Immortan D Posted July 21, 2015 Author Report Posted July 21, 2015 Based on the suggestions, here's my new list: Medium Shoulder Plane No. 3 Bench Plane Low Angle Jack Plane Set -- Honestly, I want the set beyond all reason Large Router Plane I'm going to order mortising chisels at a later time. Size will be determined according to the specific needs of each project. Quote
Trip Posted July 21, 2015 Report Posted July 21, 2015 I've got everything on that list --- use it all... Although, the Large shoulder plane is more useful for 'full sized' pieces... Since your buidling smaller items, then the Medium maybe a better fit... The #3 is a great smoother on smaller items... 45d or 50d frog? 1 Quote
Immortan D Posted July 21, 2015 Author Report Posted July 21, 2015 I've got everything on that list --- use it all... Although, the Large shoulder plane is more useful for 'full sized' pieces... Since your buidling smaller items, then the Medium maybe a better fit... The #3 is a great smoother on smaller items... 45d or 50d frog? Yep, Medium shoulder plane is on my list. 45d standard angle but open for suggestions. Quote
Tpt life Posted July 21, 2015 Report Posted July 21, 2015 I've got everything on that list --- use it all... Although, the Large shoulder plane is more useful for 'full sized' pieces... Since your buidling smaller items, then the Medium maybe a better fit... The #3 is a great smoother on smaller items... 45d or 50d frog? Can you elaborate? The medium feels quite large in my large hands. What makes the bigger better for large projects? Longer reference sole? Quote
Trip Posted July 21, 2015 Report Posted July 21, 2015 Once you get to pieces larger than occasional tables, the joinery gets larger rather quickly... Larger joinery benefits from taking bigger pass/cut. A bigger cut benefits from a larger reference surface, wider iron and the increased mass of a larger body... Quote
Trip Posted July 21, 2015 Report Posted July 21, 2015 ==>45d standard angle but open for suggestions. I've got one #3 at 45 and one #3 at 50 (at some point, I just got tired of swapping frogs, so started getting duplicates)... With straight-grained stock, I use 45d. With figured stock, I use the 50d. Since you really want the LAJ, I’d get the 45d unless you mostly work with figured stock... 1 Quote
G S Haydon Posted July 21, 2015 Report Posted July 21, 2015 I saw this earlier today and wanted to chime in. Now I'm home I see you have been advised wisely! Quote
Immortan D Posted July 21, 2015 Author Report Posted July 21, 2015 I saw this earlier today and wanted to chime in. Now I'm home I see you have been advised wisely! Indeed I was! Thanks Graham. Quote
Immortan D Posted July 22, 2015 Author Report Posted July 22, 2015 I would also advise that you go with the LV Skew Rabbet plane (way more useful for making rabbets) According to a picture in the product page, raised panels is one of the intended applications of this tool. Did anyone actually use this one for creating raised panels? Quote
Trip Posted July 22, 2015 Report Posted July 22, 2015 Don't care what LN says, not the right tool for the job... For larger panels, you need more mass. For small panels, you need more control -- most of the competition adds a depth stop. T-LN has been talking about a depth stop for years, but it's a low priority... Avoid for this application until they add the depth stop. Same for rebates... There are just too many better tools out there... Quote
Immortan D Posted July 22, 2015 Author Report Posted July 22, 2015 It's a LV plane the one I linked. I was thinking about doing my raised panels the way Paul Sellers did in his clock making Youtube videos. But of course, Sellers can cut a perfect miter using a handsaw and without even drawing a line... Quote
aengland Posted July 22, 2015 Report Posted July 22, 2015 I'm getting ready to order some items from LN. Intended use of the new tools: Mortises & Tenons, Rabbets, Dados, Smoothing, Jointing. Current related tools I have: Stanley #4, Stanley #5C, Stanley LA Block Plane, Several card scrappers, Flat and Curved spokeshaves. I don't have any mortising chisels. I'm basing my selection on what I think I need and what I read in the previous threads. The List: Rabbet Block Plane w/Nicker (will it completely replace a shoulder plane?) Low Angle Jack Plane Set (not quite sure if I need the set or just the plane -- the reason for the set is the extra blades) Large Router Plane Mortise Chisel (1/2) Mortise Chisel (1/4) Hot Dog for the Low Angle Jack Plane (for a shooting board) LN.PNG What's to criticize ! I agree on using smaller mortice chisels (always 1/3 of the with of your wood; so, if your working 1 1/2" wood, do keep the 1/2). I have the LV router and a Stanley 71 (blades are interchangeable) and love them both. LN should be excellent, too. I shoot with what ever's handy (and sharp!) but I do have a LN LAJ: it's not as NECESSARY as I had thought but still I'm very glad to have it. My old #5 and #6 shoots just as well. You NEED both the shoulder and a skew rabbet plane. I like both LN and LV (have one of each) but prefer the LN skew rabbet. I just get better results. I bought a vintage Stanley scrub plane for a fair to good price. It works flawlessly and is always used when shaping rough lumber (but rarely used otherwise). And, though you could go for a cheaper chisel, buy right by buying once! There's a reason why the better chisels cost significantly more; IMO you are getting what you pay for! Some of these options (and opinions) are merely preference: but you asked... Have fun! Quote
Trip Posted July 22, 2015 Report Posted July 22, 2015 ==>Some of these options (and opinions) are merely preference: but you asked... Get that, but let's qualify some of the recomendations... ==>do keep the 1/2 I've had a ½” mortice chisel for about a decade and can count on one hand the number of times it's been used... Two dining tables and one bed... It’s a tool for large projects -- and the OP says he works on small ones... ==>You NEED both the shoulder and a skew rabbet plane Agree the shoulder... but the skew rebate is another specialty tool... And the LN, while well made, is not that useful until the promised depth stop is added... Quote
Immortan D Posted July 22, 2015 Author Report Posted July 22, 2015 Thanks Archie, but I've already made my order and waiting for shipping.... which may take up to 3 weeks according the LN's site. Quote
jmaichel Posted July 22, 2015 Report Posted July 22, 2015 Thanks Archie, but I've already made my order and waiting for shipping.... which may take up to 3 weeks according the LN's site. I would take a look at the Craftsman Studio. I used to buy from his store when I lived in San Diego and still order from him time to time. He also offers free shipping. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.