TerryMcK Posted January 1, 2013 Report Posted January 1, 2013 My wife has given me a great Christmas present. She will pay for a tool of my choice and I have narrowed it down to one from a small selection of hand planes that I have seen for sale. Either an essentially brand new unused bronze #3, a used bronze #2, a used cast iron #8 or a used bronze #4 I already have a few #4s, admittedly not Lie Nielsen, I already have a #7 that is adequate for jointer use and I was tempted by the #3. I have a small bevel up Veritas bench plane that is similar in size and weight to the #3. My wife's only criteria was "it must be a beautiful object and also be useable everyday". Now you can see why I was heading towards the bronze direction. Given this dilemma what would you guys go for? Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted January 1, 2013 Report Posted January 1, 2013 How are your #4's? If at least one of them isn't fantastic, that's the first top-end plane I'd buy. There's also the thought that you can get a 50 or 55 degree frog for the LN plane, and have a fantastic tool for difficult woods. After that train of thought, I'd probably lean towards the #3. I don't think I'd use the 2 much, and it sounds like you're happy with your jointer. If LN made a high angle frog for the jointer, I'd move it ahead of the the #3, but they don't make one for the #8... I LOVE high angle jointing planes for match joints. The high cutting angle is a good amount of work to push, but it cleanly shears reversing grain and edge figure. 1 Quote
SMeekWoodworks Posted January 1, 2013 Report Posted January 1, 2013 My Lie-Nielsen #4 is what got me started down my hand tool addiction path. A bronze one would just be icing on the cake! Even though I use wood planes almost exclusively now, I will never get rid of my LN #4. 1 Quote
glh17 Posted January 14, 2013 Report Posted January 14, 2013 It depends on what kind of work you do. Personally, I don't have much use for a #2 or #3 bench plane. The #4 is the smallest I have other than a low angle block plane. If it were me, I'd be looking at a #5, either the bevel up or bevel down. My most used plane is a LN bevel up jack. I can use it as a normal jack as well as on a shooting board. Although I own the LN, I heard great things about the Veritas bevel up jack as well. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted January 14, 2013 Report Posted January 14, 2013 I agree with Barry. Unless your current #4's make you tear up just to look at them, then I'd get the bronze #4. It is sexy just to look at. Plus it performs great and won't rust. Quote
TerryMcK Posted January 18, 2013 Author Report Posted January 18, 2013 I've opted for the bronze #4 and I will be receiving it in the next few days. Also I have the option to buy the #3 and #8 so I'm going to pay for them in the next month. Pictures to follow watch this space guys. Quote
nateswoodworks Posted January 18, 2013 Report Posted January 18, 2013 I don't see a jack (#5) on the list of planes you have, you may want to think about getting one instead of the #3 since you already have the smother covered. Also since you said that you already have an adequate #7 you may want to look at something like router plane or a rabbeting block plane, just my opinion here but my thoughts are that you may want to fill in the holes in your arsenal before duplicating it. Keep us posted! Quote
tirebob Posted January 20, 2013 Report Posted January 20, 2013 I agree with Nate on this one. You have a smoother, now you need a a Jointer and/or a roughing plane like a 5 jack or 6 foreplane. The roughing plane can double for a jointer if the pieces you are jointing are not too long, although if you do not want a dedicated foreplane and a dedicated jointer, you may want to consider two blades, once being fairly heavily cambered for rough work and another much less aggressively cambered for jointing. Depending on what type of stuff you will be building, some of the specialty planes can be invaluable like the Veritas small plow plane or either the LN or LV rotuer plane. Shoulder planes definitely come in handy too... Such a slippery slope we ride! Quote
TerryMcK Posted January 28, 2013 Author Report Posted January 28, 2013 I should have said I already have a Stanley #5 jack for the rough stuff with a cambered iron. I have a cheap #7 jointer which is ok for some of the work I do but I will probably sell that when I get the #8. For specialty planes I have a #50 that I am learning how to use (not easy but I'm persevering) along with a great #71 router plane. I also have and a Record 44C plow and a Record 778 rabbet both of which are superb examples and work really well. All these were bought from preloved and the #50 was essentially unused and dates back to about 1968 if the date written in pencil on the box can be believed. It is still in its pristine cardboard box, had all the wax paper around everything and all the blades still have their manufacturers oil coating. I guess the guy who owned it bought it then stuck it in the back of a drawer and forgot about it. His wife sold all his tools when he recently died and I got the #50. I think a separate thread on folks experiences with combination planes old and new would be good! It may need to be a sub-forum of the hand tool village one as I am sure there will be many stories/advice/questions. Have a look at Alf's advice on combo planes here http://www.cornishworkshop.co.uk/combinationplanes.html I also have a nice shoulder plane and recently bought a chisel plane that I still have to try out. Great for removing glue squeeze out in corners amongst many other things. A plane till is a likely addition to the shop in the future. Quote
TerryMcK Posted February 5, 2013 Author Report Posted February 5, 2013 The sale of the #8 and #3 planes fell through but I got some others instead. Here is the #4 my wife bought for me. It's 12 years old but is immaculate, as are all the tools, due to the retiring cabinet maker looking after all his equipment (a lesson for us all maybe?). I have tried it out and can't believe what I have been missing all these years. I am a Lie Nielson convert I bought the rest of these tools myself starting with a 103 block plane. Here is the cabinet makers scraper plane. This is an awesome piece of kit! And finally a little dinky Ibex violin makers plane with the scraper plane blade in view for scale. I also bought a 24" Veritas straight edge but everybody knows what they look like. No more tool purchases for a short while as Lie Nielson doesn't come cheap whether new or pre-used. 1 Quote
Jfitz Posted February 5, 2013 Report Posted February 5, 2013 Congrats on all the new tools. That bronze 4 is beautiful, but I'm more taken by that cabinet scraper. I've been on the fence about going with Veritas or LN for planes - I know I can't go wrong with either - but your comments have me strongly leaning towards LN again. Quote
TerryMcK Posted June 1, 2013 Author Report Posted June 1, 2013 I took the cabinet makers scraper plane to a Lie Nielson event at a local tool store back in March. Deneb Puchalski was there and I asked him how I should sharpen it as the bevel was 60 degrees. My MKII couldn't handle it. He said that the design was changed a year or so after it was made and the bevel is now 45 degrees. Needless to say he was kind enough to change the bevel and rehone it for me using his diamond plates. It did take about 30 minutes for him to do it but he was very entertaining while doing it. It now scrapes even better than ever and is easy to hone even with my Veritas MKII 1 Quote
Bobby Slack Posted June 2, 2013 Report Posted June 2, 2013 Jack # 5. Since this plane is not really a precision tool and you have a # 8. and a #4. May be you can use somebody else's plane or a #6 with an camber blade. This was my approach. What say you guys? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.