DaveT Posted May 9, 2014 Report Posted May 9, 2014 I'm planning a workbench that is made from construction grade 2x4s for the frame and possibly also for the top (depends how many I mess up on the frame). The bench will be one of a pair that will take up over half of my available floor space and will have to cope with a serious amount of abuse. Having watched countless videos, read endless blogs, spent untold hours lying in bed at night cogitating I've now reached the point where I know what joints I'm going to use for the frame - mortise and tenon. Relatively simple but with a lot of strength and will allow me to dismantle it when I win the lottery and buy a big house with dedicated workshop - drool!!! I'm thinking of a tusked tenon to join the front and rear rails to the legs, and a cogged tenon to join the side stretchers. This combination seems to give the maximum strength along the bench and allows me to tighten it up if it gets loose. Exactly the same joints will be used for the lower rails/stretchers. What do you reckon - too complicated? Alternative solutions/advice gratefully accepted Quote
Dave H Posted May 9, 2014 Report Posted May 9, 2014 Seems like a far amount of work for a joint that's not all that stunning, if it's just a 2x4 bench I'd just do some shallow mortised and tenon joints and lag bolt that sucker together so I could have a bench to do some fancy joints on. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted May 9, 2014 Report Posted May 9, 2014 All that joinery will be wasted on construction lumber. Most 2x4s are too soft to keep tight joints without glue or bolts. Lateral forces applied as you work at the bench will make the joints loose pretty fast. Quote
..Kev Posted May 9, 2014 Report Posted May 9, 2014 Doesn't matter if you're making fine furniture or shop furniture. The goal is to enjoy the process as much or more than the end result. So I say the decision is solely yours. 1 Quote
skiback46 Posted May 9, 2014 Report Posted May 9, 2014 That joint does look like fun to cut. As far as "wasting" it on construction lumber, I think it would look better in the shop as part of a bench, than on a piece of furniture. I say try cutting a joint, and see how tight it gets using the 2x4's and go from there. Quote
Bob Lang Posted May 9, 2014 Report Posted May 9, 2014 Joints are only as strong as their weakest link, and that's the amount of wood left over after making the cuts. You don't have much meat in the leg or in the one stretcher. If I were building a bench from 2 x 4s I would assemble the legs as an "L". them simply tenon the rails into the legs and get on with making things. Bob Lang 1 Quote
krtwood Posted May 10, 2014 Report Posted May 10, 2014 Pocket screws and move on with your life http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=69V07Uq9iDc (How do you embed a youtube video on the forums?) Quote
DaveT Posted May 10, 2014 Author Report Posted May 10, 2014 Thanks for the input guys. Much appreciated and I've taken them on board. Seems like a far amount of work for a joint that's not all that stunning, if it's just a 2x4 bench I'd just do some shallow mortised and tenon joints and lag bolt that sucker together so I could have a bench to do some fancy joints on. The aim wasn't to produce a stunning joint but rather one that would work. Think I got that a bit wrong as well All that joinery will be wasted on construction lumber. Most 2x4s are too soft to keep tight joints without glue or bolts. Lateral forces applied as you work at the bench will make the joints loose pretty fast. Very fair point there. It was one of my major concerns. I think this video (from about the 10 min point) from Paul Sellers shows how to solve the problem though. Doesn't matter if you're making fine furniture or shop furniture. The goal is to enjoy the process as much or more than the end result. So I say the decision is solely yours. Couldn't agree more That joint does look like fun to cut. As far as "wasting" it on construction lumber, I think it would look better in the shop as part of a bench, than on a piece of furniture. I say try cutting a joint, and see how tight it gets using the 2x4's and go from there. I'm going to make a test joint to see how it performs. If nothing else it will give me some practice at making mortices and some firewood for next winter. Joints are only as strong as their weakest link, and that's the amount of wood left over after making the cuts. You don't have much meat in the leg or in the one stretcher. If I were building a bench from 2 x 4s I would assemble the legs as an "L". them simply tenon the rails into the legs and get on with making things. Bob Lang Another very good point and I don't know why it didn't occur to me. I guess I just got carried away trying to get things all neatly lined up. I'm going to use the video above as the basis for creating the ends. It has 2 2x4s laminated to make a leg. That will double the amount of wood and as the rails will now be attached on the outside there will only be one joint through the legs at the top and one at the bottom therefore leaving a lot more wood and therefore (hopefully) a stronger joint. Pocket screws and move on with your life http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=69V07Uq9iDc (How do you embed a youtube video on the forums?) Don't have a pocket screw jig and to be honest I'm not a great fan of them, but it is a valid idea As I said at the beginning guys, thanks for the input.You have saved me a great deal of wasted time and effort. Please have a on me. I'm going to spend the next couple of days re-doing my design and then hopefully I'll have one that corrects all the glaring errors you pointed out. Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted May 10, 2014 Report Posted May 10, 2014 How about a fox tenon on the side boards? Quote
DaveT Posted May 10, 2014 Author Report Posted May 10, 2014 How about a fox tenon on the side boards? I want to be able to dismantle the bench. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.