Recommended Posts

Posted

I have had a Veritas MKII guide for a year or so and it has work well on chisels.  I got a Stanely low angle jsack plane #62 for Christmas.  I sharpened the blade to 25 degrees and discovered that the MKII does not leave the end of the blade square with the sides. I was not too concerned until I found that the plane has very little tilt adjustment and I mean very little. The width of the blade is just over 1/64" narrower than the distance between the plane body walls.

 

I cannot adjust the tlilt of the blade far enough to compensate for the unsquareness that the MKII left in the blade.  I think it would work if the blade were just a little narrower so it does not contact the sides of the body of the plane so soon.

With the blade removed the planes tilt adusting mechanism moves quite a lot but it is the blade width that limits the movement.

 

Any ideas or comments?  Should the MK II be closer to perfectly square.  Did I just get a bad one?  Should I accept the tolerance of the MK II and return the plane?

 

Ronn

Posted

Thanks for your suggestions.  I have doubled checked everything.  I had a talk with the "plane expert" at the local Woodcraft store.  He tried my blade in my guide and we noticed that the high side of my blade was being sharpened more than the low side.  Our conclusion was that I am unconsciously putting a little more pressure on one side of the guide as I roll in on the sand paper or sharpening stone.  This becomes much more visible the lower the angle of the blade and the wider the blade is.

 

Since I reset the angle on this blade starting with 80 grit sandpaper and had to sometimes hold the sandpaper with one hand and operate the guide with one hand I think I have found the problem.  From now on a glue the sandpaper down so I can use both hands on the guide.

 

By the way,  I ground just a little steel of of each side (edge of the blade) only for the rear half of the blade and gained considerable adjustment room.

 

Thanks again everyone.

Posted

A tip for you, and others that put uneven pressure on your blades when sharpening... Try using pull strokes on your stones/paper/whatever you use. You shouldn't really be pressing down much unless you are purposely introducing camber to the blade, which is more that I care to get in to here. :)

 

Just buy this dvd... It will solve all of your sharpening problems. Keep in mind, I didn't say this dvd was exciting ;)

 

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/dvds/hand-tool-techniques-part-1-plane-sharpening/

Posted

I use the MKII, and keep the cambering roller on it all the time.  I used the thing you put on the front the first time to establish the right "stick-out" for the different bevel angles, and with an iron set by the guide, used it to put stops on the plywood base of a grinder that's always on the sharpening bench top.  That way, it's just as fast as any other guide to set up. 

 

The single best thing about this guide is the click stops for micro-bevels. Anyone can get an edge to maximum possible sharpness, which considering how much of a barrier it is for a LOT of people to get through, that alone makes it worth the price of admission.  My helpers do have some trouble with narrower chisels, but they can still go in the Eclipse.  Lee Valley is coming out with a special side clamping one just for chisels, and I'm sure I'll order one of those as soon as it's out.

 

For irons with a lot of camber, like the Scrub plane or Jack, I have an old Record guide that just has a narrow ball for the roller.  It works great for that use.

Posted

The blade is probably moving in the jig slightly.  Virtually all top-clamping honing jigs suffer from this problem to one degree or another (it's even worse if you use oilstones).  The 'out-of-square' problem has been widely reported across several forums.  I thought I had heard Lee Valley was going to redesign the thing or come out with a new jig altogether.

 

A side-clamping jig, an Eclipse clone, available for less than $15 is the essence of simplicity and by far the easiest solution to the problem.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.