Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Oil finish feeling rough

Featured Replies

So I just finish d my table and I am letting dry ... it’s mostly dry now and I rubbed my hand across it. It felt rough on most of it. This did not happen on the first coat and it felt silky smooth. 

Is there something I can use to knock all that crap down? 

99939E8F-8822-4ED1-A237-25BF71D58FC9.thumb.jpeg.9e0169daa99d5e15e5ef62ebe482e872.jpeg

Belt sander! Just kidding. That sucks! Hope someone has a good answer for ya! 

  • Popular Post

Not sure if you tried hitting it with paper from a brown paper bag? I usually put some on a sanding block with spray adhesive and wipe down everything, doesn't usually take much, don't need to be aggressive. 

  • Author
16 minutes ago, Think0075 said:

Not sure if you tried hitting it with paper from a brown paper bag? I usually put some on a sanding block with spray adhesive and wipe down everything, doesn't usually take much, don't need to be aggressive. 

I have not tried that but I definitely will and see how it goes. 

46 minutes ago, Think0075 said:

Not sure if you tried hitting it with paper from a brown paper bag? I usually put some on a sanding block with spray adhesive and wipe down everything, doesn't usually take much, don't need to be aggressive. 

So doesn’t have to be crumpled? For some reason, that’s what I featured Good to know. 

But, they’re all plastic now:huh:! 

  • Author
29 minutes ago, wdwerker said:

A gray abrasive pad followed by a white abrasive pad .

This Lot 5 Grey 3M Scuff Pad Scotch Brite 3M Brand https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00MBPTH56/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_00EmAbSEN0BS3

and this

Scotch-Brite 9030 Light Duty Scrubbing Pad, 5" Length x 3-1/2" Width, White (Case of 40) https://www.amazon.com/dp/B006WQJ0SE/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_s2EmAbVVD6J1N

 

???? 

Just not sure what you mean 

That's what I referred to. You can get them at a home center. There are several brands, some thinner & cheaper. They all work fine.

You can follow up with a buffing using a brown paper bag, seriously its texture is like a superfine abrasive ( above 800 I think)

I use a firm rubber pad and 1000, 1200 or 1500 to "finish the finish" with mineral spirits from a spray bottle as a lube.  I do an area no bigger than I can manage before the mineral spirits goes dry then wipe with a soft cotton rag spritzed with mineral spirits.  I don't know if I have any before and after shots . . . hmm, no, bummer.

I won't argue with the effectiveness of that " finish the finish " protocol cause it's spot on ! But you would need far more coats of " Danish oil " or  whatever wiping varnish mixture flavor you prefer to bother with those kind of grits.  4-5 coats and a week or more to cure and that  protocol would yield some nice results. Especially the " or more time to cure " 2 or 3 weeks wouldn't hurt. 

Agree with the light abrasive. I have 3 sanding sponges I bought from hd for a few bucks in 220 and 320 then 500. It may take a minute to go through all of them, so not a big time commitment.

10 hours ago, K Cooper said:

But, they’re all plastic now

What 40s come in plastic now!

I used to get a lot of texture like that. Making sure there isn't dust floating around in your finishing area helps a lot as well as a clean surface. Did you sand with 320 or something between coats?

I also do the same thing gee dub does except i mix some mineral oil in with the mineral spirits and use festool platin pads on the ets. Takes about 5 min to hit a table top. I clean off the excess mineral oil with some denatured alcohol.

8 hours ago, wdwerker said:

I won't argue with the effectiveness of that " finish the finish " protocol cause it's spot on ! But you would need far more coats of " Danish oil " or  whatever wiping varnish mixture flavor you prefer to bother with those kind of grits.  4-5 coats and a week or more to cure and that  protocol would yield some nice results. Especially the " or more time to cure " 2 or 3 weeks wouldn't hurt. 

Thanks to wdwerker for adding that info.  I apologize for being too brief.  Just as he says, you need enough of a film to be able to smooth it down without sanding through.  Just as important, the finish needs to be cured, cured, cured.  You should be seeing white dust once the mineral spirits finish off-gassing.  Is that a word?  I mean once the mineral spirits have "dried".  If you try to sand a finish too early you can get little gummy balls or leave trails in the finish instead of getting the smoothing effect you are after.

I didn't want to step on any toes but wanted to head off the disaster of that much effort on such a fresh and thin finish. Drew/Chestnut's mention of Festool's platin pads & mineral oil/mineral spirits is also valid on 5-6 coats of a well cured finish. 

Alder is kinda soft as is a danish oil finish. But if the coffee table is going to be put to everyday use & abuse that's kinda a good thing. It will acquire some nicks & dings which I think removes the caution associated with a piece of finer furniture. Use it and enjoy it for what it is. It is so easy to clean up and re-coat a Danish oiled ( or wiping varnished) piece. And if you use a colored Danish oil it will sort of highlight the nicks and dings to develop a graceful patina.

 If the recipients are shall we say a bit more " retentive " then more coats of finish, plenty of curing time, rubbing out and a life of habitually using coasters is equally valid. (Although I couldn't live that way.)

33 minutes ago, wdwerker said:

I didn't want to step on any toes but wanted to head off the disaster of that much effort on such a fresh and thin finish. Drew/Chestnut's mention of Festool's platin pads & mineral oil/mineral spirits is also valid on 5-6 coats of a well cured finish. 

Alder is kinda soft as is a danish oil finish. But if the coffee table is going to be put to everyday use & abuse that's kinda a good thing. It will acquire some nicks & dings which I think removes the caution associated with a piece of finer furniture. Use it and enjoy it for what it is. It is so easy to clean up and re-coat a Danish oiled ( or wiping varnished) piece. And if you use a colored Danish oil it will sort of highlight the nicks and dings to develop a graceful patina.

 If the recipients are shall we say a bit more " retentive " then more coats of finish, plenty of curing time, rubbing out and a life of habitually using coasters is equally valid. (Although I couldn't live that way.)

I guess i missed that it was an oil blend finish i saw oil in the name and the picture looked like a poly film finish. No toes stepped on i was offering an alternative, honestly your just stepping on Marc's toes if anything, i got the technique from him.

I've used it on as little as 4 coats of a wiping poly only 24 hours after with great results but i almost always leave 24 hours between finish coats. I don't know if that has an effect. Different finishes i believe cure at different rates so more details might be needed and adaptations to Steve's and Dubbs methods are probably needed.

Temperatures and humidity plus thickness of each coat affect drying and curing times greatly.  The amount of pressure & time you spend rubbing out a finish is another variable. Thin coats in a warm dry shop followed by a light touch carefully rubbing out can succeed on a shorter timeline. Thicker or even medium coats, cold shop etc and the longer wait times are smart. 

If you ever rub through a finish or smudge the finish w the heat & friction of too much pressure on a partially cured finish it's a painful error to recover from. So I err on the side of caution having learned the hard way. Learn from my mistakes or repeat them and learn a lesson you will never forget.

  • Author

Can’t make it to the home store till about Sunday ... however I have these 2000 grit pads. Would this work? DB03D6C4-5ED9-47CF-86AF-7F4616E399DA.thumb.jpeg.927561f55df2a00d99d7536273a95971.jpeg

 

AE7F6118-91D3-43F0-949A-9FF2A1DE303D.thumb.jpeg.28f7b34e893fc41e88742c85e4f80540.jpeg

@bushwacked can you be more specific about the finish you are using? While all the aforementioned advice is good for hard film finishes, you would need a gazillion coats of danish oil to achieve that. 

If you are using oil-based poly, then proceed as mentioned above, and this abralon pads should be fine.

If you really are using danish oil, my preferred application technique is to flood it on, and wet-sand it with 600+ grit to form a slurry. Let stand for 15-20 minutes, then wipe away the excess. Repeat after 8 hours, minimum. Re-coat as many times as needed to achieve the level of silkiness you prefer. I usually go 4 coats, at least.

  • Author
29 minutes ago, wtnhighlander said:

@bushwacked can you be more specific about the finish you are using? While all the aforementioned advice is good for hard film finishes, you would need a gazillion coats of danish oil to achieve that. 

If you are using oil-based poly, then proceed as mentioned above, and this abralon pads should be fine.

If you really are using danish oil, my preferred application technique is to flood it on, and wet-sand it with 600+ grit to form a slurry. Let stand for 15-20 minutes, then wipe away the excess. Repeat after 8 hours, minimum. Re-coat as many times as needed to achieve the level of silkiness you prefer. I usually go 4 coats, at least.

I use danish oil dark walnut. Applied per the instructions on the can. Flood on sit for 30 reapply sit for 15 and then wipe off. Wait 8 hours. I did that and first coat was great. 2nd time I did it is when it got rough. 

I think if you use that Abralon pad by hand to knock down the nibs it will do fine. It will knock the gloss down but another thin coat should fix that.

What you are describing sounds like dust settled into the wet second coat.

  • Author
1 hour ago, wdwerker said:

I think if you use that Abralon pad by hand to knock down the nibs it will do fine. It will knock the gloss down but another thin coat should fix that.

What you are describing sounds like dust settled into the wet second coat.

Steve .. I’m almost certain that is what happened. I think my wife may have come through and left a door open long enough to stir the dust into the air. 

I soaked the pad I have in mineral spirits and sanded. It seems to have knocked down all the nibs. I’ll take a look tomorrow and see how it looks in the daylight. I may add 1 more light coat if it looks off. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.