Recommended Posts

Posted

I spent a little over an hour trying to flatten the back on my new 1.5" Bacho chisel with my Shapton stones. I progressed from 500 to 2000 to 8000. The first quarter of an inch behind the edge.is a.perfect mirror,then there is about an inch of "hazy mirror" and then back to a perfect mirror. Is this a problem because I know that seeing this means my back I not Dead flat. Should I just go back to the 500 stone and work my way back up through the grits again? I think this set will last me a very long time and I only want to have to flatten the backs once so I think it would be pretty cool if I could get the backs on each and every chisel to be a perfect mirror finish. Is this a pipe dream or common place amongst the pros?

Posted

I find that a mirror edge on the back of a chicel or plane blade is not really neccesary. I find that a flat back is more important, and if your chisel dips after a quarter inch I think you may have a problem registering your chisel on a work piece in some cases. To flattten the back of my chisel and planes I find it easiest to use sand paper (aluminum oxide) on the flatest surface avaliable; I use an offcut of a granite counter top. I start with a 180 and work there until I have a consistent scratch pattern across the entire back then i work all the way up 600 grit and stop there. At the end I put the chisel or plane blade down on the surface and try to fit a .0015 feeler quage under the area I have flatened If the guage doesnt go under the blade job well done and now I move onto sharpening. Check out http://tatteredjeansandsawdust.blogspot.com/2011/09/dull-day.html to see the full process with pictures.

Cheers and hope this helps

Hans Christopher

Posted

From what you are describing, I think your chisels are good to go. By the time you wear the chisel down to the hazy area, you'll be so good at sharpening that it will be trivial to get it to the point that you want.

And my bet is that by then, you'll have figured out that perfect flatness on the back of a chisel is overrated.

Posted

If you do decide you want to polish the back, remember to get a consistent scratch pattern before moving on to the next grit. And don't make too large of a jump between grits, e.g., from 220 to 600. I usually go through the following grits (sandpaper) when flattening/polishing the back of a chisel - 220, 320, 400, 600, 1000, 2000. I don't go beyond 2000.

I agree with the others that polishing the entire back isn't necessary for function, but I do it partly for aesthetics reasons and practice; it also satisfies that OCD part of me. I've learned quite a bit this way through trial and error - the best teacher.

Also, moving up through the finer grits, to 8000 for instance, isn't just a matter of aesthetics. You're creating a sharper edge by bringing the two planes (the back and the bevel) closer to that ideal zero radius, which of course you'll never reach, and the entire back obviously doesn't need that level of polish to accomplish that. The question is how sharp is sharp enough...

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

before and after...

As a few of the others have already said I think you're in great shape. Based off of the before and after pic I don't see any reason that you should worry. I will typically only end up with about the first 1.5" polished to a shine on my chisels, but for me that's fine as I rarely ever do anything that would require me to register the chisel much deeper than that.

Posted

As a few of the others have already said I think you're in great shape. Based off of the before and after pic I don't see any reason that you should worry. I will typically only end up with about the first 1.5" polished to a shine on my chisels, but for me that's fine as I rarely ever do anything that would require me to register the chisel much deeper than that.

I wouldn't worry at all about were you are Brian. By the looks of the picture I would say that you are in pretty good shape.

I agree that Brian looks to be in good shape, but what about his chisel? :P

Posted

before and after...

Brian -

When they say you should be able to shave with it, they are only talking about replacing the razor, not the mirror :-)

As long as the front 1/4" or so is "mirroresque", you should be fine.

"Grind, hone, get back to work" - The Schwarz.

Jonathan

===============================

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.