Recommended Posts

Posted

I've noticed one diff between a cabinet saw and the contractor saw.  Those contractor saw legs do encourage both vibration and torque. So I was wondering ... anyone ever build an alternative base for the contractor saw, one that adds rigidity and reduces vibration?

It's not that the torquing is an issue.  One cannot help but notice it from time to time. It's the encouragement of vibration that bothers me the most.  (Again, my goal is to spend as little as possible and get the most possible out of a contractor saw.)  It's like a turntable -- a little resonance in the base transfers to the arm. You won't probably hear it but you can gear its impact.

(Of course I could take some twine and tie it to a tree stump but in this case I have something more permanent in mind.)

My inspiration? Looking at the benefits of a cabinet saw last night.  And the cost.

Posted

I feel the vibration is caused by two glaring features of a contractors type saw. 

1) table mounted gear.  Having the trunions, motor supports mounted directly to the table obviously gives a more direct flow of vibration to where you feel it. 

2) low mass.  The low weight has less to absorb so you feel more. 

I'm not convinced that a new base fixes either, unless it's made of brick. 

Posted

Is it concrete dancing? Try a rubber mat under the feet. FWIW, it was common when I was in high school for the back alley guys to set cheap contractor saws in cabinets that functioned as table extensions. Kind of like today's router cabinets. 

Posted
7 minutes ago, collinb said:

"low wrought"?  Mine does have all cast/open wings. It's a heavy beast.

Low weight obviously is a sliding scale.  Yes it's heavy but it's not as heavy. 

The component sizes and weights between a contractor and cabinet size actually surprised me.   Speaking from my experience,  the guts of the unisaw make the delta 36 look like Play things.

A 1 or 1.5 horse motor has some weight to it but a 3 is a beast. I'm not comparing  a contractor saw to a toaster.  I'm saying it is light  compared to a cabinet saw. 

Another thought is maybe you need to try to tune out some vibration.  Proper and matched belts, proper pulley alignment and pullies without runout should help. 

Posted

Mine is a 3hp motor.  I've replaced the pulleys and aligned.  Have a link belt. Some have said that a good v belt gives less vibration even though it may require more frequent replacement. It's a cheap test.

 

Posted

Have you tried loosening your saw leg bolts and re-tighten them. What this will do for you, the slop in the bolt holes will give the stand stand some wiggle room to conform to the irregularities of the shop floor. I did this for my band saw and table saw. Worked like a charm. Or go buy some bags of play sand and drape over the leg supports. 

-Ace-

Posted

Not just weight but placement of weight has a big impact as well. The base of cabinet saws places more weight lower that helps prevent vibration. Getting weight lower on the saw will help stop some of the vibrations.

Posted

When I used a contractor saw did have a lower shelf that helped stiffen the legs.  The real gain came (after the machined pulleys and link belt) after wrapping a 100# sack of redi-crete in plastic and tossing it on the shelf. Ace's suggestion of loosening the leg bolts to let the saw settle and then re-tightening would help.  Old hockey pucks make decent isolation feet..

Since your motor is obviously an add-on (being 3HP) let's look at speeds and the pulleys a bit.  Are they machine steel or just replaced?  Is the motor a 3450 RPM unit?  If so, are the pulleys the same or very near the same size?

Obviously it is easy to remove the belt and turn on the motor to check for vibration.  Symptoms will be minimized without other machinery connected so a stick held to the motor housing will give you a good transfer sensation of what is going on.  If the motor is not glass smooth you may as well start there because everything you add to the 'drive train' will only amplify that vibration.

Assuming the motor is good, slip the belt back on, remove the blade, arbor washer and nut, re-test.  All good? add the washer and nut, er-test.  If you have not had to stop to address a culprit yet, add the blade.  I' imagine you have already been through some of this but, when diagnosing, a painfully slow and diligent methodology will take less time than going back over and over again.

Posted
26 minutes ago, gee-dub said:

When I used a contractor saw did have a lower shelf that helped stiffen the legs.  The real gain came (after the machined pulleys and link belt) after wrapping a 100# sack of redi-crete in plastic and tossing it on the shelf. Ace's suggestion of loosening the leg bolts to let the saw settle and then re-tightening would help.  Old hockey pucks make decent isolation feet..

Since your motor is obviously an add-on (being 3HP) let's look at speeds and the pulleys a bit.  Are they machine steel or just replaced?  Is the motor a 3450 RPM unit?  If so, are the pulleys the same or very near the same size?

Obviously it is easy to remove the belt and turn on the motor to check for vibration.  Symptoms will be minimized without other machinery connected so a stick held to the motor housing will give you a good transfer sensation of what is going on.  If the motor is not glass smooth you may as well start there because everything you add to the 'drive train' will only amplify that vibration.

Assuming the motor is good, slip the belt back on, remove the blade, arbor washer and nut, re-test.  All good? add the washer and nut, er-test.  If you have not had to stop to address a culprit yet, add the blade.  I' imagine you have already been through some of this but, when diagnosing, a painfully slow and diligent methodology will take less time than going back over and over again.

That's a good check list.  The systematic approach is always preferable to the reactionary (putting out fires) approach.

The 3hp motor is original.  Model 113.298761 like this one, but with one more wing to the right. http://hinesauctionservice.com/index.php?slb=1&itmpg=1&itm_id=76072 and a different fence.

I'm also thinking that a rubber sheet in the motor mount couldn't hurt -- even if all else gets tuned up, isolation always helps.

My first *fix* will be the blade and then work back from there.  Why? Because it has a little shimmy that is not the bearings or arbor (they're new & checked).  It's a cheapie Diablo and they're not the heftiest of blades.  (What I've observed is that, even though a modestly-priced blade can have good, sharpenable carbide on it, the blade base material is just as important. That adds life to the blade by keeping it flat longer for better cuts. At least that's my observation. If I'm wrong, someone let me know.)

I'm also considering something akin to this approach in addition to the tuning suggestions  (but have made no final decision yet) : http://lumberjocks.com/projects/49484

***

These things came to mind after I visited a guy last evening with a very nice basement shop.  Laguna band saw. PCS. Jet 6" jointer. Lots of other quality tools for making nice stuff. He made a beautiful guitar that also sounded pretty good.  (Not as rich as a Martin, but not as brilliant as a Gibson and w/o the Yamaha resonations.)  And some cabinetry.  Probably the only thing he can't make himself is more space in the basement. (They ain't making land any more.)

Anyway, the PCS is pretty impressive.  His only complaint is dust removal on the back. He has a rack for wood under his outfeed and that makes it a little crowded for the dust port connections. (I think he wishes it were a side port instead.)  Still, a relatively small concern.  He upgraded from a Craftsman 113 series saw with stamped wings.  Clearly no comparison.

Even after mine is fully and precisely tuned I know that it will still not be as good as a cabinet saw.  Still, I think it can be made awfully good for little expense -- good enough that I won't *need* to concern myself with upgrading.

Posted

there are lots of plans that have appeared over the years in various magazines to build a base cabinet for your contractor saw. They usually add storage, and are mounted on a nice set of wheels to make the saw easier to move around.

If you want a quick/easy fix, take two pieces of 3/4" plywood that are slightly bigger than the footprint of your four legs and sandwich them together to make a 1.5" thick piece, then remove the levelers from the legs and use those holes to bolt the four legs to that piece of plywood. If you need height adjustability, then you can reuse the original levelers and attach them to the plywood.

This will tie the four legs together at the top (where they attach to the saw) as well as the bottom and will make the base much more rigid. From there you can add weight by putting a few bags of sand on the plywood if you need to

Posted

I was thinking along the same lines, except removing the original legs and building a solid cabinet beneath.  Like you said, plenty of examples online.

Posted

My old Powermatic model 62 does not vibrate.  It probably weighs twice what today's contractors saws weigh.  It has not only a solid top, but solid wings too, and the legs and shelf are unusually thick for sheet metal. All the trunion structure is really thick cast iron.  It and the Craftsman 12" RAS were the only big tools I've ever bought new, and I still use both.

http://vintagemachinery.org/pubs/detail.aspx?id=4326

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 64 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined