Recommended Posts

Posted

Had a friend (contractor), who has been professionally using table saws for years, lose his index finger and a chunk of his thumb in a TS accident. He doesn't even know what went wrong, and I don't want to press. His wife says that he is very gun shy about getting back out to the shop.

Even though I've never had a serious mishap with the TS, I ordered a Sawstop yesterday. The above incident factored heavily into the decision, but so did the fact that I have three daughters that may want to learn woodworking some day. The thought of one of the girls getting hurt...and it could have been prevented with a Sawstop, well, the extra money has finally become worth the piece of mind.

I think I will keep my Delta, and use it as a dedicated dado device, to save blade changes.

Be safe.

Posted

Sorry to hear about your friend. Stories like his are always difficult to hear, as it honestly could be any of us

I made the switch last December, after using SawStop saws in other shops. I sold my y2K General 650 on Craigslist, for what I paid for it in 2000. It sold in three days, to the first caller... I kept my Excalibur overarm guard to install on the new saw.

Depending on how old your Delta is, the biggest difference you may see on the new saw is the riving knife. Riving knives are fantastic, both safety and accuracy-wise, probably the best update to table saws in 50-60 years. Truth told, it was the riving knife that got me saw shopping, and after using a few examples, I went all the way to SawStop.

Work safe, and I wish your friend a speedy and complete as possible recovery.

Posted

There is nothing wrong with that! It is a shame that there seems to be this strange peer pressure out there regarding Sawstop. I think it is similar to helmets in hockey. No matter how many people were hurt from bouncing their head off the ice several people were either too "tough" to make the switch or had the "it will never happen to me because X" attitude.

I was able to take a class from a guy that owns both a sawstop and a powermatic of equal HP and size. The truth is that there is that for the price you pay the quality of the saw alone is worth it - making the added safety free.

In the end it is a personal choice to either go with the added safety or not. Regardless of what choice someone makes, it is their choice - and it is the right choice because they are choosing to work wood!

  • Like 2
Posted

i know its safer but how does the saw perform in a regular rating the craftsmen we use at school the riving knife needs to be ajust alot. and the motor can bog down when im runing a board and a shop vac on the same plug. and i dont care for the blade guards that is on the machine.

Posted

Saw Stop is still unique to the TS world and therefore it's still a little expensive. But......one mistake on your part or one of your daughters!!!....and the deployment of the mechanism....it wouldn't matter if the saw had cost you $10,000. Through the years, I've had some near misses where I just got just a little complacent. In 'the old days' I rarely used a push stick. Now I use them on the most basic, seemingly harmless cuts.

Posted

The reviews I've read say that the Sawstop is comparable in quality to other saws in that price range. The safety feature is essentially free.

The problem is that the brake action is very forceful. In order to withstand a braking event without throwing things off-kilter, the saw has to be built like a tank. So, you can get the Sawstop brake in a high end saw that's built like a tank, but not in a lower end saw.

At least, that's what I've read. I haven't been in a position to compare the saws side by side.

Posted

Do seatbelts teach complacently? They save you from serious injury. See, you just have to teach people to drive without having accidents. There is no need for them.

Just think what would happen if a bunch of lawyers got together and made us wear them when we drive. It be the end of the world.

It seems to me most people don't like saw stop because someone came up with a great idea, that works, and it wasn't them.

  • Like 1
Posted

I have to disagree with you as well MTK. The SawStop feature is just another form of risk mitigation and does not introduce complacency. As an air traffic controller I have seen my fair share of complacency both from controllers and pilots and any time there is an opportunity to mitigate the risk by implementing a procedure or control measure, it is 99 out 100 times implemented. The only time it isn't utiltized is when the control measure introduces other risk. Human factors are just part of life and the probablity that someone is going to put their finger in the saw blade is high. You don't have to agree with the SawStop technology but to say that it teaches or invites complacency is not a valid statement IMHO. I do agree that any of the other power tools in the shop are also dangerous. The good news is that if you don't have a SawStop table saw if you don't want one...so far :)

  • Like 1
Posted

Please - just for my personal sanity, read all of the previous Sawstop threads in this forum. Then, if you have something to say that hasn't been said four times before, please feel free.

Marc bans discussions of religion and politics, and these sorts of Sawstop discussions often have the same flavor.

This is not me as a moderator speaking - this is me as someone who's thinking, "Oh no! Not another Sawstop thread!"

  • Like 1
Posted

i would love to put a saw through its paces to find out how well it works through all kinds of posibble acidents. but im not willing to spend 5k for the cost of hotdogs to find out if they work. oh and the cost of the saw. and as for complantacy well anyone that can stay perfectely calm around a high speed disc of razor sharp metal is asking for a acident. i dont think this topic will ever stop coming up because everyone who sees the videos of the saw stoping has question and worries because it seems so unbelievable. at least untill other companies start making it or untill everyone has a saw stop.

Posted

Please.....oh please make it stop............the voices - they just won't go away.....

:)

Please take Beechwood's advice - lots of SS posts on all the points made here. As for your last point - just Google it, I believe it was done.....

Posted

"To Google I go!"

The wife hates it when I say that but I think she is just jealous that I can search better than she can :)

For completeness you should also watch Tom's "kickback" video where he simulates a kickback. Of course in a supposedly controlled test he STILL almost got seriously injured. It was that movement that he tried to replicate when he slapped the sausage onto the blade.

Posted

To the OP, I doubt you will ever regret buying a SawStop from what I understand they are very good saws and as a new dad (10 day old girl) I would not even think twice about buying a SawStop if I were in your shoes. It sounds like you made the right choice. On the contrary if you did not get a SawStop and one of your daughters put their hand in the moving blade, well I am sure you would never forgive yourself.

Posted

It was kind of funny reading this, this morning...earlier in the week, I typed a response to this thread that basically said the same thing as I said above but I added the part, "Want to make WTO Administrators get a little tense? SHOULD THE GOVERNMENT MANDATE.....NOOOOOOO......NOT ANOTHER 'LEGISLATE THE TABLE SAW INDUSTRY DISCUSSION!!!!" Now the cat is out of the bag and you guys have already said it, I'll echo...search it out on WTO....we have already beaten the issue silly and almost threw mahogany scraps at each other. Radio or silence, TV or Journey blasting in the shop, your wife, best friend, or kid talking to you....you have to keep your head in it every saw cut, every router cut, every chisel cut - period. My guess is the StopSaw (whoever you are, your wife immortalized the new name for me)....the StopSaw with a hand slap would probably inflict at least some type of injury as it deployed. Heck, I'm with James, any type of mitigation technology is welcomed. Richard Petty at one time, drove with a lap belt only and God only knows why more drivers didn't die through the early years of NASCAR. Now, our passenger cars are constantly re-engineered to be stronger and safer.

I am TimWood and I approved this message.

Posted

Has anyone who believes SawStop technology teaches complacency ever actually used a SawStop?

I bought mine as my fourth table saw, and second cabinet saw, in about 17 years of woodworking. I am extremely comfortable around power tools. It's been over a year since I first personally used a SS, and about 10 months since I bought my own. My experience is that the presence of the flesh sensing has absolutely no bearing whatsoever on how I approach a spinning set of carbide teeth.

The only thing that's changed using my SawStop vs. the mighty General 650 I used for the previous twelve years, is that now I have to remember and activate bypass mode, before zipping through a bunch of brads or pins, or recently glued stock that might still have a damp center.

The General 650 is a very well respected, pro quality, Canadian-made cabinet saw. My SS is a far better saw, with a true riving knive, flatter table, less arbor runout, a far better mobile base, and vastly improved dust collection. Another improvement over the 650 is the power system. Every time I changed blades on the General, I had to do a lap around the saw to unplug it, and another to plug it back in. Right below the SawStop's blade wrench hangers, something else missing on the General, is a handy power disconnect. So, within reach of the operator's position are three distinct power switches. With three switches off, I have no problem changing a blade without unplugging.

  • Like 1
Posted

I have to remember and activate bypass mode, before zipping through [...] recently glued stock that might still have a damp center.

CPB,

Has the indicator light ever signalled that the brake would have fired on damp stock? I've heard that while it's theoretically possible, and a good idea to bypass just in case, in practice it happens rarely or never.

There are so many rumors about the Sawstop, I like to get first hand experience whenever possible.

Thanks

Posted

I am not complacent with my SS. Not only do I fear the small chance that the device may for some reason not trigger, I don't like the idea of spending $180 to replace the brake and blade. And I sure hope it never triggers with my dado stack!!

RE: Wet lumber - because the manufacture states not to cut wet lumber and nails/brads I believe it to be true. If they did not believe it would trigger they would not warn against it - which shows one of the negatives to the technology.

Posted

RE: Wet lumber - because the manufacture states not to cut wet lumber and nails/brads [...]

Note, the manufacturer says that you should cut wet lumber in bypass mode, not that you shouldn't cut it at all.

I know that wet lumber or brads might trigger it, and that the manufacturer says to run it in bypass mode just to be safe. And I plan to put mine in bypass mode if there's any question. One cut in bypass mode will show whether the brake would have gone off, and then I can turn off bypass mode if I want.

What I'm asking is whether the bypass mode indicates that the detector "went off" when cutting wet wood: often, sometimes, or never. From what I understand about the technology, you'd have to have a pretty good conductor between the blade and the operator, and wood would have to be very wet to qualify. Even a brad won't trigger it unless you are touching the brad at the same time. I'm pretty sure in the hot dog demos the operator is holding the hot dog. Although a hot dog might have enough capacitance to trigger it on its own.

But, that's just theory, so I was wondering if people had actual experience. I haven't cut any wet wood or brads on mine.

Maybe I'll go downstairs, turn on bypass mode, and do some experiments.

  • Like 1
Posted

Wow - hot topic.

I would buy a sawstop tomorrow if the budget allowed it. I used the 3hp version at lee valley during a course, and I was sold. The machine operates smooth as silk, with a great fence and superb DC. It just screams quality. This alone is enough reason to buy it. Of course, the safety features put it in a class of it's own. I am jealous of all the SS owners out there! My day will come (cyclone first, sawstop second).

Posted

CPB,

Has the indicator light ever signalled that the brake would have fired on damp stock? I've heard that while it's theoretically possible, and a good idea to bypass just in case, in practice it happens rarely or never.

I can't comment on that, as I don't often work with wet, damp, or pressure treated wood. I only use stock dried to levels suitable for furniture and sheet goods.

I'll bypass for the rare occasions when cutting brads or glue-ups that might not be fully dried. I don't bother to test in these instances, as the conductive areas are not contiguous. It's not a bother to bypass here, because I'm also taking a moment to install a beater blade. When I'm working with wet or construction grade lumber, I'm usually not in the shop, but outdoors and using my circular saw and CMS.

I have accidentally hit single or small numbers of brads, and luckily, the saw did not fire. As I understand it, for the saw to fire, the metal or moisture needs to be in contact with both the blade, and the human or table. If it's fully encased in wood, it apparently doesn't trigger the brake.

I've been told the three examples at my busy local woodworking school have fired a total of twice in the past 5 years. Once was a student using the wrong miter slot running an aluminum miter guage into the blade, the other was actual flesh contact.

Posted

Honestly the Sawstop is a first rate tablesaw anyway so even without the blade brake it's not a bad choice. If I ever decide to get a new TS it will be fairly high on the list of contenders anyway so I don't think I'd be reluctant to purchase one. I'd feel different if the blade brake was all they had going for them but they have a pretty nice TS all around by everything I've seen.

I'm moving away from using a TS as much as I can, though there are still some things that the TS just does easier/faster/simpler then I can do with hand or hand power tools. Eventually I'd like to do away with the TS entirely and not need to worry about it at all but for now my Ridgid does what I need it to. Wish it had a riving knife though, I think I'd like that feature and better dust collection even more then the blade brake...

-Jim

Posted

I'll reply by staying to the spirit of the OP's post without getting into all the other stuff that makes people respond with, "oh, no! not another SawStop thread!" Just a month ago, I had a table saw accident. I nearly cut off my pointer finger while removing an off-cut from the blade while it was still running. Not smart. I don't think I was complacent as I've only had a table saw for about six months. I wasn't tired or drunk, either. Just dumb, apparently. I watch all the PBS woodworking shows and good ol' Scott Phillips says it, literally, every single time he makes a cross cut or rip on his table saw: "Wait for the blade to stop before removing that off-cut," he says. I didn't do that this one time, and it nearly cost me a finger. Luckily, it only cost me a trip to the ER and some followups to a orthopedic doctor. Having said all that, I'm sticking with my current saw...because I can't afford another one anytime soon and I'm just getting started in woodworking. I have a Craftsman contractor style table saw and it's served me well so far (other than mangling my finger, of course!). It was the table saw that fit my needs at the time and was in my budget. Higher quality cabinet saws are still just a dream as my woodworking budget is still very much a hobby budget that comes way last to other family needs, but I will most certainly be looking at SawStop when I do get to go shopping for a better saw someday. Shocker, huh?! I'd love to have a Delta Unisaw, or Powermatic, or any of the other cabinet saws that folks around here swear by, but the safety features of the SawStop are suddenly a major factor in my decision. The good thing, I suppose, is that the saw itself is rated highly and it seems that most everyone who has one really likes it. To the OP, I hope your new saw works out well for you and makes lots and lots of dust!! I'll be here nursing my wounds and just a little jealous!

Edit: Forgot to add that I, too, want to be able to teach my son some woodworking skills when he gets a little older. He loves to watch woodworking shows on TV with me, and he was basically my shadow this summer out in the shop. So I can definitely understand wanting to have some additional safety for the little ones in your life!

--Joe

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 51 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined