Kevmc Posted June 22, 2014 Report Posted June 22, 2014 looking for recommendations on sharpening a shoulder plane. I am using the verities sharpening jig but i just can't get the jig to hold the blade firm enough probably because its so narrow where its under the bar that holds it. I have a razor\ sharp skew chisel now. This is twice in a row!. Any recommendations. I just reground the blade square and sharpened free hand and it seems sharp enough but if you have any ideas on how to better use the veristas jig or another jig I would much appreciate it. I have a ton of shoulders to clean up with my new LN shoulder plane and my inability to sharpen the blade is a real bummer. I want to be a wood worker, not a metal worker! Quote
wdwerker Posted June 22, 2014 Report Posted June 22, 2014 Find something the same thickness to clamp either side of it and help keep it square. I do something like this on my Tormec. Haven't tried to sharpen my shoulder plane on my Veritas jig yet. Quote
rodger. Posted June 22, 2014 Report Posted June 22, 2014 I have sharpened my sholder plane blade a few times using the veritas jig with no issue. Are you clamping the blade with equal pressure on both sides of the blade? Don't push down too hard while honing. Quote
rodger. Posted June 22, 2014 Report Posted June 22, 2014 Sorry, just reread your post. I have the veritas shoulder plane, so maybe not so helpful advice! Quote
derekcohen Posted June 22, 2014 Report Posted June 22, 2014 Two obvious tasks: is the blade straight before you hone, and does the blade remain straight when you hone? Use a square to check the first one. For the second, ensure that the blade is in the centre of the guide and that there is equal pressure (look at the gaps) on each side. Start with very light strokes. Stop after a couple of strokes and look at the wear pattern. Is it straight? (It is a good idea to mark the bevel with a dark sharpie and score a line across it as a guide). Check with a square. If not, then adjust the tension with the adjustment screws, increasing the pressure on the side where you need to have more wear, and loosening it a tad on the other. Personally, I hollow grind my edges on a Tormek first. This has a similar clamping system to the LV honing guide. When all is set up correctly, it is still possible to skew the bevel if you fail to use even pressure across the blade. Watch for this with the LV guide. Similarly, I freehand hone my blades on the hollow. As with the guide, finger pressure on the blade will affect where the honing takes place. Regards from Perth Derek Quote
CStanford Posted June 22, 2014 Report Posted June 22, 2014 looking for recommendations on sharpening a shoulder plane. I am using the verities sharpening jig but i just can't get the jig to hold the blade firm enough probably because its so narrow where its under the bar that holds it. I have a razor\ sharp skew chisel now. This is twice in a row!. Any recommendations. I just reground the blade square and sharpened free hand and it seems sharp enough but if you have any ideas on how to better use the veristas jig or another jig I would much appreciate it. I have a ton of shoulders to clean up with my new LN shoulder plane and my inability to sharpen the blade is a real bummer. I want to be a wood worker, not a metal worker! Top clamping honing guides allow blades to skew, narrow blades particularly. And it's worse, for obvious reasons, if you use oilstones. Your best long term solution is to look for a different jig for small blades or develop your freehand skills. The problem with the Veritas jig is well-documented and the fix seems to be to just shower-down on the pressure. I thought I had heard they were coming out with a re-designed one or a side clamping jig. It's easier to freehand hone these things and keep them square if you're willing to go straight to a stone that will raise a burr in a hurry. A medium oilstone is actually not too coarse but a fine synthetic oilstone will raise a burr in five strokes or less unless the cutter was allowed to get really dull. Once you have a distinct and scratchy burr start flipping back and forth with light pressure on your finest stone for ten to twenty strokes or so (light pressure!) then strop or just swipe the cutter through the endgrain of a scrap block of pine. All of this might very well make Toshio Odate nauseous, but if you remove bluntness you're 98% of the way there. My routine may not produce the most highly polished cutter you've ever seen but it won't knock it out of square either if you're halfway careful. You'll be able to cut wood and the plane will function as it was intended. 1 Quote
Tom King Posted June 22, 2014 Report Posted June 22, 2014 I use both the MKII for some things, and the old Eclipse for others. I think you can get an Eclipse clone pretty cheap. Quote
Kevmc Posted June 22, 2014 Author Report Posted June 22, 2014 Thanks guys. I notices that I had the clamp very uneven. 1 end was almost bottomed out and the other was very high so that probably contribute to the problem. Plus I kept sharpening on a rough stone to get the last part of the bevel and that made the skew even worse. Having said that even with a proper tightened clamp on the jig the blade is not all that secure. I think I will just start practicing freehand sharpening In the long run it's faster which means I will sharpen more frequently which means I don't need a lot of strongest Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.