Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Add a helical head or buy new planer

Featured Replies

I have a 25 year old 15" jet thickness planer. It is still working like new. Still no snipe. My only issue is I get tear out when working with figured wood. So I have a jet 32 drum sander that requires a vac. And my understanding is that a helical head can work without tearout. My neighbor has 2 machines with helical heads and has offered to let me try some curly. I will wait a week as he is out of town.

If it is a good idea to change the head then I can sell the drum sander and big vac. Could pay for most of the new head. And gain more space in my shop. Do I want to put a new head in an old but good working machine? 

Im not a high production shop. And I dont buy 4s wood. So the planer gets moderate and consistent use.

Is it difficult to make adjustments on the pieces of carbide?

 

 

 

 

  • Popular Post

I can only speak from my experience.  I am a one man hobbyist shop.  I do use a lot of figured wood and got tired of losing so much to spoil due to tear out.  I bought a used bandsaw from a pro who happened to have a Byrd Shelix head jointer and a Grizzly German head jointer in the shop so I got to compare them.  The Byrd is helical and the German head was just a spiral. There was no difference in the performance. That being said, I would wait to try it for yourself on your friend's machines.  That way you can decide for yourself.

The inserts "seat" in the head and register against reference surfaces so there is really no "aligning" per se.  When you eventually rotate the inserts (we're talking years in a one man hobby shop) you do need to make sure the seat is clean, clean, clean and that you torque the insert as per the manufacturer's spec.  If I recall correctly mine are 50 INCH pounds.  I have an INCH pound torque wrench in a small blow-mold case velcro'd to the back deck of my jointer.

I bought my jointer in 2008 and rotated for the first time in 2011.  I rotated to the fourth edge in 2021 but the jointer had been in storage for about a year so that is about right.  I did the math way back when before buying the jointer.  Based on my straight knife sharpening / replacing schedule the additional cost of the head paid for itself in about 18 months.  It has all been gravy since then.

Segmented carbide heads can leave a bit of a pattern but no worse than a straight knife machine.  The pattern is just different due to the overlapping inserts.  All jointers, planers, and other spinning head machines cut in an arc.  Some do it better than others.  More cuts per inch yield a better result than rushing through an operation.  When your buddy gets back take some of your problematic material to his shop and give it a whirl.

I think newly sharpened straight knives give a better finish off the machine but that only lasts for a certain number of feet before they are not "new" anymore.  In my shop the edge of a carbide insert lasts for years before I have to rotate.  There is definitely an initial cost shock but just do the math.  If you are not having your knives sharpened or replaced very often the cost savings will be different.  It was the loss of that perfect piece of figured cherry I wanted to use for an end table that drove me to insert heads. Your mileage may vary.

 

I can only tell you this much: 

On my last jointer, an older Delta,i converted from knives to a Shelix head and it was like a completely different machine afterwards - better cut quality, felt more solid through the cut, better overall experience. Plus no more knives to drive myself crazy trying to set. It was a massive improvement. 

But i don't work with a lot of figured stuff, beyond some moderately figured maple. I keep wanting to upgrade my planer too, but it's a pretty low priority. 

  • Popular Post

So I went through this over the last couple years as well. I have had a Hammer A3/31 for for about 20 years with straight Tersa knives and it has served me well. There is not an upgrade to spiral head from Hammer so I would have to had to go with a Byrd replacement head or upgrade. Before dropping the money on those I decided to try the tech out by buying an Oliver 12" benchtop planer with the segmented cutter. I was sold in about 30 seconds it would go through figured/ birds eye maple coming out like glass! To say I was impressed was an understatement. I recommend the machine to anyone who asks and while the price has increased a bit from the $899 I paid its still big bang for the buck and compared to head replacement can be competi8tive there as well. 

Full disclosure I did upgrade my Hammer to a new version of the same machine with silent head cutter and after trying it out today could not be happier.

Now I have to decide whether to sell the Oliver or keep it :D

Shelix, Byrd, German, spiral, segmented?  What are the differences?

  • Popular Post

Shelix and Byrd are brand names. 

Not sure what's meant by German, though my guess is that these types of cutter heads originated in Germany maybe?

Spiral and Helical are the two different types/shapes for the run of the cutters on the head. They're very similar looking. 

I believe that Segmented is more of a generic term to differentiate from a cutter with straight knives. It's 'segmented' into lots of little cutters instead of 2-3 knives. 

Correct me if I'm wrong, fellas!

  • Popular Post
On 5/18/2026 at 7:39 AM, Ron Swanson Jr. said:

Shelix and Byrd are brand names. 

Not sure what's meant by German, though my guess is that these types of cutter heads originated in Germany maybe?

Spiral and Helical are the two different types/shapes for the run of the cutters on the head. They're very similar looking. 

I believe that Segmented is more of a generic term to differentiate from a cutter with straight knives. It's 'segmented' into lots of little cutters instead of 2-3 knives. 

Correct me if I'm wrong, fellas!

Ron I believe this is correct.

  • Popular Post

Spiral cutters are mounted 90° to the wood feed and helical are mounted at an angle to slice more.

  • Author
On 5/17/2026 at 10:55 AM, curlyoak said:

My neighbor has 2 machines with helical heads and has offered to let me try some curly.

The curly oak with a lot of curl, machined perfect. Jointer and thickness planer. I'm selling my 16 32 jet drum sander and a vac to accommodate the dust. And considering which helical heads to get. The neighbor got his from bird.

Sugestions on brand to buy appreciated. At this point should I add new bearings?

  • Popular Post

I've heard good things and looked into FindBuyTool. The one for my Dewalt is cheaper than most others and is a helical.

Most replacement cutterheads I've seen come with new bearings. I looked up the Jet 15" and it appears that it doesn't. Bearings are a cheap replacement, so I would go ahead and do it.

  • Popular Post

I recommend pursuing a helical head for your planer . IMO, its ability to handle figured wood is impressive.  I put a Byrd Shelix on my DW735.  As mentioned above, the finish is not as nice from a new set of knives.  But that newness wears off quickly, and you'll likely be sanding the pieces anyways.  

I would treat the decision on your drum sander as a different issue - and one to be made later.  Yes, you might not need the drum sander to compensate for your planer tearout.  But the drum sander might find a different specific purpose - for instance, sanding resawn or veneer pieces off your bandsaw.

  • Author

Like many here, I suffer from small shop syndrome. If I sell the sander then I can sell the big vac and gain some precious space. And pay for the re-tooling. When I resaw I saw it a little bigger so the planer can resolve the saw marks. Also the sander boggs down when sanding wider parts, A 12" wide piece would require three passes before I crank the drum down a tiny bit. All 16 32's are underpowered...

  • Popular Post

Drum and belt sanders, like miter saws and radial arm saws, require a hefty footprint.  If they are not paying their way I would swap them out for free space or some machine that will help me more.  When I was in a 2 car garage-shop I did quite the dance routine to get from behind the tablesaw over to my bench so I know of what you speak.  I have never swapped out a standard head for another type so I am no help there.  I did just go through some milling of reversing grain material and was once again pleased with the result.  I think you are headed in the right direction and your choices for a head are much better today then back when I bought my native insert-head machines.  I will be watching with interest and wish you the best on your quest.

  • Author
  • Popular Post

I pulled the trigger and ordered 2 byrd helicals for my jointer and my thickness planer. For both around $1600. Including new bearings and other parts. And I will get 850 for my sander and vac. At one point I was considering building a closet for the sander and vac. Both on wheels for $4000. And now with the new heads I can do the same work much faster. And gain a few square feet of shop space. And spend less money than I was originally considering.

Now the wait for the heads...

  • Author

Time to slow my roll. The head for the planer is 6 to 8 weeks. At least I get the head for the jointer in 2 to 3 weeks...

To be continued...

  • Popular Post

Tick, tick, tick . . . I remember we used to say the longest few minutes in your life was waiting for the Xerox machine to warm up.  Then it switched to waiting for the computer to boot up.  Now I stand in front of the microwave and scream "come on!!!".

  • Popular Post
On 6/1/2026 at 4:01 PM, curlyoak said:

I pulled the trigger and ordered 2 byrd helicals for my jointer and my thickness planer.

Don't you hate it when the video you need shows up the day after you pull the trigger?

tldr;

  • highly recommended
  • pricey for a hobbyist, but cheaper over (a long) time
  • Some gotchas to be aware of, mostly about rotating or replacing cutters

 

  • Author

The planer and jointer have been and still are in service. I just have to wait until the helical comes in.The heat is slowing me down. 

The jointer has solid carbide knives. Does that make them valuable?

 

  • 4 weeks later...
  • Author
  • Popular Post

IMG_1827.thumb.jpeg.a9d06f79b46115fbf1387eada52bfb44.jpeg

For the jointer. Still waiting for the planer head.

 

The cutter on the far right in your photo is oriented differently from the others.  Is that supposed to be so?

  • Author
On 7/3/2026 at 9:24 AM, Mark J said:

The cutter on the far right in your photo is oriented differently from the others.  Is that supposed to be so?

I noticed that. Not sure at the moment. It should be easy to adjust if needed.

On 7/3/2026 at 9:12 AM, curlyoak said:

I noticed that. Not sure at the moment. It should be easy to adjust if needed.

Yes, it is supposed to be staggered like that and it can't be adjusted.  It's seated in that position and cant be moved.  The shelix I bought many years ago was the same way.  This is the difference between a helical head, which you've got here, and a spiral head.  At least, to my knowledge. 

I think that most folks contend that helical is the better design.  But don't quote me on that. 

  • Popular Post
On 7/3/2026 at 6:24 AM, Mark J said:

The cutter on the far right in your photo is oriented differently from the others.  Is that supposed to be so?

On 7/3/2026 at 7:23 AM, Ron Swanson Jr. said:

I think that most folks contend that helical is the better design.  But don't quote me on that. 

That cutter is the furthest from the fence and if I remember it has something to do rabbeting on you jointer if you do that sort of thing.  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.