Recommended Posts

Posted

My living room is a wide open space to allow two very high energy small children the chance to run around. However this doesn't give us anywhere to put hot drinks etc. So I'm going to build two end tables. I recently picked up some I think will do nicely in our living room. There are a number of design considerations to take into account when building the project:

  • I have a limited budget. The oak I bought was second hand and has been sat in someone's garage for 15 years.
  • I have a wide variety of tools I've acquired over the years (jointer, planer, 1 1/2HP table saw, couple of routers etc).
  • I have limited experience. So there's a limit to the joinery etc I can produce accurately. I might have to practice mortise and tenons a few times before getting started on this project.
  • I have limited amount of time in the shop.
  • I'm a mostly power tool user.
  • One of the dimensions of the top must be 12" or less. Following the golden rule, that would be make the other dimension of the top around 18"
  • The table needs to be 25" high or so, so it's the same height as the arm of the chair.

So here is the design I've got so far:

post-6539-0-90032600-1378339779_thumb.jppost-6539-0-90997900-1378339780_thumb.jp

 

This is the Sketchup for you to play with:

EndTable2.skp

 

I've already milled up some of the boards already. Some of them are paler than the others, which leads me to believe that these could be white oak (I'm going to call them white oak even if they aren't, to avoid confusion). So I've joined the boards together for the top, sandwiching the red oak between the white oak. This forms a slab measuring roughly 25" by 18". This will be cut in half to form the two tops.

 

I was originally thinking of splaying the legs a little. Maybe only 5 degrees to provide a little extra stability given that small children may end up climbing on it. My concern would be trying to joint the top of the legs and aprons to bring it level again. Would the table need the stability?

 

If it does, and I add the 5 degree angle, how do I accurately joint the top of the legs so the table top sits flat? Do I need to joint it?

Posted

Instead of splaying the legs start below the depth of the apron and taper the legs to maybe half the thickness on the bottom.  Do a two sided taper on the insides of the legs only.  It'll make fitting your stretchers a little bit trickier but no more so than if you had splayed the legs.  Tapering the legs will not affect the stability of the stands and will make them look lighter.  I'd also think about tapering the underside of the top a little less than the width of the reveal.

 

In the end, however, they're your end tables and you'll be a lot happier with them if they're not designed by committee.

  • Like 1
Posted

I agree with Byrdie 100%. I would taper the legs to give the piece a better look.

However, there is a place for splayed legs. I forget what the style is technically called, but splayed legs look good when done right.

With the tapering, the aprons will be straightforward. Rule of thumb is for the taper to start about an inch below the apron or shelf. But rules are meant to be broken :)

Posted

I recently made a set of tables almost exactly like you are describing for our new neighbors. They are a young (very young) couple who just had their first baby.

She bought a table at a yard sale and he came over to see if I could build another to match it. I told him that I would rather build a set of two from scratch than try to duplicate the forty year old piece of junk that they had.

I too used red oak and built it from a sketch I made on a scrap piece of paper.

I bought my wood at the big box store (quick and easy) and used a dark walnut stain (at their request).

All joints are m&t  even the legs into the top are blind m&t. 

The top and legs are glued up using the 3/4" thickness of the boards to get 1-1/2" legs and width for the top. (I forget how wide the top is now)

 

 

Endtables003_zpsbe567890.jpg

 

 

Rog

  • Like 1
Posted

 

In the end, however, they're your end tables and you'll be a lot happier with them if they're not designed by committee.

 

A good point, well made.

 

That said, I was playing with putting a bevel on the under side of the table on Sketchup. It looks better on the drawing. I guess I can put it together and see how I feel once it's complete before actually doing the bevel.

Posted

Hey Rog,

 

Aren't you concerned about the wood moving and blowing out the stretcher's joints?

 

How tall are the tables, and how stable are they?

 

Well, actually no I'm not worried about wood movement altho maybe I should be.

I live in Kansas and we do have extreme temperature and humidity changes through the year. Any temp from -16 degrees in the winter to +110 in the summer and humidity accordingly. However, these tables will be in their living room and most people around here have central heat and air conditioning so the atmosphere inside the house is fairly constant. And as small as they are, I doubt there would be enough wood movement to cause any serious problems.

I'm not sure about the dimensions but, if memory serves, I think the top is about  12" x 20" and the height is around 22". I'll go next door and measure them this afternoon and if I've missed the measurements very far, I'll re-post later.

Granted, the tables look very fragile and unstable but, as they are going to sit between an easy chair and the wall and are designed just to hold a drink or maybe a table lamp, I think they will serve the purpose. I was worried too, that a child could pull the table over on themselves but, that didn't seem to worry the neighbors much and they liked the tables. If you had seen what they were going to use, you would be impressed with my design. :) 

Besides, you get what you pay for. :)

 

Rog

  • Like 1
Posted

So I've been playing around with Sketchup (which I've told myself I really should learn how to do - thanks to Sketchup For Woodworkers). "Follow-me" FTW.

 

I've come up with an alternative design:

post-6539-0-59352300-1378408063_thumb.jppost-6539-0-70472300-1378408064_thumb.jpEndTable3.skp

 

My wife who has rather a lot of say in the design doesn't like the tapers at the bottom of the leg, and on reflection I agree. I just wanted to try it out. The top on the other hand we both agree is an improvement, with the round over and the bevel. So I think my final design is like that, just without the tapered legs.

 

The next question: To drawbored or not?

  • I'll learn a new technique which shouldn't take too long to master thanks to Marc's (and others) videos.
  • It will improve the strength of my M&T joinery, when I'm in no doubt the joints will be a little sloppy due to my inexperience
  • It'll add a little detail
Posted

I'd arch the side aprons as well. The round over and the taper is something to keep an eye on. It may work in real life, and it may not. Depends on taste, and how the light hits it when it's finished. I would pick one or the other, but it's your table :)

I'm interested to see this one.

Posted

I was thinking about arching the side aprons. One of the tables that's not going to be seen often. I might have another play with the sketchup and see what I think. Or maybe I'll dry fit it together, and then have a change of heart.

 

The round over on the top is a 1/4" radius. That was my intention anyway! I'm just very aware of small heads and sharp corners. From that perspective, the bevel on the bottom is probably more important. Maybe I'll play with a 1/8" round over on the sketchup and see how I feel about that.

 

I'm getting kinda excited to see how this turns out too!

  • Like 1
Posted

Just a personal opinion, but I much prefer the slender stretchers of Roger's design. The big change in proportions between the side stretchers (rails?) and central stretcher just doesn't seem right to me - though I can see you were repeating the side aprons.

 

Also I'm not able to follow Andrew's concern that wood movement would blow out the stretcher joints - movement in what sense? From the top expanding and contracting? I'd think there would be enough elasticity in the joint to cope with that, or am I missing something?

 

I have a manufactured set of nested tables of similar dimensions, and of course they have no stretchers at all...

 

John

Posted

My concern over the top was that the legs are M&T'd into them, so when the top expands it will put pressure on the legs to push them apart. That said, the gap between the two legs is quite narrow, and as Rog said, it's in their living room so the temperature (and therefore humidity) variation shouldn't be too high. Time will tell I guess!

 

I'm putting in stretchers more as a belt and braces exercise. I don't have a huge amount of experience and I can guarantee my children will climb over them as one is two years old, and the other just turned one.

Posted

Thank you for that. I can understand Roger's design using m&ts for the legs, but since you have an apron, you could use buttons or those 'figure of eight' clips. Rather than expansion, contraction could do worse damage by splitting the top. I had been thinking of the m&ts in the stretchers, not the apron, presuming you'd be 'floating' the top, as it were.

 

Young children are extremely resourceful, though not too heavy. I think that design without stretchers would be strong enough, but I can understand the embarrassment of finding your trousers round your knees  :rolleyes:

 

You could taper the outside faces, then you'd still have square references for your m&ts, and taper from just below the aprons.

 

Fox wedging the tenons could be an alternative to drawboring, but you won't have any details.

 

Good luck with the project.

 

John

  • Like 1
Posted

If I were tapering the legs I'd start just under the aprons and make a much more gradual taper to the bottom.  I agree that tapering the last few inches of the leg, essentially the foot, doesn't make sense.

 

I may have to take a few minutes and play with SketchUp.

  • Like 2
Posted

So I started cutting down my stock yesterday. I'm still trying to finish my wife's birthday present (only 2 months late so far, but I'm nearly there!) and I'm just finishing gluing all that up.

 

I've encountered my first challenge with the stock I'm using. Whilst for the most part it's really nice red oak, there used to be some nails in. This has left some black marks and holes embedded in the wood. Some times it's difficult to see where those are going to end up. I don't have a huge budget for wood (or at all for that matter), so I don't want to waste wood just because it's got a few dings. I'd rather learn how to fix this kind of problem than just discard otherwise great pieces of wood.

 

So the question is - how best to fix this?

 

My current thinking is learn how to do inlay. It's a skill I'd like to learn, and for the most part these will be legs which I can hide at the back.

 

I also noticed some small round holes - maybe 1mm across. I'm worried they are some kind of bug which is eating my valuable stock! There aren't a huge number of them so I can fix them, but only if I've killed all the bugs - if that's what they are. I don't have any pictures - my iPhone is rubbish for doing close up work and I've not been up to my barn shop with my SLR.

Posted

I've been working (or should be working) on a dining table for a commission where the client actually wants the nail holes and dings in the wood.  She wants it to look "rustic,"  like an old farmhouse dining table.

 

That's one solution.  The oxidation from the nails has leeched into the wood and likely goes right through.  You'd have to figure out some way to do a small patch or finish in a color that wouldn't show then color from the nail holes.  I hope you can find a way to make them a design feature.  Otherwise try a drill bit slightly larger than the nail hole and and drill in a 1/16th to an 1/8th.  Then fit a small plug in the hole and do you're best to orient grain.  If done well and sanded you'll have to look closely to show others where it is.

  • Like 2
Posted

Some of the oxidation marks are pretty big - at least 1/16th" either side of the hole. And the hole isn't small either.

 

I might do a test cut with some red oak dowel, though I availability of such things round here is very limited so I'll probably have to make some myself. Which will be a new and interesting technique to learn.

Posted

Try a plug cutter instead of dowels. Dowels will give you end grain and stain differently. Using a plug cutter you can cut face grain from off cut scraps of the same or similar grained boards.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 39 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined