pghmyn Posted November 20, 2013 Report Posted November 20, 2013 My birthday is December 1st, and I usually don't ask for anything on my birthday. If my parents are going to get me anything I can wait until Christmas. I asked for a few tools this year, and my mom decided to give me one as an early birthday present. She just couldn't wait for me to have it, which I'm not complaining about My new Lie-Nielsen 3/16" socket chisel! So, before I go all crazy in the shop, what is the recommended sharpening I do to this chisel? Just a secondary bevel, or full on sharpening process? Quote
JerrySats Posted November 20, 2013 Report Posted November 20, 2013 You should be ready to go out of the box with that LN chisel . Back should be flat and edge sharp , give it a run over your hand hairs and see if it shaves them . That's how i check sharpness . Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted November 20, 2013 Report Posted November 20, 2013 Deneb has a good video on the LN YouTube channel. Flattening the back and doing a micro bevel is what I did on mine and so good so far. Quote
pghmyn Posted November 20, 2013 Author Report Posted November 20, 2013 You should be ready to go out of the box with that LN chisel . Back should be flat and edge sharp , give it a run over your hand hairs and see if it shaves them . That's how i check sharpness . Did not shave any hairs. But it feels incredibly sharp compared to my other chisels. Do you have a good mallet? Nope, I'm going to pound the hell out of it with a claw hammer!! HAHA. Kidding, of course, I plan on making a mallet before I go crazy on the chisel Deneb has a good video on the LN YouTube channel. Flattening the back and doing a micro bevel is what I did on mine and so good so far. I watched the video a few times, and I hope I can achieve the same results he does with just my India oil stone. Quote
Llama Posted November 20, 2013 Report Posted November 20, 2013 Claw hammer! Well, as long as it's an Estwing it's ok Quote
..Kev Posted November 20, 2013 Report Posted November 20, 2013 Happy early Birthday Sam! Congrats on the new toy! Quote
pghmyn Posted November 20, 2013 Author Report Posted November 20, 2013 Claw hammer! Well, as long as it's an Estwing it's ok You sound like Graham now Happy early Birthday Sam! Congrats on the new toy! Happy Birthday Sam. Thank you. I decided to give a slight sharpening to the chisel tonight, instead of waiting until tomorrow. Come on, that thing was just aching to be used. I polished the back a little bit, and it is completely flat out of the box. A few strokes on the bevel, and a tiny secondary bevel was then added. I put a scrap of cherry on the bench, cut an arbitrary dovetail pin, and did a small amount of paring. The control that I have with this chisel is unbelievable. I can see why a chisel this size is so sought after. I know that I will want at least two more Lie Nielsen chisels, but those can wait I have this baby to toy around with! Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted November 20, 2013 Report Posted November 20, 2013 LV may have the Pm-v11 but the socket construction and handle design are just so well planned (thanks Stanley) that it brings the balance sheet squarely to the LN side for me. 1 Quote
ChrisG Posted November 20, 2013 Report Posted November 20, 2013 I watched the video a few times, and I hope I can achieve the same results he does with just my India oil stone. You can get pretty sharp with just the india but not as sharp as he does with his fine water stone in that video. Get yourself a cheap stick of honing compound. Doesn't matter what kind, but you want something less than 3 micron and preferably something around 1 micron. Rub it around on a piece of MDF. After working a fresh edge on your inda, lift the bevel a bit so your just honing a tiny area at a slightly higher angle... if you are using a guide backing the blade into the guide a little farther to increase the angle has the same effect. Take pull strokes only until you can see a tiny TINY polish line at the very tip of the edge (so small you can barely see it). Then take a bunch of pulls on the back of the blade to make sure the burr is off and the back of the edge is polished/...be sure you are holding it down FLAT to the MDF. If do this right it can get you and edge as good as any fine waterstone. You probably don't want to work the back of your LN chisel on you india stone...it's unlikley your india will get it flatter than it already is. You just want to polish the back. The next time you sharpen go back to the india and hone on the primary (or secondary) bevel that you honed on with the india before. Each time you hone with the india you are removing the polished area (which is one reason why you want you keep it tiny). The thin polished area that gets removed each time is often called a tertiary bevel (becasue the you'll likely be working a secondary bevel with the india and this tiny bevel is sorta a 2nd secondary bevel). You remove it each time to ensure that it stays tiny, which is what allows you to make the jump from something somewhat coarse like an india to something very fine like honing compound. You can refresh that "tertiary" bevel using just the compound between honings on the india, but again you don't want to let it grow because then it will take too long to remove when you go back to the india. This method is specifically catered towards making big leaps in grit, and it work very well for an inexpensive india stone/honing compound setup. Anyway, it all sound esoteric and confusing when written out, but its not. Basically your just polishing the smallest area of steel possible each time you make the jump from the india to the compound. Sounds like you might already be doing this or something very similar to this, so hopefully it all makes sense. Oh yeah...Happy Birthday! Quote
pghmyn Posted November 20, 2013 Author Report Posted November 20, 2013 You can get pretty sharp with just the india but not as sharp as he does with his fine water stone in that video. Get yourself a cheap stick of honing compound. Doesn't matter what kind, but you want something less than 3 micron and preferably something around 1 micron. Rub it around on a piece of MDF. After working a fresh edge on your inda, lift the bevel a bit so your just honing a tiny area at a slightly higher angle... if you are using a guide backing the blade into the guide a little farther to increase the angle has the same effect. Take pull strokes only until you can see a tiny TINY polish line at the very tip of the edge (so small you can barely see it). Then take a bunch of pulls on the back of the blade to make sure the burr is off and the back of the edge is polished/...be sure you are holding it down FLAT to the MDF. If do this right it can get you and edge as good as any fine waterstone. You probably don't want to work the back of your LN chisel on you india stone...it's unlikley your india will get it flatter than it already is. You just want to polish the back. The next time you sharpen go back to the india and hone on the primary (or secondary) bevel that you honed on with the india before. Each time you hone with the india you are removing the polished area (which is one reason why you want you keep it tiny). The thin polished area that gets removed each time is often called a tertiary bevel (becasue the you'll likely be working a secondary bevel with the india and this tiny bevel is sorta a 2nd secondary bevel). You remove it each time to ensure that it stays tiny, which is what allows you to make the jump from something somewhat coarse like an india to something very fine like honing compound. You can refresh that "tertiary" bevel using just the compound between honings on the india, but again you don't want to let it grow because then it will take too long to remove when you go back to the india. This method is specifically catered towards making big leaps in grit, and it work very well for an inexpensive india stone/honing compound setup. Anyway, it all sound esoteric and confusing when written out, but its not. Basically your just polishing the smallest area of steel possible each time you make the jump from the india to the compound. Sounds like you might already be doing this or something very similar to this, so hopefully it all makes sense. Oh yeah...Happy Birthday!I will have to pick up some of that honing compound. Sounds like it would work wonders. I know Graham won't like this, but I plan on getting a honing guide some day soon Free hand is nice, but I would just like that other "hand" to guide me. Benefit of this chisel being so small, Only a couple light swipes on the stone and I was ready to go. Quote
Freddie Posted November 20, 2013 Report Posted November 20, 2013 I just want to point out that i recommended the 3/16", ill take my credit now congrats on the new tool sam and happy birthday! Quote
pghmyn Posted November 20, 2013 Author Report Posted November 20, 2013 I just want to point out that i recommended the 3/16", ill take my credit now congrats on the new tool sam and happy birthday!Thank you. Where would I be without your amazing recommendation? Now I have to somehow fit a LN #4 somewhere in a list. Maybe when taxes come back Quote
Freddie Posted November 20, 2013 Report Posted November 20, 2013 Go bronze, it changed my life! Quote
ChrisG Posted November 20, 2013 Report Posted November 20, 2013 I will have to pick up some of that honing compound. Sounds like it would work wonders. I know Graham won't like this, but I plan on getting a honing guide some day soon Free hand is nice, but I would just like that other "hand" to guide me. Benefit of this chisel being so small, Only a couple light swipes on the stone and I was ready to go. I much prefer to freehand, but I think that unless you have someone to show what a sharp tool is its good to at least start with guide (and of course, nothing wrong with always using one). When I learned to freehand I had been been working with handtools and honing with a guide for a couple years, so I new I was doing it right once I could get a tool as sharp freehand as I could with a guide. I wouldn't have known how to measure my success otherwise. Freehand honing is a valuable skill to develop at some point since there are some tools that are not as readily honed in a guide, but I would certainly advise keeping a cheap $10-$15 side clamping guide around....that's all you really need. I still keep one around even though I freehand hone 99% of the time, do still find it useful to have sometimes. Honing compound is just the cheapest way to get to an ultra fine level. A fine stone is a bit a nicer and easier to use, but compound will get you just as good and edge provided you A] use it correctly (which is also the case with a stone) and B] make sure your substrate is flat and uncontaminated. Lots of dust and grit float around our shops so its a good idea to keep you substrate with the compound on it wrapped in a paper towel or something. Even if it doesn't work wonders right way, it will certainly improve the edge of an india. Quote
G S Haydon Posted November 21, 2013 Report Posted November 21, 2013 My birthday is December 1st, and I usually don't ask for anything on my birthday. If my parents are going to get me anything I can wait until Christmas. I asked for a few tools this year, and my mom decided to give me one as an early birthday present. She just couldn't wait for me to have it, which I'm not complaining about My new Lie-Nielsen 3/16" socket chisel! So, before I go all crazy in the shop, what is the recommended sharpening I do to this chisel? Just a secondary bevel, or full on sharpening process? Happy Birthday Sam and let's here it for your Mom! A lovely tool as well, brilliant! I have pm you a vid of what I think would be appopriate. Firstly with what I say next feel free to disregard it completely as there are so many ways to skin a cat. Skin yours how you see fit. On prepping, this is hard for me as I don't see the merit in all but maybee one chislel (if that) in my tool box having a flat back. I bought an Irwin Blue Chip and it was ready to go in about two mins because in my view it's made in a way I prefer, slightly hollow in it's lenght, as is my Ashey Iles MKII, as are Narex Chisels. If you want sharp, on the back of the chisel only the area just behind the back needs to be refined to the same level as your sharpening medium of choice. I personally have no need to go any further than shown below. This will take longer on a perfectly flat back as you will be working a larger area. And when I say the back is hollow in it's length it's not by much. This is the chisel resting on a flat hard arkansas. I can only echo Chris and others which is to focus your honing on a small secondary bevel. This means you focus the fine abrasive on a small area enabling a big jump in grits, this brings very quick and sharp results. Once the secondary bevel gets big remove it and establish the primary bevel again. A cheap side clamping eclipse style jig and the coarse side of your Inda will be great for this. BTW is it A2 or O1 (please say O1 ), all jocking aside I have not used A2 so I cant comment. Chris can dobtless advise you more on the slightly steeper angle of honing often discussed when using A2. Before you worry about shaving hairs with it, cutting paper etc try your edge on some wood and see how you go. For a tool like this you might want to lean on mom for a finer stone/medium of your choice. On using a Jig for honing, that's just fine, it's not about ho you sharpen it's what you make with it. Would I hit this with a hammer, no, would I tap it with a hammer, yes, what would that hammer be? Estwing . When I get time to attend a show I cant wait to get my mits on some of these hgh end tools. Enjoy it Sam. Quote
G S Haydon Posted November 21, 2013 Report Posted November 21, 2013 LV may have the Pm-v11 but the socket construction and handle design are just so well planned (thanks Stanley) that it brings the balance sheet squarely to the LN side for me. I would love to trial these or the Stanley's Tony, I always fear the handle is gonna come loose. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.