Recommended Posts

Posted

I recently purchase a set of inexpensive Narex bench chisels and I've trying to several hours to flatten the backs with mixed results. 2 of the 6 are flat (I've used a sharpie to judge), but other 4 have various high spots, some at the tip, the 1" chisel still has a quarter-sized high spot in the middle. And despite hundreds of strokes I don't seem to be getting any further with 220.

 

Setup: I've been using a 220 equivalent DMT 8" diamond plate and some water. I have the 325, 600, and 1200 equivalents, but I haven't gotten there yet.

 

Method: I've been holding the blade perpendicular to the stone with as much of the blade as possible on the stone and moving back and forth along the length of the stone staying perpendicular to the stone. For the 1/8" chisel I held the chisel more at 45 degrees for a larger reference surface.

 

I did try to run one chisel on some cheap 180 sandpaper on my MDF workbench, but it only trimmed the edges of the blade and now it's convex.

 

Go I need to go scary sharp down to 180? (I'd hate to buy nice sandpaper and a flat surface for what should be a one-time operation) If so, what is the most efficient movement to flatten the back? Or is there a better method for use on the 220 diamond plate?

 

Thanks

 

 

Posted

Try just flattening the first 1" of the blade. You don't need to flatten the entire back.

 

I can give that a try, I guess I've been trying to flatten the first 2.5" so far.

Posted

High spots are a problem if you want to pare with the chisel. Low spots are not as much of a problem away from the cutting edge. If you truly have high spots within the first inch or two, eventually you will have to deal with them in order to get a good cutting edge that is not curved. I don't have a diamond stone but I do have very coarse oil stone. If 220 is not getting fast enough result, I would move to a lower grit and then move up the grits. The plus side to removing the high spots is that you'll only need to do this once. Some won't mess around if the chisel is high in the middle instead of slightly concave.

Posted

==>Need help flattening chisel backs

==>various high spots

==>I don't seem to be getting any further with 220

 

Narex uses Cr-Mn high-carbon steel. While not as tough as some of the new kids on the block, it's still pretty hard. You'll be there all day with 220... It'll get done, but you're going to spend some serious time... And you've got four chisels with high spots???

 

==>I'd hate to buy nice sandpaper and a flat surface for what should be a one-time operation

This is Sparta! OK, it's only sharpening... But, you can save time or $$ -- not both...

 

With four chisels, you're going to have to figure what you're time is worth...

If you get yourself a Chosera #400, you'll be done in about 30 minutes... But that's a $65 solution...

Posted

I have every Narex chisel and haven't seen that kind of bad quality. Bad batch?

 

Some of them have very pronounced machining marks - good overall flatness, but they take some work removing.  Seems to be getting better, my newer ones (mortising, paring) were better than my bench set.

Posted

Dude, I have a set of 8105's, the 25mm took a little while but nowhere near that long!

 

This dude prep's some narex backs here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBZ8446KqkM if it helps, took him 7mins or so and he is not rushing. One word of warning, I cut myself on these little devils, the junction between the land on the side and the back of chisel is real sharp. It's not often I cut myself and doing it this way was a first!

Posted

==>^^^

Nice video... The 100u lapping film makes pretty quick work of hollow backs... Would take a bit longer with the 'quarter sized' high-spots the OP describes -- that's quite a bit of steel...

 

Listening to the video, it sounds like the OP's set is a bit of an outlier...

Posted
BTW: Looked at the rest of Workshop Heaven's videos – what a great group of guys…
 
Thanks…
 
Really liked their Kell Jig Wedge demo…
 
One thing that struck me funny --- I happen to have a Kell jig as well (nice piece of kit, BTW) and I also made a wedge according to Richard's instructions – but without the benefit of YouTube -- but with the benefit of power tools…
 
You can really tell who’s a Normite and who’s a Neander on this little exercise…
 
Workshop Heaven: Carefully scribe the stock on all sides. Pare a relief chamfer. Pare the wedge. Chop a scribe line for the handle cut. Saw to the line. Chop the scribe line for the release cut. Saw to the line. Plane the faces smooth. Done. Total time: 5 minutes…
 
TrippleH: Hold miter gauge against instruction sheet, read bevel angle. Set SCMS bevel angle to match. Chop wedge. Reset SCMS to 90*. Chop release cut. Double-stick tape wedge to sacrificial stock. Smooth wedge faces with disk sander. Done. Total time: 5 minutes…
 
D'oh... Hate when that happens… :)
 
BTW: @OP: GSH's right, send them back...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.