Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

I always thought a table saw's main duty was ripping!

Featured Replies

How wrong I was....or maybe how wrong the old guys I did my apprenticeship with were 38 years ago.

I am thinking a lot of people prefer using a large bandsaw for ripping, table saw for a crosscut sled, dovetail jigs, box joints, half lapped joints, dado and rabbit work and the list goes on. Does anyone use it for rips?

I don't have a band saw (well, I have a little table top one for crafts and small pieces) to the TS gets all the ripping duty in my shop.

I use a bandsaw all the time for ripping. Of course, my options are a bit limited, as I don't have a table saw. ^_^

In Marc's last Wood Whisperer episode on his calendar frame project he uses a bandsaw for ripping, and mentions that he does this on the bandsaw more often these days.

I'll +1 for ripping on the BS, both for (at least the 'feeling' of) safety, along with minimizing waste (I do segmented turning with expensive exotics).. Mind you, I don't have what I would consider to be a 'great' TS either..

Im thinking that using a bandsaw is more for rough ripping. I dont have a bandsaw so my tablesaw gets all ripping duties.

One thing about woodworking is anyone can use a saw or other shop machine but there is more to it than wood cutting. You need to understand the wood in order to work it. Look at the wood and then decide what machine fits the job. Not everyone has both machines but if you do just think about the wood before picking the machine, there is no one machine does it all.

Don

Yeah I should clarify that I only do "rough rips" at the bandsaw. These are the types of rips that would be the most dangerous at the tablesaw. And even with my fancy Resaw King blade, the finish cut from the bandsaw is not nearly as good as the finish cut from my tablesaw. So I do still use the TS for rips. But only after I am close to final dimension.

With the right blade in a table saw a rip cut can be ready for a glue up. That would probably never happen using a band saw. I occasionally use the band saw to rip a board but it must go to the jointer if I want a smooth edge.

But only after I am close to final dimension.

I think this subject would make a good video when you get the time. I think there are many folks that dont understand how to dimension lumber properly.

Don

I use my TS for ripping and crosscutting, along with other things. It's the most used power tool in my shop except for the DC. My TS is more accurate at crosscuts than my miter saw, and is usually more convenient if the piece isn't over 6 feet long.

I've been using my bandsaw more then my tablesaw for ripping lately. No chance of lifting or kickback and thinner kerf than the thinnest TS blade. The Kreg fence is awesome for this too.

Setup is a little more cumbersome if you have to change blades though... and as has been pointed out, you have to clean up the cut on the jointer or planer (or hand plane or whatever)

-Jim

I've been using my bandsaw more then my tablesaw for ripping lately. No chance of lifting or kickback and thinner kerf than the thinnest TS blade. The Kreg fence is awesome for this too.

Setup is a little more cumbersome if you have to change blades though... and as has been pointed out, you have to clean up the cut on the jointer or planer (or hand plane or whatever)

-Jim

Jim - Doesn't cleaning up the cut negate most (or all) of the difference in kerf width between the BS blade and a thin kerf TS blade?

Jim - Doesn't cleaning up the cut negate most (or all) of the difference in kerf width between the BS blade and a thin kerf TS blade?

Sort of depends on the blade you are using. If you are using a finer tooth blade on the bandsaw (something higher then a 3 or 4 tooth) it can make a pretty clean cut with a slow feed rate, usually not quite as clean as the TS. Depending on the wood, and what the piece is for, I can get away with a quick sanding with a high grit sanding block sometimes...

-Jim

  • 1 month later...

I do almost all my ripping on my ts. If I need to rip a 4x4 for some reason, I will use the bs.

For anything the ts will rip, I can't imagine using the bs and having to use the jointer to clean up the cut.

I want to rip a board, and be done with it.

if the board is less than 8" wide, I'll flatten one face and one edge then rip it on the TS. The only time I use the BS for ripping is when I can't flatten a board that is too wide for my jointer and need to rip it in its rough state.

It boils down to using the right tool for the job and making the most out of material. Ripping cupped boards on a tablesaw is an accident waiting to happen. Just jointing a board to get rid of a cup then ripping is generally a waste of material. Each board and cut needs to be looked at on an individual basis, there is no one size fits all.

Don

It boils down to using the right tool for the job and making the most out of material. Ripping cupped boards on a tablesaw is an accident waiting to happen. Just jointing a board to get rid of a cup then ripping is generally a waste of material. Each board and cut needs to be looked at on an individual basis, there is no one size fits all.

Don

Honestly, I've never had a nice band saw until now. A few months ago, I purchased a Jet 18" off of CL. I've never thought of ripping with it. I've always had a TS so that's what I used. Never thought about cupped boards Don, the TS was what I used because it was what I had. Irregular rough boards or cupped boards on the BS...makes sense.

So if you rip with the band saw, what blade do you use? - width, #teeth and brand

If you rip with the TS, what blade do you use to get the smooth finish with minimal cleanup? #teeth and brand please.

As I mentioned, I have to do all my ripping on a bandsaw since I don't have a table saw. ^_^

I use a 1/2" 3 tpi Timberwolf blade from Suffolk Machinery. Then I hit the edge with a hand plane. It takes me less than a minute to clean up the edge, and the resulting edge is better than what comes off of any table saw.

That blade is what I use for >90% of my bandsawing needs. The only time I change the blade is if I have to cut a curve that is too tight for the 1/2" blade to handle.

As I mentioned, I have to do all my ripping on a bandsaw since I don't have a table saw. ^_^

I use a 1/2" 3 tpi Timberwolf blade from Suffolk Machinery. Then I hit the edge with a hand plane. It takes me less than a minute to clean up the edge, and the resulting edge is better than what comes off of any table saw.

That blade is what I use for >90% of my bandsawing needs. The only time I change the blade is if I have to cut a curve that is too tight for the 1/2" blade to handle.

Wilbur,

What do you use to make one edge parallel to the other? I have a table saw but to be honest I hate using it because it scares me a little everytime I go to rip a board. Makes nice crosscuts but it seems like kind of a waste. I was thinking about selling it and using the proceeds to put toward a TS55.

James

Wilbur,

What do you use to make one edge parallel to the other? I have a table saw but to be honest I hate using it because it scares me a little everytime I go to rip a board. Makes nice crosscuts but it seems like kind of a waste. I was thinking about selling it and using the proceeds to put toward a TS55.

James

I think you need a better ts. I have an old Unisaur, and rips are a piece of cake, and are ready for glueup, straight from the saw.

I can't imagine not having a good ts in my shop, and having to set up a track saw for every cut. Especially on small pieces.

Honestly, I've never had a nice band saw until now. A few months ago, I purchased a Jet 18" off of CL. I've never thought of ripping with it. I've always had a TS so that's what I used. Never thought about cupped boards Don, the TS was what I used because it was what I had. Irregular rough boards or cupped boards on the BS...makes sense.

So if you rip with the band saw, what blade do you use? - width, #teeth and brand

If you rip with the TS, what blade do you use to get the smooth finish with minimal cleanup? #teeth and brand please.

I use a 1 1/4 resaw king and ww2 blades almost exclusively. One thing i learned years ago. The closer you get yourself to final dimension the safer. For example making stiles and rails out of a cupped one by. The first cuts for me are rough length then rough width, then joint and plane. The final cuts are always done on the table saw. I never rely on a table saw to get a jointed edge for glue up but thats a different subject all together.

Don

I use a 1 1/4 resaw king and ww2 blades almost exclusively. One thing i learned years ago. The closer you get yourself to final dimension the safer. For example making stiles and rails out of a cupped one by. The first cuts for me are rough length then rough width, then joint and plane. The final cuts are always done on the table saw. I never rely on a table saw to get a jointed edge for glue up but thats a different subject all together.

Don

"Resaw king"...is that a Laguna blade? What is ww2?

What is your table saw blade that gives the smoothest finish?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.