WOW!!! Thank you for the information! I've been googleing and asking around at shops about it but have gotten very little info. Someone told me it was English because it's maple rather than pine. Good to be learning. What are the square holes are for? The legs were pretty much the same as in that photo but it had a V-shaped trough in the center where he tossed things.

Nice bench, BTW!

  • Author
1 hour ago, Jean [Fr] said:

Personnally, I would not apply any finish on sides in contact with wood (top, vices and valet). I used my first workbench with no finish at all for few weeks, and that was great. Then it was a real deception after oiling it (Thung oil). Sure the grain was enhanced and the wood protected, but the surface was slippery. After a while I sanded it all over and retrieve good sensations with the workbench. Just my two cents. Note the top does not wear that much compared to the sides.

Hmmm good tip. Maybe I'll just do the sides and handles- perk them up a little. Thanks!

21 minutes ago, gabernat said:

What are the square holes are for?

The square holes are called "dog holes," and traditional square dogs live in them.  When you want to hold a workpiece, you pop up one dog in the bench and one dog in the tail vise, give the vise a turn and it pinches the workpiece in place.

These are traditional dogs (they usually have suede on the faces but I hadn't done that yet in this pic)...

 

5Pj2V8I.jpg

 

7z7OYCJ.jpg

I just go with the simplest answer for this question.  Since my workbench occasionally doubles as my finishing bench, I just coated the bench with my most frequently used finish.  That way any drips just become yet another coat and I can rub them in without feeling bad about it.

  • Author
7 minutes ago, Eric. said:

The square holes are called "dog holes," and traditional square dogs live in them.  When you want to hold a workpiece, you pop up one dog in the bench and one dog in the tail vise, give the vise a turn and it pinches the workpiece in place.

These are traditional dogs (they usually have suede on the faces but I hadn't done that yet in this pic)...

 

5Pj2V8I.jpg

 

7z7OYCJ.jpg

Interesting-thank you! I'll ask my dad if he remembers seeing them. We have this piece- don't know if it's original with the bench since it's a different color and type of wood.

IMG_8708.JPG

I'll be honest...I have no idea what that is. LOL

Does the wedge move up/down?

With the metal loop under, once pressure was applied to the inboard face, does it push the toe of the wedge into a divot in the wood spine?

Looks like a variable clamping device, but for what, who knows

I think that's just an old-fashioned bar clamp, but the clamping pad appears to be missing. The block on the left can just hook into one of several notches on the bottom to accomodate different widths. Sort of like this:

il_fullxfull.224183138.jpg

@jjongsma is right this is a type of clamp. We call it "dormant". This is not old fashioned. There's modern versions still in use today. They provide a lot of pressure, and can lay flat on an assembly table. The use is like parallel clamps. Some have holes in the main rail to use smaller clamps to hold the parts flat on the large clamp. My grand father made a lot of them. He had a vertical panel press mad out of a bunch of them.

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.