zberger7646 Posted December 27, 2014 Report Posted December 27, 2014 I recently viewed Marc Spagnuolo's "Low-angle Jack Plane: The Only Handplane You Need?" and found the content extremely interesting. As a novice in woodworking, still accumulating the tools i want and/or need, i had a particular question. The Lie-Nielson low angle jack that Marc reviews is modeled after it's Stanley predecessor. With that being said, would the purchase of the Stanley model 62 be out of the question, or is the Lie-Nielson, or Veritas for that matter, the better buy. Now, i am worried about expense, but i do believe that quality can outweigh price. Any thoughts? Quote
Llama Posted December 27, 2014 Report Posted December 27, 2014 I have and love the lie-nielsen low angle Jack. I also have the other low angle bench planes they sell. Can't go wrong with lie-nielsen. 1 Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted December 27, 2014 Report Posted December 27, 2014 I'm not sure I can intelligently answer your question because I doing know much about the Stanley. It was my understanding that the Stanley is rare in the wild and priced accordingly but that might not be accurate. I do have the LN and it is an excellent tool - very well made and versatile. Quote
zberger7646 Posted December 28, 2014 Author Report Posted December 28, 2014 The Stanley 62 can be purchased through Rockler for $159.99. That price is what brought my question to mind. When compared to the Lie-Nielson counterpart, it is certainly less expensive, but will it be a smart buy? Quote
Tpt life Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 One thought. Check LN and LV sales pricing on eBay and do the same for Stanley. I find that used LN go for almost full retail value. This make me a touch less nervous about making an investment. If I find it does not truly fill a need, I am not panicked about unloading it. Just a thought, not an attempt to capture the whole conversation. Quote
Tom King Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 The thing I find strange about the popularity of this plane is that the plane it's modeled after was never popular back in the day when hand planes were used all the time by people who did finish work. If it had been popular back then, there would be many more of them on the market. I've had exactly one of the old ones in my hands, and can't even begin to count all the 3's, 4's, and 5's I've handled. I started using planes before LN ever made their first model. Most of the ones (talking bench planes here) I started out using were the same ones all the carpenters before me used. Those are still the ones I use. Over the years, I've increased my collection of the specialized ones. I still have no need for a low angled Jack. If I was just making furniture, I wouldn't need as many planes as I have, but I do have each one tuned for a specific purpose. It's nice to be able to grab the one I want without having to spend time retuning it for a different job. I feel pretty sure that without the beginner market, that these boutique tool makers would not be in business. I'm sure being able to take one out of a box, and immediately start making shavings has a lot to do with it. There's not much skill in making shavings with a plane that has a sharp iron. Getting an iron sharp is a skill that seems so simple, but is obviously fairly hard to gain. If you can get an edge way beyond ordinary razor sharp, almost anything will take nice shavings. I know it sounds like I'm knocking this plane, but I'm not. I've never used one, but I have hand planed I don't know how many hundreds of square feet of wood....just trying to add a different perspective. The thing that seems so odd to me, and other experienced people I know, is that people are willing to spend big bucks for a fancy new tool, but so little time and money invested in sharpening. The first thing I teach anyone who wants to do some woodworking is how to sharpen an edge, and what that sharp edge will do. Probably well more than half obviously think they are wasting their time, but do marvel at the pretty shavings they can make with my tools. The thing is, if you do end up working wood, those edges won't stay sharp. 1 Quote
Trip Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 There’s a lot feeding the BU-Jack phenomena… Maybe more than can be covered in a single thread… You’ve got metallurgy, novice woodworkers, paid sponsorships, etc all combined to push a plane that, for many, is of questionable utility… I’ve got a BU-Jack and month after month it goes unused – I don’t think I’ve touched it in a year… If you’re a novice, then the LA-Jack is a good first bench plane (probably the best) – easy to adjust, easy to use, versatile, etc… With a few irons, you can cover a lot of ground… Further, it’s hard to self-teach the finer points of BD plane adjustment/use (no matter how much YouTube content you digest). A poorly adjusted BD plane is a nightmare to use… The BU-J solves so many of these issues for the novice at just one go... That's huge -- Again, BUs are easy to learn to adjust, easy to learn how to use and highly-flexible… What more could a novice want? However, once you develop hand-tool skills and start to acquire BD kit, the utility of the BU-Jack starts to drop-off… With experience, the things that make the BU-Jack a great first plane start to get in the way – can’t adjust on the fly, harder to properly chamber for efficient stock removal, etc… Why don’t you see a lot of vintage 62s? They didn’t work very well (no Hock irons) and they broke (metallurgy used at the time)… To answer the OP – if you’re looking at a BU-Jack, then I’d get the LN or LV… To TK's point, 90% of hand-tool 'issues' can be solved with a sharp edge... As a side note: I also have the LN BU-Smoother... I use that plane rather often -- it can be adjusted on the fly... If LN ever added a bailey-style adjuster, then the BU-J would get a lot more use in my shop... Quote
rodger. Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 I've got the Veritas BUJ and love it. I also have the bevel up jointer, which is equally as awesome. Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 In my limited experience this checks out. I love my LN 62 but the more I get comfortable with my #4 and #7.There’s a lot feeding the BU-Jack phenomena… Maybe more than can be covered in a single thread… You’ve got metallurgy, novice woodworkers, paid sponsorships, etc all combined to push a plane that, for many, is of questionable utility… I’ve got a BU-Jack and month after month it goes unused – I don’t think I’ve touched it in a year… If you’re a novice, then the LA-Jack is a good first bench plane (probably the best) – easy to adjust, easy to use, versatile, etc… With a few irons, you can cover a lot of ground… Further, it’s hard to self-teach the finer points of BD plane adjustment/use (no matter how much YouTube content you digest). A poorly adjusted BD plane is a nightmare to use… The BU-J solves so many of these issues for the novice at just one go... That's huge -- Again, BUs are easy to learn to adjust, easy to learn how to use and highly-flexible… What more could a novice want? However, once you develop hand-tool skills and start to acquire BD kit, the utility of the BU-Jack starts to drop-off… With experience, the things that make the BU-Jack a great first plane start to get in the way – can’t adjust on the fly, harder to properly chamber for efficient stock removal, etc… Why don’t you see a lot of vintage 62s? They didn’t work very well (no Hock irons) and they broke (metallurgy used at the time)… To answer the OP – if you’re looking at a BU-Jack, then I’d get the LN or LV… To TK's point, 90% of hand-tool 'issues' can be solved with a sharp edge... Quote
rasher Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 My first premium plane years ago was a Lie Nielsen BU-Jack... I use it a ton. Note that this is a hobby for me, not a profession. I also have a Lee Valley BU-Jointer. I wish my jack was a Lee Valley now. Reason being is that you can get a BU jack, jointer & smoother that all use the same size irons so each iron you acquire becomes even more useful. Also Lee Valley offers A2, 01 & PM-V11 blades whereas Lie Nielsen only offers A2. With a bevel down plane, you'll want to invest in higher angle frogs if you want to work with trickier woods. Whereas an, easy to sharpen, O1 blade can be micro-beveled very quickly... To a higher angle and then back down to a lower one. The only penalty is less edge-retention. Once you find the angles most useful to you, you can invest in dedicated irons (in an A2 or PM-V11) to keep at your favorite angles. Lastly, don't overlook the toothed blade. It's like a scrub plane in that it can hog off a large amount of material with far less effort and time. I still have yet to feel the need to sharpen/hone it too, it just keeps on going. Just my 2-cents. My only experience with bevel down planes are my #3, 4 & 5 Stanley planes that I restored. My #4 has a hock iron and to me, made a huge improvement. But I will be getting a LV BU smoother eventually. My #3 and 5 don't get much use anymore. They were my first and got me hooked... plus they really helped me learn the value of sharpening as others have mentioned here. Quote
TerryMcK Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 I believe the LN/LV/Woodriver(Quangsheng) bevel up planes will give the same results. If it were me I would go for the LV jack as I like the adjustment mechanism and mouth adjustment. The LN has a similar mouth adjustment mechanism. I've tried the new #62 Sweethearts and find the lateral adjustment mechanism lacking. The new castings are ok but I would have expected more considering the premium price (albeit not in the LN//LV price bracket). The Woodriver/Quangsheng feels better than the Stanley and is a similar price bracket to the Sweetheart. I would also get a block plane too if you go down the "Jack does everything route" (it doesn't BTW but is adequate at most tasks). Get a series of different angle bevel blades and you can certainly do more. Quote
rasher Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 I second Terry's statement about a block plane. I just ordered one the other day with my xMas loot. I did get away with using a #3 and a spokeshave for jobs a block plane would be better at... round-overs and knocking of splintered edges, etc. But I keep wishing I had a block plane. Quote
zberger7646 Posted December 30, 2014 Author Report Posted December 30, 2014 The information given here was very enlightening. Unfortunately, with one question answered, another takes it's place. Between the A2, O1 and PM-V11, what are the advantages of each? Is the better plane made with PM-V11, or does that primarily go for the blades themselves? My first premium plane years ago was a Lie Nielsen BU-Jack... I use it a ton. Note that this is a hobby for me, not a profession. I also have a Lee Valley BU-Jointer. I wish my jack was a Lee Valley now. Reason being is that you can get a BU jack, jointer & smoother that all use the same size irons so each iron you acquire becomes even more useful. Also Lee Valley offers A2, 01 & PM-V11 blades whereas Lie Nielsen only offers A2. With a bevel down plane, you'll want to invest in higher angle frogs if you want to work with trickier woods. Whereas an, easy to sharpen, O1 blade can be micro-beveled very quickly... To a higher angle and then back down to a lower one. The only penalty is less edge-retention. Once you find the angles most useful to you, you can invest in dedicated irons (in an A2 or PM-V11) to keep at your favorite angles. Lastly, don't overlook the toothed blade. It's like a scrub plane in that it can hog off a large amount of material with far less effort and time. I still have yet to feel the need to sharpen/hone it too, it just keeps on going. Just my 2-cents. My only experience with bevel down planes are my #3, 4 & 5 Stanley planes that I restored. My #4 has a hock iron and to me, made a huge improvement. But I will be getting a LV BU smoother eventually. My #3 and 5 don't get much use anymore. They were my first and got me hooked... plus they really helped me learn the value of sharpening as others have mentioned here. Quote
Gilgaron Posted January 2, 2015 Report Posted January 2, 2015 I sharpen my plane irons by hand so I like the O1 better than A2, as it is slightly less effort. I've not tried PMV11. The differences are pretty academic, though, between the three. Your skill with the tool, and that it is sharp, will make a bigger difference than the type of steel in the blade. You aren't comparing mild steel, cast iron, and tool steel, but three varieties of tool steel. They're all good for the application. Quote
cellardoor Posted January 2, 2015 Report Posted January 2, 2015 As TripleH mentions, the design was prone to cracking and many of the originals didn't survive into antique-hood. Where the sides dip down in the middle it turned out to be just too weak for the metallurgy of the time. I bought into the hype about this being the first plane because it was a good multi-tasked and that argument just CANNOT be understated to someone at the very beginning of the craft. To a seasoned woodworker 15 years of accumulated tools and widgets and doodads are easily taken for granted. For a newbie each little tidbit has a cost and a burden of mastery associated with it. When I got mine at a LN handtool event I went from messing with grandpa's neglected planes to hogging & smoothing like a champ. Had I not made that purchase - and probably that specific plane - I can't say I'd still be woodworking. You can only fail at a hobby so many times before you move on! Fast forward to today and I still find it versatile enough that I don't see the need to add a bevel down jack. In fact, when you think about the "jack of all trades" nature of the jack plane it's almost better suited to that role than the standard #5. With the adjustable mouth and easily swappable irons I'd much rather do some on-the-fly scrub work, extemporaneous smoothing, and fly-by-the-seat-of-your-pants jointing with this than something with a moveable frog and a cap iron. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.