Recommended Posts

Posted

I did it tonight. 

 

I have 2 Disston saws that I had purchased for 5 bucks each. They needed a little cleaning up, but the steel was straight and no teeth were missing....so i figured they were good enough saws.

 

I looked over a few internet sources for some instruction on saw sharpening...and decided that Bob Rozaieski"s video seemed legit.

 

http://logancabinetshoppe.com/blog/2009/09/episode-7/

 

I did the rip saw first, and it really made a big difference. It cuts very quickly after sharpening. Success!

 

The crosscut saw....I'm not so sure.It didn't seem to cut like what I expected it should....but I'm very green when it come to this. I really have no clue what it "should" cut like. It also left a very rough edge....not at all like what I see on other peoples videos.

 

Maybe I snafu'd the filing of the crosscut? I'm not sure....

 

Should I try again until it seems right?

Posted

Great work Dan. I'm anxious to try this too. Being raised on a diet off the brillinat but disposable hardpoint saws means I will be newbie too. I will take a look at Bob's how to, fortunatley a lot of people like Bob are putting info like this out there.

Posted

I would try it again, what do you have to loose! I have sharpened a couple rip saws but not a crosscut, yet. My crosscut saws are family heirlooms so I am going to do as you did and buy an inexpensive old saw and practice till I feel comfortable doing it. Keep us posted!!

Posted

Crosscuts can be tough at first. Most new filers don't finish the job. What I mean is that they stop filing when the think they're there when in fact each tooth could use a few more strokes. You're removing more steel filing crosscut because of the fleam. So my suggestion would be for you to make another pass down the saw, making two to three strokes on each tooth (count and be consistent so you don't create big and little teeth) without jointing first. You should see the teeth all of a sudden appear to get longer if you're going far enough. When you're done the teeth should "stick" to your fingers because they come to sharp points at their tips. Getting a clean, smooth end grain cut comes later and takes a bit more diagnosis and fussing, so ignore the cut surface for now. Just focus in getting a saw that crosscuts correctly. A properly filed western cc saw will cut every bit as fast as one of those hardened tooth disposable saws with the Japanese style teeth. If you can post some good clear close up pictures of the teeth it will help diagnose the problem as well.

Posted

Hi Bob!

 

I think you are right...I kind of felt a little paranoid about filing each tooth too much. I ran the file in each gullet twice. I don't really know firsthand what a properly filed crosscut looks like....so I just stopped with 2.

 

Here's a few pics of the saw after filing:

 

post-13786-0-98109600-1385309257_thumb.j

 

post-13786-0-99637400-1385309258_thumb.j

 

post-13786-0-00571000-1385309260_thumb.j

 

post-13786-0-94496800-1385309256_thumb.j

 

 

Also....after reading the instructions on the vintage saws site, I realized that i had filed towards the heel of the saw and not towards the toe. I'm not sure how much a difference this would make, but I think that may be part of the problem too. 

Posted

Don't put so much pressure on the file. Take long, smooth, straight and level strokes. Long smooth strokes will allow you to get each tooth to a good, sharp point with a smooth shiny face to the whole face of the tooth. Lay a sheet of white paper on the off side, and practice putting the same amount of shavings on it with different length strokes. Then practice putting more or fewer shaving on it with full length strokes.

Rake looks like it might be a little different on each side, but it might just be the lighting.

You're very close. I'd rejoint lightly, and hit it again. Take half of the flat, jointed, shiny part on the first side, and just finish taking it on the other. Later, you will learn to even up any irregular teeth in the process. The practicing taking different amounts of shavings with a full stroke will help you get this part later, but it only comes with practice.

When sharpening a Rip saw, I set first. That way all the tops of the teeth are flat on the same plane when you get finished. With a crosscut, it doesn't really matter, but I usually set them after. I don't stone the whole side, but look for any teeth sticking out too far, and stone that section if needed.

Good eye magnifiers help a lot, but take a little getting used to.

I think the "file towards the toe" can be a little misleading. It doesn't matter which end of the saw you start at, but file towards the side that the tooth is set towards-file towards the cutting edge, not into it-so the file is always going "towards the toe" while filing.

Posted

Don't put so much pressure on the file. Take long, smooth, straight and level strokes. Long smooth strokes will allow you to get each tooth to a good, sharp point with a smooth shiny face to the whole face of the tooth. Lay a sheet of white paper on the off side, and practice putting the same amount of shavings on it with different length strokes. Then practice putting more or fewer shaving on it with full length strokes.

Rake looks like it might be a little different on each side, but it might just be the lighting.

You're very close. I'd rejoint lightly, and hit it again. Take half of the flat, jointed, shiny part on the first side, and just finish taking it on the other. Later, you will learn to even up any irregular teeth in the process. The practicing taking different amounts of shavings with a full stroke will help you get this part later, but it only comes with practice.

When sharpening a Rip saw, I set first. That way all the tops of the teeth are flat on the same plane when you get finished. With a crosscut, it doesn't really matter, but I usually set them after. I don't stone the whole side, but look for any teeth sticking out too far, and stone that section if needed.

Good eye magnifiers help a lot, but take a little getting used to.

I think the "file towards the toe" can be a little misleading. It doesn't matter which end of the saw you start at, but file towards the side that the tooth is set towards-file towards the cutting edge, not into it-so the file is always going "towards the toe" while filing.

 

 I had the file pointing towards the heel while I was filing. I think I should give it a redo tonight.

 

 

Check the flash reflection in the last pic. You have two planes on each tooth. Which plane is your cut?

 

As green as this may make me sound.....I think both planes are my cuts.

Posted

You haven't filed the whole tooth. This is the common problem I was referring to. Looking at the pictures, the shiny area has been filed, the dull area has not. So you have different fleam angles at different points on the edge if the tooth. You're also getting some classic "cows & calves" or big & little teeth. This comes from applying uneven pressure on adjacent teeth. To keep this from occurring, focus on filing the bottom of the gullet, not the front or back of a tooth. However, you will need to focus on the front/back of the larger teeth now in order to correct the mis-spaced teeth.

To correct these teeth, I'd refiled the saw as a rip saw to start. Stay with the crosscut rake angle (about 15-20 degrees) but don't file any fleam. File the teeth straight across, like a rip saw, all from the same side. It will be easier to correct the spacing if you don't have to worry about fleam. You may need to joint and file multiple times. Focus on getting evenly spaced "rip" teeth that are all about the same size. After the shaping is done, set the teeth, joint once or twice lightly just to even out the tips. Then file in the fleam. Color the teeth with soot from a candle before filing the fleam. This will give you an indicator to know when you have filed the fleam all the way to the bottom of the gullet. Make multiple passes if needed, making just two to three strokes per gullet each pass. Again, don't turn the around. File every other tooth toward the toe first, then file the other teeth toward the heel. Use a rake angle guide block to maintain the proper rake angle. Stop and look at the side profile of the teeth often to make sure you're keeping adjacent teeth even.

Keep at it. You're almost there. Shape the teeth rip first. It's easier. Then file the fleam after setting. It will keep everything more consistent. Once the saw is done, you won't need to file "rip" again unless you want to alter the rake angle. Usually, the first filing of a new old saw is doing exactly that. So filing "rip" first really helps you get an even rake angle on the teeth because you're only worrying about one angle at a time.

Posted

I re-jointed and made a pass to file it rip. I made 2 strokes per gullet...and I could see that I wasn't at the bottom of the gullet yet on some of the teeth. Rake angle is 15 degrees.

 

post-13786-0-50850300-1385352086_thumb.j

 

I jointed the saw again and made another pass doing exactly the same thing...2 strokes per gullet. and this time I could see the bottoms of all the gullets were shiny.

 

post-13786-0-56663500-1385352085_thumb.j

 

I think it looks better now...the teeth seem to be more even. Unless anyone sees something that I'm missing...I think it's ready for filing the fleam.

Posted

Almost there. It looks like there's still a hint of roundness at the tips of some of the teeth. I don't think you're filing the whole flat away. Get the teeth to sharp rip teeth first. One more pass without jointing should do it. Also, how many PPI is the saw and what size file are you using. The bottoms of the gullets look kind of a large radius for the size of the teeth. May just be because the flats haven't totally been removed yet.

Posted

OK. So I am sharpening a crosscut saw today, so I snapped a picture of the teeth. This is what you are looking for in crosscut teeth. The teeth all come to a needle sharp point that "sticks" to your fingers. The points are all at the same height. The front and back of each tooth has a single, flat bevel that goes from the point all the way to the bottom of the gullet. Use this picture as a reference when you file the fleam into your saw. This saw had 8 PPI and I used a 6" slim taper file.

post-2117-0-75287000-1385394792_thumb.jp

Posted

OK. So I am sharpening a crosscut saw today, so I snapped a picture of the teeth. This is what you are looking for in crosscut teeth. The teeth all come to a needle sharp point that "sticks" to your fingers. The points are all at the same height. The front and back of each tooth has a single, flat bevel that goes from the point all the way to the bottom of the gullet. Use this picture as a reference when you file the fleam into your saw. This saw had 8 PPI and I used a 6" slim taper file.

attachicon.gifimage.jpg

 

Good night....those look perfect Bob!

 

My saw is either an 8 or 9 PPI...I'm not sure if you count the first point or not.

 

I'm also not sure what size number my file is. It was just and old 3-square file that came in a box I picked up second hand.

 

 

 

 

Baby steps Dan...baby steps...

Posted

I picked up new 6 x slim file and started the process over again. Joint and file rip cut. It went much smoother this time, and I could feel the file register with each gullet. All the teeth looked even, so I filed the fleam at 25 degrees. Here is the result...

 

post-13786-0-69959100-1385437790_thumb.j

 

I think it looks good.

 

I made a test cut in some 4/4 pine and the saw felt really grabby. It did cut quickly, but it would stop often. Maybe I have a tooth that's sticking up too high? Maybe it's the soft wood?

Posted

YES! Those look great! Nice job! As you noticed, the correct file can make a big difference. Files do get dull, pretty quickly these days in fact, so it's worth it to spend the $4 for a new, sharp file for this work, especially when most folks will likely only need to sharpen their saws once every year or two.

The grabbiness could be a few things. The saw may be under set. It may be unevenly set. The kerf could be closing. You could have a tooth or two that are sticking up a bit high. Or it could just be that you're not used to using a sharp saw and you might be trying to force the saw through the cut subconsciously. When you're used to using dull saws, there is a tendency to apply downward force into the cut to keep the teeth engaged in the cut and keep the saw progressing. However, if you put downward pressure on a sharp saw, the teeth dig in and the saw grabs. Try lightening your grip on the handle and letting only the weight of the saw carry itself through the cut. Focus your effort moving the saw forward, not down into the wood.

Posted

I'll have to go back and re-watch some videos on sawing technique....I wasn't subconsciously trying to force the saw through the cut, I was very consciously trying to force it!

 

Bob - Thank-you so much for helping me get started on saw-sharpening. I owe you lunch someday. 

Posted

Good job!!! You're making a good example of the learning process. Check the rake now too. Did you make a little rake indicator handle for the off hand? More rake equals faster cut, but can make one "grabby" too.

Posted

Good job!!! You're making a good example of the learning process. Check the rake now too. Did you make a little rake indicator handle for the off hand? More rake equals faster cut, but can make one "grabby" too.

 

I did make one of those handles out of some scrap wood. The rake is set at 15 degrees...I'm not sure if that's good for a beginner like me or not, but it seems like a good starting point.

 

My only experience with hand saws was using my dad's old rusty panel saw when I was a kid. I literally had to hold it down with my other hand just to get it to cut anything.

 

I also lost his keyhole saw in the lawn once because I was pretending to be Hans Solo. Dad found out when he hit it with the lawnmower.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.