moxzero Posted August 23, 2013 Report Posted August 23, 2013 Just getting started in woodworking. First post on this forum. Have a question about preparing new chisels. I purchased the 7 piece Narex Classic Bevel Edge chisels. The chisels have an oily substance on the surface, which I believe is to protect them from rusting. Before sharpening, do I remove this oil? If so, with mineral spirits? As regualr maintenance, should I apply something to the chisels for protection? Thanks in advance! Quote
Trip Posted August 23, 2013 Report Posted August 23, 2013 ==> mineral spirits? MS works, some folks use WD-40, Naptha, etc... There are some pretty good videos on YouTube produced by Lie-Nielsen and Veritas on prepping chisels. The first step is to flatten the backs -- takes time, but you have to do it. Check-out the videos and go from there... Quote
moxzero Posted August 23, 2013 Author Report Posted August 23, 2013 TripleH - thanks for the info, I will check those video out tonight. Quote
rodger. Posted August 23, 2013 Report Posted August 23, 2013 I use WD40 all the time to clean my tools. With new chisels, just a quick wipe down of the metal with wd and a rag shod do the trick. Quote
moxzero Posted August 23, 2013 Author Report Posted August 23, 2013 F Pug - do you wipe them down with WD40 before and/or after each use? Quote
G S Haydon Posted August 23, 2013 Report Posted August 23, 2013 moxzero, Congrats on the purchase. I have just purchased a 1/2" Narex Mortice Chisel. You might like this vid. One thing you might find with Narex is with the first time you use them the cutting edge chips. I was advised by Matthew (bloke in the vid) that this does occur on some of the Narex chisels but it goes away after a second sharpen. Something to do with how the metal is treated. All good advice so far with good video links too. To contrast that advice I would not bother flattening the backs. As Matthew said they are consistently hollow (although he is not advocating what I propose). I would retain this hollow to allow quicker easier sharpening rather than spending time flattening. If you try without flattening first you might like them and save yourself some time. Quote
missioninwood Posted August 23, 2013 Report Posted August 23, 2013 I wipe down all metal tools with MS after I touch them. That may seem quite fanatical. And I believe it is... WD40 gives me a wicked headache. miw Quote
rodger. Posted August 24, 2013 Report Posted August 24, 2013 F Pug - do you wipe them down with WD40 before and/or after each use? No, but it certainly wouldn't hurt. My normal regimin for handplanes is wd40 and 0000 steel wool, followed by topcot, and finally a coat of paste wax. For chisels, I normally clean them with wd40 and a rag after sharpening to chase away any moisture left from the water stone sharpening process. Quote
Tom King Posted August 24, 2013 Report Posted August 24, 2013 I dry moisture off of irons and chisels after being on a waterstone with a propane torch with self-igniter and watch the moisture fade right off. Since agreeing with the protectant test in FWW after my own testing, I now only use CRC 3.36 on everything. Quote
Trip Posted August 24, 2013 Report Posted August 24, 2013 ==> I would not bother flattening the backs. As Matthew said they are consistently hollow I did not know there were concave... You learn something every day -- all my J chisels are concave, but just didn't think about it with Western-style. With concave backs, they are much easier to prep - but at the cost of a reference face. You should at least lap the back a bit to verify two edges are in the same plane and remove grinding marks. You can't get a sharp chisel without doing some work on the backs... Quote
wilburpan Posted August 25, 2013 Report Posted August 25, 2013 The traditional manufacture of western chisels and plane blades resulted in a slight concavity on one side. This was the side that was selected to be the back, for exactly the same reason that Japanese chisels have a hollow — to make managing the back easier when sharpening. 1 Quote
G S Haydon Posted August 25, 2013 Report Posted August 25, 2013 Very very good link Wilbur. HHH your right, a bit of work would be needed but the hollow back ensures the pressure is just where it needs to be, behind the cutting edge. Just removing the burr should get you real close depending of the surface quality of the chisel back. Kinda why I like the ruler trick too for plane blades too. Quote
Trip Posted August 25, 2013 Report Posted August 25, 2013 Boy, we're off into the weeds... ==> Very very good link Wilbur. Joel's blog entry is a tad bit simplified... Don't get me wrong, he'll forget more about edge grinding/shaping then I'll ever know (I regularly use his custom Baldor grinder)... But he fails to mention that during the period Ray is referring to, chisels were delivered with a slight hollow due to the mfg process and without handle --- the joiner was expected to fettle the chisel and turn/fit a handle to taste. As Ray Anderson correctly points-out -- at a minimum, the craftsman needs three sides of the back flat and in plane -- not the entire surface. So at a minimum, the joiner brought the sides into plane with the area directly behind the front edge. The point is, the back needed to be flat or slightly concave -- never convex -- and the cutting edge needs to be in the same plane as the sides of the chisel. Over time, lesser--quality mass-produces chisels/irons appeared using a different mfg process and, occasionally, delivered convex-back tools (requiring more setup and leading to the entire back being polished). This evolved into a habit of flattened/polished backs on W-style chisels/irons (the sign of a 'true craftsman'). For the J-style chisel/iron, the hollow was deliberately introduced by the blacksmith. ==> Kinda why I like the ruler trick too for plane blades too Yea, after David demoed it, I was an instant convert... Not only does it speed setup, but the slight back-bevel can't hurt either... However, not everyone is a convert -- if you scan Hock's sharpening blog, you can find some lively debates on the ruler trick -- some of the arguments against it are rather compelling -- but I think the pros still outweigh the cons so I'm sticking to it... Quote
G S Haydon Posted August 25, 2013 Report Posted August 25, 2013 Ahh the "true craftsman", judged on his tools, not his finished product . I must confess to ignorance of flattening as a whole until joining this forum back in feb of this year. Depending on your work I don't think three faces are essential in most cases. I know you will easily give me a list but what tasks do you find you need a perfectly flat backed chisel over its full length? If my work becomes very very refined perhaps I might splash some cash on a premium 1/2" chisel and keep it for the occasions where a register face is useful. I would never encourage anyone to make do with poor quality tools but I think there is a balance (different for all of us) to be struck between ceremonial tool preparation and actually making things. Quote
Trip Posted August 25, 2013 Report Posted August 25, 2013 ==> I must confess to ignorance of flattening as a whole until joining this forum back in feb of this year. Funny, most of the hot debate on flattening comes from your side of the pond -- some of those boards are certainly a bit spicy... Hay, don't get me wrong -- I don't completely flatten/polish the backs of any of my edge tools -- I think it's a waste of time... But many folks don't agree with that and have some well-thought-out arguments -- so can't be completely ignored... It doesn't matter what chisel/iron you buy, some lapping needs to be done to the back -- but how much is the basis of tradition and modern-debate... ==> Ahh the "true craftsman", judged on his tools, not his finished product that's why I put it in quotes.... Quote
G S Haydon Posted August 25, 2013 Report Posted August 25, 2013 that's why I put it in quotes.... I know dude Tell me about it, it's a head f#~k. From ignorance to I don't know how many options in only a few months, I'm just pleased I'm not a newbie. but how much is the basis of tradition and modern-debate... So difficult. I think some of it is because we all spend time on these types of forums, shooting the breeze in between fleeting moments at the bench. As I type this I'm cooking the evening meal, easy to post on the forum when cooking, not always easy to get to the bench . Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.