TheFatBaron Posted August 6, 2013 Report Posted August 6, 2013 After getting something rust-inducing on my old Stanley #4, I decided it was as good a time as any to wax my hand planes. I warmed up some paraffin wax, rubbed it on, and got either lumps of wax, or nothing. After scraping out the wax from the recesses on the bottom of my #5C, I rubbed off the excess... but now I think I'm essentially back to where I started with unwaxed planes. Is there a trick to getting a nice, even coat of wax? Quote
Tpt life Posted August 6, 2013 Report Posted August 6, 2013 I use Johnson's paste wax. I wipe my plane sole before use but all the top surfaces get paste wax. If the sole needs treatment during use I will use a touch of bees wax but a little goes a long way. The frictional heat transfers the wax around. I have never been a fan of applying straight paraffin. Quote
rodger. Posted August 6, 2013 Report Posted August 6, 2013 Use paste wax (silicone free) to maintain your planes. Use a dab on some cheesecloth or a rag and apply a thin coat. Let sit for a few mins, then buff off with a few clean rags. Use paraffin wax as a lubricant when using your plane. Just rub a bit on the sole when using it. Quote
Tom King Posted August 6, 2013 Report Posted August 6, 2013 After the test in FWW on a bunch of different rust preventers a year or so ago, where 3.36 came out on top, I tried some, and haven't used anything else since then. Not a speck of rust on any hand tool or machine top since starting to use the CRS 3.36. Part of their test was effect on finish applied to wood worked, and feel to the hand. Wax came in WAY down the list. I may use a little beeswax once in a while on the sole of a molding plane, but no other wax. Quote
mds2 Posted August 6, 2013 Report Posted August 6, 2013 I use Johnson Paste wax too. I've never noticed it leaving behind a residue on stuff, but I've never really thought to check thoroughly. I have no complaints with it. Cheap and a can will last just short of forever. Quote
mkirby Posted August 6, 2013 Report Posted August 6, 2013 I dont use wax for rust prevention, only to lubricate the sole, and then i just use a tea light candle. I wipe down and buff out with 3 in 1 oil after use. 1 Quote
missioninwood Posted August 6, 2013 Report Posted August 6, 2013 I use Johnsons or Paraffin, which ever is close-by. I have never had reside issues with either, but I do make a conscious effort to throughly clean all surfaces with Mineral Spirits prior to ANY other treatment. But those who know me know I am ALL about the CHEAP. miw Quote
wdwerker Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 So I am the only high tech guy in the crowd? Try Bostich TopCote or whatever they call the spray since they repackaged it. No silicones but it will make your plane or cast iron tablesaw slide wood with ease. Spray it on, wipe off the haze a few minutes later and away you go. Highland and Woodcraft both carry it. 1 Quote
Tom King Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 I guess no one read the FWW "test". Topcote was in the test, but didn't even make the top anything list. 3-36 is a spray on too. It only takes the smallest amount to spread around also, and rated the highest in every category. They put some of each thing on raw A2 and cast iron (table saw top), left them exposed, and showed the "after" pictures. Some of the "after" pictures didn't look much different than the untreated samples. 3-36 was the only thing that allowed no rust at all on either A2 or cast iron. Also tested were effects on finish adhering to wood, and feel to the hand. 3-36 was the only one at the top in each of the categories. They tested 20 different products, most of which either you have heard of, and I believe everything that has been mentioned in this thread. I don't subscribe to FWW, even though I was a charter subscriber-they kept repeating stuff I've heard before-but I do look at them on a newsstand, and see if there are any articles worth buying the magazine for. It looks like that issue was one I bought last year for that article. After that article, I decided I'd try it, and it really is amazing stuff. Nothing I have has had a speck of rust on it since I applied it, and everything slides smoothly. It is a lubricant. I bought two cans of it, put it on everything, including all my handsaws, and it doesn't seem like the cans are hurt at all. Some Sandvik handsaws that I bought as new old stock, that I've used for the past year or so, still look like new. Quote
Tpt life Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 I read the article and distrust their findings. Several of their negative test results do not match my experience in life. I trust your recommendation of 3-36, but not their nay saying of several other remedies. I do not necessarily care which fails fastest if my seasonal regimen never gives a treatment a chance to fail. Does that make sense without sounding negative. I do not intend negativity. I will likely invest in 3-36 at some point but not before I run out of my other remedies or until my current remedies burn me at least once. Quote
Tom King Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 Makes sense. I read all sorts of other criticism on the article too, but I decided to give the winner a try, and I don't have any reason to use anything else now. It works. You can't see it or feel it, and whatever makes it last for rust prevention must also make it last as a lubricant because stuff keeps sliding smoothly. I've been most impressed that it's kept rust (that I have had to always fight fairly constantly in the past) off the bare tracks on the Biesmeyer fence. And I've tried all sorts of things on handsaws, and never had anything to keep them looking like brand new before. Polished plane soles, and sides, stay polished. I wish I had it back when I first bought my Record shoulder planes which have developed a bit of patina from contact with my hands. Nothing else has since putting 3-36 on shiny bare metal. Camelia oil has not been squirted since, and the only wax touched has been bees wax to put on wooden planes. Quote
mds2 Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 Does anyone know what issue of FWW? Uninsulated garage shop here. Quote
Tpt life Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 It was within the last ten issues. The public library limits me to ten issues at a time:-) Quote
Tom King Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 Yeah, I was just looking at it. August 2012. It was the last FWW I bought, so at the end of the stack.They put 20 different things on raw A2 and a table saw top, sprayed water on the table saw top and left it outside under an over hang for something like 10 days. The A2 samples they took in and out of a freezer to force condensation. If you don't want to bother to find the magazine, just buy some CRC 3-36. It did everything the best in the test, and has on my stuff. Camelia oil and wax do nothing by comparison with my real world experience. Quote
wdwerker Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 I was only using it to reduce the friction! Daily use for 27 plus years polishes the surface so rust is rarely an issue. I will look into the CRC product. Quote
rodger. Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 So I am the only high tech guy in the crowd? Try Bostich TopCote or whatever they call the spray since they repackaged it. No silicones but it will make your plane or cast iron tablesaw slide wood with ease. Spray it on, wipe off the haze a few minutes later and away you go. Highland and Woodcraft both carry it. I use the topcote as well. My normal routine is clean with wd40 and 0000 wool, then topcote, then paste wax. Do the same for all machine surfaces that are cast iron. Quote
TheFatBaron Posted August 7, 2013 Author Report Posted August 7, 2013 I was only using the wax to cut some friction - I haven't gotten any rust since cleaning off... I dunno, whatever it was. But I'll check out the I'll check out the CRC stuff and the Topcote and see what I find (and maybe hit up my local library if they have an old copy of FWW). Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.