Recommended Posts

Posted

I've made the plunge and purchased the BenchCrafted leg and tail vises!!! I'm super psyched! WooHoo!!!! :)

I'll be building a Shaker style bench. I plan on doing something neat, so stay tuned!

I put this in the hand tool area because that's what I'll be using. Well, for the most part. I'll be using my bandsaw and /or tablesaw. Maybe my thickness planer too. But all joinery will be by hand. I'm planning on using the square dogs. I am warming up to the idea of having them there at all times. And they won't damage my handplanes! :)

All joinery also means the ship lapped boards, the doors, drawers everything.

This will without a doubt be my largest build. I can't wait to get started!! I'll get my wood as soon as possible. I decided to buy the vises first to give me some focus :) now I can't turn back!

Now, what to do with my like new twin-screw Veritas?

  • Like 1
Posted

Nice Mel! I also wanted to build the shaker, I fell in love with it when I first visited the benchcrafted site a year or 2 ago. You betta be logging this on the journal brutha!

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh I will! It will probably start slowly, but come together quickly.

The BC design calls for a 2" thick top, which I can get out of maybe two pieces in order to get the width I need. This will significantly reduce my dependence on power tools, and save me some time as well. I'm not sure how closely I'll follow the BC plans, but it'll be a Shaker bench alright :) I'm still super psyched!! I've been drawing a day. Just rough drawings to get the drawer layout how I want it. In a perfect world I would find 10' material, but I'd settle for 8'.

Posted

You will never regret it!! I built my Roubo last year and other than building my shop it has been the single biggest improvement I have made. I bought Schwarz 2nd workbench book and because of it I altered my design a tad, something you may want to consider if you haven't already. What species of wood are you going to use? I had some hard maple I had cut and dried several years ago that I used for the top and beautiful reclaimed old pine for the base. It is fun to build but even more fun to use, you will have a blast!!

Posted

I have both of C.S's books. They are great! I almost built a Roubo. And to be honest, my bench will incorporate some of the Roubo elements. The theme I have in my mind is "what if the Shakers built a Roubo?" :)

 

Definitely Shaker, but some Roubo on the side! (or the top? front?) I can't give everything away! There will be a twist, or a split? hmmm....

 

I am leaning towards hard maple, perhaps soft... It really depends on what I can get at the length I want. The bottom can be anything... It's getting painted anyway! 

Posted

Great news Mel! It will be nice to see a Shaker version unfold in a project journal  :). Though I would post some images that I hope will inspire you further 

 

Old School

696f134a75b7a726c21bcc3583991852.jpg

7feac1a143c1ab110099f52da339e7c1.jpg

 

New School 

 

b9506cbd9d41c67323a4c6fd33e3ac30.jpg

 

This one looks like it might belong to Mel

 

f3349327a06c4d557f5d602b6fe1bc33.jpg

  • Like 2
Posted

I like all of them. For different reasons though.

The first one is just plain awesome!

The second one because it has the legs on the same plane as the top. 

 I actually don't care for the third one.

The last one is probably the closest to the one I'll build. I like that the base is a true cabinet, not legs filled in with a cabinet. Perhaps the sliding deadman can be used in the same way the Roubo takes advantage of the leg.

 

I am really thinking about a split top. I know I won't be able to get a clamp in there, but to use it as a planing stop is just brilliant. Depending on how I design the top drawers, I may or may not be able to use holdfasts. And eventhough I'll have plenty of room for my tools, having my chisels and a saw or two at hand is hard to resist. I've been thinking about having a Moxon on the back of the bench as well. 

Posted

You won't be sorry at all...

 

A good bench is what makes all the other hand tools work. 

 

Personally, I prefer benches without cabinets underneath, as I always seem to need something from a drawer or door that is impeded...  My original bench had drawers, which is great now that the original bench is BEHIND ME, under a hanging tool cabinet, and used more as a table and chest of drawers.

 

If you've got the space, think about drawers and cabinets behind you, holding the tools you most often use at the bench.  This not only allows efficient, unimpeded access to all commonly used bench tools, but you can put things like planes back in the till when not in use, eliminating separate cleanup time.  You turn around and pick it up, turn around and put it down...  No bench clutter, no wasted steps, no mess, no tool damage.

Posted

I thought long and hard before deciding on the Shaker style bench. I am sure they'll be times when I need to take something out of the vise to open a drawer, or perhaps move the deadman to get to a plane I need to use. But all in all, I am confident that I'll be happier than sad in my choice. I am the type of person that over plans the simplest details. I will agonize over what goes in which drawer, and then I'll move it again. It's just how I am. :) I'll rearrange everything again when I get a new plane. Again, it's my curse. Having things close by is also a necessity. If it wasn't in my bench, it would be on my bench. Here's proof of the last statement. :) And for the record, I absolutely hate this arrangement. For one, the cheap red toolbox needs a new home. Actually the only thing I like is the handtool cabinet I made. It keeps things close by. But, it does take up valuable space. Well, I do like the Veritas vise. I'll find a home for that somehow. Not sure how it will fit into my future plans. 

 

1002352_10201775378214349_1715324143_n.j

Posted

Looks like you don't need that twin screw vise anymore.

 

I heard of a special recycling facility in the basement of a house in St. Francis.

 

Kidding, of course. That BC gear really looks sweet. Jealous!

Posted

Looks like you don't need that twin screw vise anymore.

I heard of a special recycling facility in the basement of a house in St. Francis.

Kidding, of course. That BC gear really looks sweet. Jealous!

I'll sell it to you :)

Posted

I'll sell it to you :)

Money for me is tighter than the gaps in Paul Sellers dovetails. I have been living without a vise for awhile, and I have some pretty decent work arounds. Albeit, not the most efficient. 

 

Thanks for the offer, though :)

Posted

Money for me is tighter than the gaps in Paul Sellers dovetails. I have been living without a vise for awhile, and I have some pretty decent work arounds. Albeit, not the most efficient.

Thanks for the offer, though :)

It's not going anywhere soon. I'll probably keep it where it is for awhile. I'd rather not ship it. Maybe craigslist, but I don't care for being hassled to death. :)

Posted

It's not going anywhere soon. I'll probably keep it where it is for awhile. I'd rather not ship it. Maybe craigslist, but I don't care for being hassled to death. :)

Yeah, put it up on CL and it will be like going into the Pawn Stars shop. You first asking price is $200. Their first counter offer is $10.

Posted

Yeah, put it up on CL and it will be like going into the Pawn Stars shop. You first asking price is $200. Their first counter offer is $10.

The worst part is people assume because someone is selling something nice, then they must be broke, or just lost a job. You would never guess how many people assumed I lost a job when I sold a nice bass, or a Snap-On toolbox.

Posted

 

696f134a75b7a726c21bcc3583991852.jpg

 

 

This bench ^^^ is Bad. Ass.

 

But I have to agree with Barry about the cabinets...nope, not for me.  But for a different reason: because I like to sit on a stool when I do tedious detail work, especially with chisels, and the cabinets would get in the way of my knees.  When I sit at my bench I just pop a few dogs out so they don't dig into my legs, and rest my feet on the shelf.

 

Man, it pisses me off that now BC casts their logo into the wheels instead of just giving you those cheesy little stickers. <_<

Posted

Yes it is! That's the one that made me want to build a Shaker bench.

 

I'm not a sitter, so that's not an issue :) 

 

I actually like the logo cast into the wheel. Or, do you not like it because you have the other style?

 

I'm sure they'll have something more awesome in a couple of years. 

Posted

I'm a sitter too Eric. I have my really comfortable drum stool in the shop now, and I sit at the bench for joinery work. The stool, my task light and music makes it a whole lot more relaxing.

Posted

Yes it is! That's the one that made me want to build a Shaker bench.

 

I'm not a sitter, so that's not an issue :)

 

I actually like the logo cast into the wheel. Or, do you not like it because you have the other style?

 

I'm sure they'll have something more awesome in a couple of years. 

 

Yeah I'd much rather have the logo cast in the wheel.  Way cooler.  Oh well, that's life.

 

Exactly Freddie.  I think I posted this quote on another thread recently but it's worth repeating:

 

Why stand when you can sit? -Winston Churchill

 

I'm a convenience enthusiast. :D

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.