rodger. Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 I bought a dewalt router combo about 6 years back. It came with three bases and a load of accessories, and it has served me well for all of those years. It's a dw618 kit. The other day I was routing out some handles in a cutting board, and the motor went weird. Odd sounds, and loss of power. I finished what I was doing and then took the cap off the motor to see what was up. As soon as I opened the plastic shroud, a piece of a magnet fell out. Not good I thought - so I plugged it in and tested it. Lots of sparks and no VS. Brushes are good, but in my research afterwards, apparently this magnet ring is a common issue in this router. Anyways, I think the collet may be cooked too, so I am looking at at least 120 in parts and labour to repair.(collet, bearing, brushes, magnet ring, and perhaps more). Looks like it's time for a new router kit. I have a trim router and a big table mounted router already, so I really need a 2.25 range router for hand held work. I like the balance of the power/weight in this class for general purpose work. I was thinking the new bosh kit, but no dust collection accessories are included. Anyone have an especially good kit to recommend? Festool is out of my price range, and I dont want another dewalt. This ring issue is common, apparatly, and though it is tempting to just buy a replacement dewalt unit to keep all my accessories, I'm not really wanting to go that route. I'll post a photo of the router later today when I get out there. Quote
dwacker Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 I tend to stick with PC and just call it good enough. Quote
Cochese Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 Don't laugh, but I think the Craftsman Professional is a very good value proposition. I have two Craftsman, one 2HP, the other the 2.5HP model that preceded the current one. Very nicely built, LEDs, ergonomic. The power cable is similar to the Festool, but not the same - if you have some sort of dust extraction setup like a boom arm for Festool, you could just leave the cord on the hose too. Goes on sale fairly often for about $150, not a horrible price if you need one today. Mine came with dust nozzles. If you need, I can get some pictures later today. Mine is virtually identical to the one they sell now. http://www.sears.com/craftsman-14-amp-2.5-hp-fixed-plunge-base-router/p-00927680000P Quote
rodger. Posted December 26, 2014 Author Report Posted December 26, 2014 I tend to stick with PC and just call it good enough. Is this a 1 3/4 hp model? Quote
Llama Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 I just ordered the Dewalt this morning. And, just cancelled it. I heard of this before, but the timing seemed a little too coincidental. Kind of like bad mojo or something. May end up buying the Dewalt, but this makes me think twice. Quote
sjeff70 Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 Amazon.com indicates Makita is getting the best reviews for the class of router you're looking for. I think most are buying the Bosch because of the price. I will pay a little more for a better tool... $250.00 appeals to me for the Makita: http://www.amazon.com/Makita-RF1101KIT2-4-Horsepower-Variable-Speed-Plunge/dp/B0002HC4IM/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&qid=1419613327&sr=8-4&keywords=plunge+router+kit Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 Don't laugh, but I think the Craftsman Professional is a very good value proposition. I have two Craftsman, one 2HP, the other the 2.5HP model that preceded the current one. Very nicely built, LEDs, ergonomic. The power cable is similar to the Festool, but not the same - if you have some sort of dust extraction setup like a boom arm for Festool, you could just leave the cord on the hose too. Goes on sale fairly often for about $150, not a horrible price if you need one today. Mine came with dust nozzles. If you need, I can get some pictures later today. Mine is virtually identical to the one they sell now.http://www.sears.com/craftsman-14-amp-2.5-hp-fixed-plunge-base-router/p-00927680000P I own this router and love love love it. The weight and balance are great for a handheld work and the dust collector port does a great job even when hooked to a shop vac. Although one wouldn't think of it as a power piece, My bench mount was on the Fritz so I mounted this guy up under the table and ran a 3.25" panel bit to cut four door panels on it. I never bogged it down once. Quote
wdwerker Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 Bosch , PC , And Makita routers have performed well for me. I can't say enough about my Festool trim router, it's awesome. Y'all do know several PC and Dewalt models are made by the same MFG. Quote
rodger. Posted December 26, 2014 Author Report Posted December 26, 2014 I just ordered the Dewalt this morning. And, just cancelled it. I heard of this before, but the timing seemed a little too coincidental. Kind of like bad mojo or something. May end up buying the Dewalt, but this makes me think twice. If you by the dewalt and want some accessories, let me know and I can send you some. Just pay the shipping and they are yours! 1 Quote
Llama Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 I'll know tonight. Curious, which accessories do you have? Quote
rodger. Posted December 26, 2014 Author Report Posted December 26, 2014 Edge guide, fixed base, D handle base, plunge base, centering cone, DC adaptors, wrench, 1/4" collet, 1/2" collet, and the blow molded case Quote
rodger. Posted December 26, 2014 Author Report Posted December 26, 2014 You will want to check shipping from Ontario, Canada. Quote
rodger. Posted December 26, 2014 Author Report Posted December 26, 2014 Underneath that bearing is a magnet ring that has been busted. Bearing needs to be removed, magnet attached, and then new bearing installed. 1 Quote
..Kev Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 I have several router including the FT OF1400. The Bosch 1617 is one of my favorites for sure! Dust collection is horrible but, that's the only real downside to the router. Quote
sjeff70 Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 IMG_20141226_140154794.jpg Underneath that bearing is a magnet ring that has been busted. Bearing needs to be removed, magnet attached, and then new bearing installed. Sounds easy. Probably need special tools. Quote
rodger. Posted December 26, 2014 Author Report Posted December 26, 2014 Sound easy. Probably need special tools. Yes, I looked into it. Need a bearing puller, and prob a press. The cost of these tools, plus the parts, are worth more than the router motor new. A machine shops minimum rates are close to the cost of the tools. It makes sense for me just to get a new router. This one may have other issues as well. 1 Quote
wdwerker Posted December 27, 2014 Report Posted December 27, 2014 I have purchased the same router in a "bare bones" refurbished/ rebuilt version to avoid buying new accessories. Quote
ponderingturtle Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 Amazon.com indicates Makita is getting the best reviews for the class of router you're looking for. I think most are buying the Bosch because of the price. I will pay a little more for a better tool... $250.00 appeals to me for the Makita: http://www.amazon.com/Makita-RF1101KIT2-4-Horsepower-Variable-Speed-Plunge/dp/B0002HC4IM/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&qid=1419613327&sr=8-4&keywords=plunge+router+kit It also has 1/10 the number of ratings and reviews as the bosch so it might not be as valid a statistical sample. Quote
sjeff70 Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 It also has 1/10 the number of ratings and reviews as the bosch so it might not be as valid a statistical sample. Very true...that's why I think it's because of price. But I don't know how long both have been offered on Amazon.com. So I just said it might be because of price cause I'm lazy and didn't want to do the research. Quote
Chuck Melton Posted December 29, 2014 Report Posted December 29, 2014 If Mel doesn't get the DeWalt, I'd love the D handle base. Just let me know and I will pay pal the shipping cost. Quote
Jfitz Posted December 29, 2014 Report Posted December 29, 2014 Hi Pug - sorry to hear your router crapped out. After 6 years, it's like losing an old friend. I have the same model (618) - actually two of them - and so far have not had any issues. Did you use it a lot or infrequently? Also, did it see any duty mounted in a router table? I read about the issue and some theorized it was. Ore common in table-mounted routers. Quote
Vyrolan Posted December 29, 2014 Report Posted December 29, 2014 If Mel doesn't get the DeWalt, I'd love the D handle base. Just let me know and I will pay pal the shipping cost. Along similar lines, I'd love an extra fixed base as I too have the DW618. Quote
neoOberon Posted December 30, 2014 Report Posted December 30, 2014 I'm shopping for a similar router (2hp)...I "had" it narrowed down to Dewalt (618B3), Makita (RF1101kit) and the Bosch (1617EVSPK). I've never owned a router before, so I'm starting from scratch. Before I saw the Dewalt, I was leaning towards the Makita. However then I saw the Dewalt and its three bases...It peaked my interest despite the bad reviews. However I think I'm going with the Makita...doubt the D-handle would get much use anyway. That is, unless someone here can enlighten me as to the benefits of D-handles. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.