tlbrooks Posted January 8, 2018 Report Posted January 8, 2018 I know dust cyclones are all the rage right now but I have a PowerMatic PM1300TX-CK dust collectors and I'm in the process of moving into a new shop with my son. I was wondering if I would see any benefit in using an aftermarket cyclone when the PM1300TX-CK unit has a built in Turbo Cone cyclonic system? I'm guessing that the smaller Onieda units with the 2" ports won't be big enough, but what about building something using the larger units like the Onieda Dust Deputy? I believe it has at least 5" ports. Then maybe use a 35 gallon container to mount it on? I'll be mounting the dust collector on the second floor to free up space and help reduce noise and would put the cyclone directly below on the main floor to make it easier to empty. Any thoughts or ideas would be appreciated. Quote
minorhero Posted January 8, 2018 Report Posted January 8, 2018 If people see benefits from using the harbor freight dust collector and modifying it then you should see benefits here as well. Quote
Chestnut Posted January 8, 2018 Report Posted January 8, 2018 Yes it's going to help keep your filter cleaner. Oneida makes a larger cyclone with 5" or 6" ports designed to be used with a collector like yours. I also suggest doing some small sections of hard lines. Flex hose creates a lot of resistance. Quote
new2woodwrk Posted January 8, 2018 Report Posted January 8, 2018 I just got one this week (was on sale), set it up and attached it to my shop vac. There is not only a noticeable difference in the amount dust no longer floating around, but the filter container was practically empty as well I hooked it up to my new band saw, and it was a significant improvement! 2 Quote
derekcohen Posted January 11, 2018 Report Posted January 11, 2018 On 08/01/2018 at 6:42 PM, tlbrooks said: I know dust cyclones are all the rage right now but I have a PowerMatic PM1300TX-CK dust collectors and I'm in the process of moving into a new shop with my son. I was wondering if I would see any benefit in using an aftermarket cyclone when the PM1300TX-CK unit has a built in Turbo Cone cyclonic system? I'm guessing that the smaller Onieda units with the 2" ports won't be big enough, but what about building something using the larger units like the Onieda Dust Deputy? I believe it has at least 5" ports. Then maybe use a 35 gallon container to mount it on? I'll be mounting the dust collector on the second floor to free up space and help reduce noise and would put the cyclone directly below on the main floor to make it easier to empty. Any thoughts or ideas would be appreciated. This reply is the tip of the iceberg. In brief, you would be wasting your money if you are not also using 6" piping to your machines. You need at least 3 hp in the DC to make a significant difference using the Super Dust Deputy. Forget the small dust deputy with large machines. It is a toy. Others will likely chime in to enlarge upon the points I have made. Regards from Perth Derek Quote
drzaius Posted January 12, 2018 Report Posted January 12, 2018 18 hours ago, derekcohen said: Forget the small dust deputy with large machines. Where the small DD really shines is when connected to a good shop vac & used on small tools such as sanders & routers. Very little dust actually gets to the filter. A good dust collection strategy includes both a large ducted collector and a shop vac for the small stuff. Quote
derekcohen Posted January 12, 2018 Report Posted January 12, 2018 I don't think that is true. The DD (and similar) simply separate the big bits and make it easier to collect. The fine dust gets through, and this is what is dangerous - particles under 0.3 microns. Most (all?) shop vacs simply lack the filtration to clean the dusty air. Even the Hepa filtered Festool vac I have should be plumbed to feed outside the shop. I treat mine as a chip collector, not dust collector, when using a router. A good dust mask is important. Regards from Perth Derek 1 Quote
Chestnut Posted January 12, 2018 Report Posted January 12, 2018 I can't help but find irony in this. We're concerned about tiny particles of wood and yet there are a lot of people that still smoke a pack a day .... Also the N100 filters are 99.97% of 0.3 micron or larger so the same as HEPA ... it's the same filter https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/96-101/default.html Quote
drzaius Posted January 12, 2018 Report Posted January 12, 2018 22 minutes ago, derekcohen said: I don't think that is true. The DD (and similar) simply separate the big bits and make it easier to collect. The fine dust gets through, and this is what is dangerous - particles under 0.3 microns. Most (all?) shop vacs simply lack the filtration to clean the dusty air. Even the Hepa filtered Festool vac I have should be plumbed to feed outside the shop. I treat mine as a chip collector, not dust collector, when using a router. A good dust mask is important. Regards from Perth Derek The DD gets much more than the big bits. I have filled my shop vac 4 or 5 times with MDF dust (about as fine as it gets) before cleaning the HEPA filter in the shop vac. Even then it was not terribly clogged. I do wear a respirator but that's for the dust that doesn't get collected. the air that come out of my vac & dust collector is HEPA filtered & thus is just about as clean as it can be. Quote
derekcohen Posted January 12, 2018 Report Posted January 12, 2018 You cannot see the dangerous dust. It is not in the vac. A friend of mine, who ran the air filtrations for surgeries in hospitals, now retired, is a woodworker with a interest in dust collection in workshops. He has done much research, and the scary part is that shop vacs do not filter the dangerous dust - instead, they help move it around. Plus most DCs have leaks, and the fine dust escapes. The bottom line is that power tools create dangerous dust, and we need to pay attention. Regards from Perth Derek Quote
drzaius Posted January 12, 2018 Report Posted January 12, 2018 3 hours ago, derekcohen said: the scary part is that shop vacs do not filter the dangerous dust - instead, they help move it around. Plus most DCs have leaks, and the fine dust escapes. This is true of most. But if the shop vac has good sealing at the filter & it's a HEPA filter, then there's no place for the dust to get through. Same with a DC, the sealing between the blower & filter must be perfect. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted January 13, 2018 Report Posted January 13, 2018 I find this all very interesting, as I have worked in a steel mill for over 26 years, where every surface gets coated with fine mill scale or furnace dust within hours of being cleaned, and is apparently not considered "hazardous" by OSHA. Before we switched to a weekly vacuuming routine, the overhead cranes that feed scrap into the furnace would collect so much dust on their catwalks that a shovel was kept there to clear a way for the control enclosure doors to be opened. Used to be like walking on the beach .... if the beach was 160 degF, experiencing a Sahara-grade sandstorm, and 85 feet in the air. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.