Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted January 19, 2016 Popular Post Report Posted January 19, 2016 This article has an interesting take on the quality differences between US and Chinese made tools. I have a different take, which I learned from my father. He is a retired machine designer, and he was often responsible for finding manufacturers for his designs. He didn't find a difference between manufacturers: US, Japanese, Chinese, or elsewhere. They all gave him what he asked for, within the tolerances and reject rates he specified. If he specified cheap junk, any factory could give him cheap junk. If he specified high quality metals, tight tolerances, dependable manufacturing methods, and dozens of specific checks on each unit, then he could get high quality machines from factories in every country. Often, the top of the line high quality product was manufactured in the same factory as the cheap version. The difference was in the specifications, not the design or the factory. If a company says, "Let's save a few bucks by using pot metal for this part, and a few more bucks by only inspecting one unit out of 1000", then quality will suffer regardless of where the factory is located. 8 Quote
Popular Post Llama Posted January 19, 2016 Popular Post Report Posted January 19, 2016 That is simple economics. In many cases, you do get what you pay for. The tool or widget with a higher quality control will usually cost more. There are exceptions to every rule. I feel better buying things that are made in the US or Canada than I do when buying from China. Many times when a manufacturer seeks an LCR (Low Cost Region), they are looking to (as the label suggests) cut costs. This is usually done with cheaper materials or processes. There is usually very little money left on the table when the quality is the same. Not to mention the fact that there is a feel-good factor associated with buying American. This is complicated with the increased restrictions of the materials companies in America are allowed to sell it's customers. When is the last time you saw a KB Toys? For those that do not know, they were shut down for selling toys that had lead paint. Thomas the train toys to be more exact. They did not have any role in the manufacturer of the toys, only acted as a retailer for a larger company. The larger company could afford to settle the lawsuits, KB did not. The purchasing agreement stated no lead, and the switch was made without knowledge of anyone on our side of the pond. Doesn't matter. The same thing happened to Dell, and countless others. I guess the point I am trying to make is there is much more to consider other than the quality of the product. As companies are understanding this, more items are coming back to the US. Which is a win. 5 Quote
shaneymack Posted January 19, 2016 Report Posted January 19, 2016 This is gonna get political, lets get a mod on here.... Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted January 19, 2016 Author Report Posted January 19, 2016 13 minutes ago, shaneymack said: This is gonna get political, lets get a mod on here.... Yeah, who started this thread! I'm watching! 1 Quote
shaneymack Posted January 19, 2016 Report Posted January 19, 2016 This is gonna get political, lets get a mod on here.... Yeah, who started this thread! I'm watching! That was my point, i was messin with you Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk 1 Quote
Al Capwn Posted January 19, 2016 Report Posted January 19, 2016 20 minutes ago, Mike. said: I had a long reply typed out but decided to sit back and watch the show instead. But to kick off the fun I will make the obvious comment that any country is capable of making crap. Just look at the US auto industry from the 1970s through the 1990s. Precisely what was mentioned in the article, too. There is high quality and low quality stuff in every country. I've heard that the low quality stuff is not even really sold in China - it is mostly export. Spyderco has mostly excellent product lines from Taiwan. Woodriver planes - those are generally regarded as fairly good quality, yes? Whenever you cut corners, regardless of origin, is when you are going to suffer. Oh, and as a son of a US steelworker, I would say buy USA-made. Though, like Mike said, I wouldn't buy a US car during that period, either. Quote
Popular Post JosephThomas Posted January 19, 2016 Popular Post Report Posted January 19, 2016 1 hour ago, Mike. said: I had a long reply typed out but decided to sit back and watch the show instead. But to kick off the fun I will make the obvious comment that any country is capable of making crap. Just look at the US auto industry from the 1970s through the 1990s. You misspelled "1970s through the 2010s" 3 Quote
Pwalter5110 Posted January 20, 2016 Report Posted January 20, 2016 3 hours ago, Mike. said: I had a long reply typed out but decided to sit back and watch the show instead. But to kick off the fun I will make the obvious comment that any country is capable of making crap. Just look at the US auto industry from the 1970s through the 1990s. I am the highest certified a Toyota technician can be (trying to make myself feel intelligent) but there is no doubt that Toyota was hands down the most reliable automobile manufacturer.... That is until it became American made. I don't think quality has to do with where it was built, I think it has to do with who designed it. Quote
Jim DaddyO Posted January 20, 2016 Report Posted January 20, 2016 I worked in factories and shops most of my life and the way any of them I know of work (world wide) is that you give the customer what they want, no more, no less. Build to the specs and make sure of that. If you are the customer, and your name is going on the product, you make sure to do what must be done to ensure that your specs are being met, including independent verification. That's not politics, that's business. Quote
h3nry Posted January 20, 2016 Report Posted January 20, 2016 No one can argue that apple’s products aren’t beautiful. That they aren’t wonderfully made. Whether or not the OS is good or whether it’s “the best.” — maybe. Now if you look at a competitor’s product, say a cheap HiQ from Shenzhen. No mention that Apple products are made in Shenzhen too. Quote
prov163 Posted January 20, 2016 Report Posted January 20, 2016 h3nry, I'm a Mac guy and I have to tell you that my experience with Apple products and service tells me that exacting standards are certainly, as Beech pointed out, a key to quality no matter where something is made. I also agree that design has a lot to do with quality. But, IMHO, the most important factor in a quality product or service is pride in workmanship. If people love what they make/do, if the pleasure of the end user is their main guide, they'll find a way to make it/do it well. We used to call that good old American ingenuity. Hard work and pride are the materials of success, that's why I'm voting for Mike Rowe for President. Or maybe Eric 1 Quote
h3nry Posted January 20, 2016 Report Posted January 20, 2016 Exactly. I was just pointing out that the article compared a quality product with a less impressive product emphasizing that the inferior product was made in Shenzhen, as if that was the main factor - without mentioning that the quality product is made next door. Apple just happens to require (and pays for) better standards and QC, which is what makes the difference - not the Chinese workforce. 21 minutes ago, prov163 said: But, IMHO, the most important factor in a quality product or service is pride in workmanship. There's no doubt about that. That's why there isn't a stick of furniture posted on this site of poor quality (Even Eric's rustic tables). 2 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted January 20, 2016 Author Report Posted January 20, 2016 The article also suggests that a US company that outsources manufacturing to China may end up with an inferior product, because "one hand doesn't know what the other is doing". If the designers and manufacturers aren't communicating well, that can decrease reliability. Of course, that can also happen with US designers and US manufacturers. But it explains why a US company with a great reputation for reliability can go downhill when it moves its manufacturing to China. My father used to take his designs down to the shop floor to ask how they would be made. A simple thing like how the dimensions are drawn or putting a different radius on a corner can make a big difference to the machinist making the thing. And, the harder a part is to make correctly, the more likely it will be made incorrectly. But, it's harder to visit the shop floor when the Pacific Ocean is in the way. 1 Quote
Popular Post JosephThomas Posted January 20, 2016 Popular Post Report Posted January 20, 2016 1 hour ago, h3nry said: Eric's rustic tables I just wanted to post this again to increase the number of search hits when someone searches for "rustic tables" linking back to Eric. 6 Quote
ponderingturtle Posted January 20, 2016 Report Posted January 20, 2016 13 hours ago, Jim DaddyO said: I worked in factories and shops most of my life and the way any of them I know of work (world wide) is that you give the customer what they want, no more, no less. Build to the specs and make sure of that. If you are the customer, and your name is going on the product, you make sure to do what must be done to ensure that your specs are being met, including independent verification. That's not politics, that's business. Or at least give them what they will accept. At the company I work for we have gotten companies rejecting our parts because they stopped having a QC department and when our parts stopped going in right they said it was our problem. Then of course we checked the mating component and found out it was way out of spec. This was not a small company or one who is a low cost option. They went with the low bid on the contract and got crap. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.