Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

LumberYard/Hardwood Dealer/Big Box Store

Featured Replies

Where do you get most of you wood from

 

Lumbar Yard

 

Hardwood Dealer

 

Big Box Store (Menards, Lowes, Etc)

 

 

Why do you get your wood from that source?

I get most of my wood from a wholesaler. As an OEM, you save a ton of money that way.

50% - Lumbar Yard

 

50 % - Hardwood Dealer

 

Percentage at specialty hardwood dealer is increasing as local lumber yards are going under.  Will probably by %70 - 30% by the end of the year.

"Lumbar yard"...I thought that was a mattress store.  :D

 

Buy all mine from a hardwood dealer.

I have about 5 hardwood suppliers but  90% is from the same mill for the last 39 years,Suwanee Lumber in Suwanee GA. The grandson and cousins run the place now.

i can dig through any stacks I want to because they know I will put the stack back neater than I found it. My grandfather taught me that trick.

I buy wherever I can afford it.  Lately, I've been splurging and buying from a lumber dealer near me, but their selection of exotics is limited.  I have one exotic dealer I know of within an hour of me, but I can't always afford the gas out there, let alone the price of the wood.  So, while the transportation is a nightmare, I've been shopping at the BigBox stores mostly.  They're about 16 miles away, but I usually know what to expect.  If I want something semi-exotic, I'll head to my local Woodcraft.

 

So, I guess it's 70% Box, 15 % Lumberyard, and 15% Dealer/Other

Sadly, no hardwood dealers or lumber yards are in my area. I get my stuff rough sawn from a local sawyer. It's more work and milling but it's the only choice I have.

I stay the heck out of big boxes unless I'm in immediate need of lumber for some reason. Otherwise, there is an indy lumber place northwest of here which is a little bit of a drive, but their lumber is totally worth it and actually in some cases, cheaper than the BORGs.

 

Otherwise I deal with several hardwood places around here, I'm fortunate to live in an area with several options.

My mill is a hardwood dealer....so I don't where that one goes.

 

No big box.  The local big boxes actually shop at the same mill I buy from (I have bumped into them there a few times) so you can imagine the massive mark up they add too it to mill it S4S and then help offset their overhead.

 

One option you didn't list is online/auctions (Ebay, etc).  I have found some pretty spectacular deals on exotic/figured lumbers that my mill doesn't consistently stock.  There can be great discounts for lumbers that are regionally grown if you buy online.  I'd say still 90%+ comes from the local mill.

 

As far as tools go, I still argue that planer is one of the best investments a woodworker can make.  Big box stores gouge something fierce, and you lose some of the great finds you get from hand picking lumber from a rough sawn rack.  I rarely buy maple or walnut anymore unless I can find at least some  extra figuring in each board, and I almost never buy from any bins but the #1 comm.  There are lots of treasures to be found!

  • Author

My mill is a hardwood dealer....so I don't where that one goes.

 

No big box.  The local big boxes actually shop at the same mill I buy from (I have bumped into them there a few times) so you can imagine the massive mark up they add too it to mill it S4S and then help offset their overhead.

 

One option you didn't list is online/auctions (Ebay, etc).  I have found some pretty spectacular deals on exotic/figured lumbers that my mill doesn't consistently stock.  There can be great discounts for lumbers that are regionally grown if you buy online.  I'd say still 90%+ comes from the local mill.

 

As far as tools go, I still argue that planer is one of the best investments a woodworker can make.  Big box stores gouge something fierce, and you lose some of the great finds you get from hand picking lumber from a rough sawn rack.  I rarely buy maple or walnut anymore unless I can find at least some  extra figuring in each board, and I almost never buy from any bins but the #1 comm.  There are lots of treasures to be found!

I never would have thought about looking on ebay for lumber (what a brilliant idea lol)

Sounds kinda cool Nick, got link to your sawyer?

This made me chuckle a bit. He lives out in the country and recently got rid of his home phone. Needless to say, he doesn't have a website. :D he's a great guy though. When I built my son's walnut bassinet last year, he wouldn't let me pay him a dime for the lumber. Some of it had gorgeous grain. Here's a close up of the figure.

photo2-24.jpg

I have just recently made the switch from the box store to a hardwood dealer.

 

These guys:

http://www.dunham-hardwoods.com/

 

It's almost 100 miles from where I live, but I took a chance and made the road trip. I was completely impressed not only with the selection of hardwoods available, but the quality of the boards. These guys were also very helpful in cutting up some longer boards to fit into the back of my SUV. Prices seem pretty reasonable to me as well. Most everything cost half as much as it does at the box store. They do mail shipments as well, but I've never used that service.

I'm pretty sure my place sells what it cuts, except for imported exotics.

Prices are the best I have seen around, compared to most eBay, Craigslist, and online dealers.

I can't wait to get some more money out aside and splurge on a lot of wood.

I build arts&craft style furniture and need quarter-sawn white oak. There are few hardwood stores in the Denver area and finding what I need would be a time consuming and expensive. I primarily build furniture only using veneer on plywood. Homedepot has some good cabinet-grade plywood which I use as a substrate for veneer. I order veneer from Certainlywood.com. tape it together, glue, and vacuum press it to the plywood. For profiled edges, I use a thin piece of solid stock so I can create the shape I need with a router. The side grain of oak looks like quarter-sawn, so it works out well. Here is an example using figured cherry.

 

P1000615.JPG

 

-Randy

finewoodfinish.blogspot.com

I'm new to woodworking and have built a few things for the grand kids.  

In Tampa, we have a couple of places that sell hardwoods, Intercity and Craftsman supply.

I go to the Box stores for practice stuff, they stock some poplar in 1x dimensions and I think some

1x red oak.  

I recently bought an old coffee table at a flea market that I'm going to cut up and see what kind of

wood it's made of.  I paid $20, so hopefully I get something out of it.

Is there a site that can help me identify the type of wood I have after I get it cut and sanded?

Thanks

Dennis

In my view, this is a relationship business. I have a great Lumber supplier from whom I buy all my wood, solid and ply.

I used to use a bunch of alder and play with stains. And thanks to this forum, I understood the value of using the type of wood for the effect you look for, using a natural finish (Waterlox) which will express the grain.

 

My lumber yard will also let me dig through the stack because I re-organize the stack better than how I found it.

 

Treat others like you want to be treated.

In my view, this is a relationship business. I have a great Lumber supplier from whom I buy all my wood, solid and ply.

I used to use a bunch of alder and play with stains. And thanks to this forum, I understood the value of using the type of wood for the effect you look for, using a natural finish (Waterlox) which will express the grain.

 

My lumber yard will also let me dig through the stack because I re-organize the stack better than how I found it.

 

Treat others like you want to be treated.

My grandfather taught me that when I was a teenager. Some of the suppliers I buy at discourage people from digging thru the whole pile. A guy started complaining that I was doing it why couldn't he, they replied he puts the stack back neater than we had it in the first place!

My hardwood dealer and lumberyard are the same place. I buy 95 percent of my stock there. The 5 comes from friends milling stuff and giving me to me. I recently received about 30 bf of 5/4 cherry from my cousin.

My hardwood dealer and lumberyard are the same place. I buy 95 percent of my stock there. The 5 comes from friends milling stuff and giving me to me. I recently received about 30 bf of 5/4 cherry from my cousin.

That's a nice cousin you have there.

That's a nice cousin you have there.

I thought so too. I am actually making him an occasional table from it as a surprise gift.

I'm new to woodworking and have built a few things for the grand kids.  

In Tampa, we have a couple of places that sell hardwoods, Intercity and Craftsman supply.

I go to the Box stores for practice stuff, they stock some poplar in 1x dimensions and I think some

1x red oak.  

I recently bought an old coffee table at a flea market that I'm going to cut up and see what kind of

wood it's made of.  I paid $20, so hopefully I get something out of it.

Is there a site that can help me identify the type of wood I have after I get it cut and sanded?

Thanks

Dennis

How's Craftsmanship pricing? I have bought from Intercity and they seem pricey.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.