Von Posted September 18 Report Posted September 18 The smoke detector in my workshop tends to false alarms. Anyone know of a good smoke detector for a workshop? I've heard of heat detectors being an alternative but don't have any experience with them. TIA Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted September 18 Report Posted September 18 On 9/18/2026 at 6:53 PM, Von said: The smoke detector in my workshop tends to false alarms. Anyone know of a good smoke detector for a workshop? I've heard of heat detectors being an alternative but don't have any experience with them. TIA Do you have a fire risk out there, or just being cautious? Either way, sorry. No. I don't have one in my shop but if I did it would likely just be a run of the mill jobber off the shelf. 1 Quote
gee-dub Posted September 19 Report Posted September 19 The detection technology is the handicap. I do not run detectors in my shop but, I do have cameras. I also have extinguishers at every door. They are handy if I am going in to deal with something and they are handy if I have made it to the exit, exhausted the extinguisher, and have decided to run for it. 2 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted September 19 Report Posted September 19 @Von, there are several fire / smoke detection technologies on the market, but some run into real $$$ to install. I would start by evaluation what makes the detector you have trigger falsely. If it is the typical home detector, I believe it can be triggered by any fine enough particulate in the air. A heat sensor may be a better fit, but has drawbacks of its own. The basic type would false trigger on a hot day in my small, un-conditioned space. The type that measures rate of temperature rise would be more reliable. See here: https://www.alarmsystemstore.com/collections/heat-detectors?srsltid=AU7gw4UPaW_omdN-6WtNyT9jAoT9CcceNy45wkhhAp6oUXJAKqwbhUG8 At work, we use digital video cameras with thermal imagers to detect fire. Tricky, since in a steel mill, lots of stuff is SUPPOSED to be on fire. The algorithm examines absolute temp, temp rise rate, and image movement. Does an amazing job, if positioned appropriately to the desired field of view, but now we're talking industrial-grade expense... 2 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted September 19 Report Posted September 19 I believe that there are two types of home smoke alarms. One gets triggered by smoke blocking a beam of light, so dust will set it off. The other gets triggered by ionized particles in the air, so it will get set off when something gets hot. The ionization type is better in a wood shop, I assume, but it can still be set off if your feed rate burns the wood (EG, cherry). Some detectors have both types. 1 Quote
Von Posted September 19 Author Report Posted September 19 1 hour ago, Ron Swanson Jr. said: Do you have a fire risk out there, or just being cautious? Nothing atypical for a hobbyist wood worker. Cutting certain types of pre-finished plywood seems to trigger the detector. As I believe as is called for by our local code, a smoke detector was installed in our garage and is hardwired and synced to all the others in the house, so when it goes off, the alarm is house-wide and really disruptive. Thanks for the feedback all, I will look into ionizing smoke and heat detectors. 1 Quote
Popular Post Botch Posted September 19 Popular Post Report Posted September 19 Somewhat related, just happened yesterday/today: I have a single Kidde smoke detector in the bedroom hallway, and yesterday morning it issued a hideous shriek, scared the sawdust out of me. Only once. I checked the gas stove, oven, workshop, and furnace and couldn't smell anything unusual. About four hours later it happened again, and scared me again. I took it off the wall, it had instructions to disassemble by "Twist this way", but I couldn't get it apart. I put it out in my porch inside my BGE ceramic cooker to muffle the sound; it shrieked one more time but hasn't gone off at all today. There was a red diode that was supposed to flash when the battery got low, but it never did; I remember older detectors would issue a loud "chirp" (always at 1:30 am!) to tell you to replace the battery; I'm wondering if they've changed the warning to be more "urgent"? I don't have a separate smoke/heat detector in my basement workshop (fire extinguisher there and in my kitchen), maybe I should look into that. Will be following this thread, thanks. 3 Quote
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted September 19 Popular Post Report Posted September 19 Why is it that smoke detector batteries always get 'low' between midnight and 2:00 am? Every. Single. Time. Especially if you have a house dog that freaks at the chirping sound. 1 3 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted September 19 Popular Post Report Posted September 19 On 9/18/2026 at 11:51 PM, wtnhighlander said: Why is it that smoke detector batteries always get 'low' between midnight and 2:00 am? The 10 year batteries have saved my sanity. They still chirp at 2am, but at least it only happens once a decade. I change all of them when one starts chirping. 3 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted September 19 Popular Post Report Posted September 19 On 9/18/2026 at 11:42 PM, Botch said: it issued a hideous shriek I found this: seems to indicate it detected a fire and then it didn't. False alarm? 3 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted September 19 Author Popular Post Report Posted September 19 7 hours ago, wtnhighlander said: Why is it that smoke detector batteries always get 'low' between midnight and 2:00 am? Every. Single. Time. Especially if you have a house dog that freaks at the chirping sound. And don't you love the "which detector is chirping?" game staggering around the house half-asleep while trying to manage the freaked out dog. Given how important they are, smoke detectors easily win my "worst user interface" award. 4 Quote
Mark J Posted September 19 Report Posted September 19 All of the above. All our detectors in our new house are 10 year battery type. When we hit the 9 year mark we're just gonna move. Seriously, I don't think home type detectors are going to be very compatible with a wood shop, just as they aren't generally placed in a kitchen. But what does @Coop, our resident expert, think? 1 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted September 19 Popular Post Report Posted September 19 On 9/19/2026 at 9:55 AM, Mark J said: Seriously, I don't think home type detectors are going to be very compatible with a wood shop I used to get a lot of alarms in my shop, so I just checked to see how I solved the problem. Sure enough, I removed the smoke detector. Problem solved! 4 Quote
Popular Post Coop Posted September 19 Popular Post Report Posted September 19 If the issue was with a fire extinguisher, fire suppression system or foam for a runway, I could offer an educated guess but I’m as ignorant and frustrated as the next guy. And @Von, I thought our dog was the only one that went crazy when the batteries were low. 3 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted September 19 Report Posted September 19 On 9/19/2026 at 4:04 PM, Coop said: I thought our dog was the only one that went crazy when the batteries were low. I'm no expert, but I bet you could train a puppy not to freak out to a low battery chirp, but instead come get you and lead you to the chirping detector. Hint, replace the battery with a variable voltage power supply, so you can trigger the low battery chirp whenever you want for training. 2 Quote
pkinneb Posted September 20 Report Posted September 20 On 9/18/2026 at 10:51 PM, wtnhighlander said: Especially if you have a house dog that freaks at the chirping sound. LOL so true... 1 Quote
TomBexley Posted September 21 Report Posted September 21 Since yours is hardwired into the whole house system, I'd be reluctant to swap detector types based only on what works in a detached hobby shop. First, get the exact model number that's installed and see what the manufacturer allows at that location. The fact that cutting certain prefinished plywood sets it off is useful. I'd also check whether dust collection and air movement are carrying the fine stuff directly toward the detector. Moving the source of the nuisance may be easier than giving up smoke detection entirely. A rate of rise heat detector sounds interesting, but I'd want to know what your local code and the alarm manufacturer allow before changing a device that's interconnected with the house. 2 Quote
Von Posted November 1 Author Report Posted November 1 I ordered a https://flamedetector.com/. Got it today and got it set up. While I had success, it was a little annoying. The product used to be known as "Eye Detekt" and they have renamed it. Problem is all the directions in the packaging refers to eyedetekt.com and the "Eye Detekt" app, neither of which exist any more. So you have to remember an email you got when you ordered it and go look for the app under the new name. It's an IOT device that wants to connect to your wifi and have you create an account. By default, it steered me to a username and passkey, which would have been fine, but I couldn't get to work, registration kept breaking. Fortunately good old username/email address and password as an option and worked. So in theory it's set up now and I can see the detector on my phone. Next time the dog is out of the house, so I don't freak them out, I'll give it a test and then get it mounted in the shop. 2 Quote
Popular Post Biotec Posted November 4 Popular Post Report Posted November 4 @Von I recently retired from the university and we use commercial smoke and heat detectors for labs and 4 mechanical rooms They were around 300 to 400 dollars each They were addressable so you knew exactly what space they went off in but that's part of a general fire alarm system Very expensive. This is a residential one. Less than $80. The Honeywell Home PROSIXSMOKEV provides photoelectric smoke detection and both fixed temperature and rate-of-rise heat detection for a Honeywell Home PROA7PLUS Alarm Panel. It includes an 85 dB sounder, and it supports One Go All Go functionality. Read more: https://www.alarmgrid.com/products/honeywell-home-prosixsmokev The alarm will sound if temperatures rise above 135 degree F. The Kidde HD135 degree From home despot Firex Hardwired Interconnected 120V AC Wire Auxiliary Heat Detector About $50 My garage where I work as what I would call a confined space only ingress egress is the garage door itself. I do most of my wood cutting outside. On the driveway apron. I do find Sanding and Scroll work and some woods seem to be a little more smoky than others My ceiling is approximately 8 feet and is closed so there's no ventilation Just the garage door itself be open. 3 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.