Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

so many choices, as a beginner what to buy so you don't waste money

Featured Replies

12 hours ago, jmaichel said:

That is not exactly what I said. I know that Festool is not only for sheet goods and believe me I did use them on a number of projects and took advantage of different setups using QWAS dogs and removing the rail on my MFT. I am not blaming Festool! I am blaming myself for not taking the time to think about my future projects and how I wanted approach these projects. You have to admit that there was/is a lot of Festool hype and for some it does not meet expectations. I am only saying some of the Core tools would have been a better first choice. 

 

 

Fair enough, I agree.

What I took away from your post is that you were caught up in the Festool hype, but it didn't meet its expectations because of some deficiency in the system.

But in reality you just bought the wrong type of tools (power vs. hand), and not the wrong brand of tools.  You would have been disappointed in Bosch if you would have invested in that brand instead, because it had to do more with method than brand.  It just came off as blaming Festool specifically for falling short in some way...at least that's how I read it.

And I absolutely think there's a TON of Festool hype that is totally overblown and undeserved.  Aside from the Domino and MFT, there are comparables to every other tool they offer.  The Festool fanboy culture makes me nauseous and I think a decent majority of their tools are just a waste of money and shouldn't be bought unless you're a millionaire.  I do believe they are usually of higher quality than the other comparable brands and usually offer greater accuracy and versatility when used as a system as they were intended.  But often they are underpowered and always too expensive.

So I do agree with you on that front, but for your previous argument's purposes, you should have said only that you regret buying power tools rather than hand tools, when instead you unfairly dragged Festool into the mix without logical implication.

Anyway, it matters not.  Carry on.

  • Replies 89
  • Views 19.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Tom Cancelleri
    Tom Cancelleri

    I see the must haves as a jointer, planer, table saw, bandsaw, dust collector. A miter saw is nice but not a must have. I would suggest a jig saw for breaking down rough stock. With a 6k budget, and

  • To answer your question, yet not answer your question at all, I'll say to buy what you need as you need it.  $6,000 sounds like a big budget until you realize a sawstop and a PM planer will wipe

  • And a good router table with a lift. Otherwise I agree with Tom's list and his comment about the SawStop.  I think it's foolish for a new woodworker on a budget to blow that kind of money on a Sa

Posted Images

2 hours ago, Eric. said:

Fair enough, I agree.

What I took away from your post is that you were caught up in the Festool hype, but it didn't meet its expectations because of some deficiency in the system.

But in reality you just bought the wrong type of tools (power vs. hand), and not the wrong brand of tools.  You would have been disappointed in Bosch if you would have invested in that brand instead, because it had to do more with method than brand.  It just came off as blaming Festool specifically for falling short in some way...at least that's how I read it.

And I absolutely think there's a TON of Festool hype that is totally overblown and undeserved.  Aside from the Domino and MFT, there are comparables to every other tool they offer.  The Festool fanboy culture makes me nauseous and I think a decent majority of their tools are just a waste of money and shouldn't be bought unless you're a millionaire.  I do believe they are usually of higher quality than the other comparable brands and usually offer greater accuracy and versatility when used as a system as they were intended.  But often they are underpowered and always too expensive.

So I do agree with you on that front, but for your previous argument's purposes, you should have said only that you regret buying power tools rather than hand tools, when instead you unfairly dragged Festool into the mix without logical implication.

Anyway, it matters not.  Carry on.

Correct! To be honest I would have been happy going with a few better quality core power tools right off the bat. My switch to hand tools was mostly driven by my move to HI and not wanting to drag them with me. Although, I am really enjoying using hand tools. When I make my final move and get settled I will be adding a TS, Jointer, and bandsaw. Somethings I just do not enjoy doing by hand. 

  • Author

It does seem like every power tool debate ends up at Festool at some point.   I can bring this back again to my RC hobby, Festool is very much like SAB Goblin people give them a lot of crap, me at times too, because they are very expensive compared to the market.  Truth be told they make a very good helicopter.   You will always have the debate if they are worth the premium price.  To some people it will be to others it wont.  Haters will hate, fan boys will fan, and the middle will like some of their stuff and could care less about other.  I do want their overalls though.  

The only Festool items that truly interest me are the Domino and the Rotax with the Domino being the one I'm likely to buy at some point. With the project I'm planning and the type of stuff and see myself doing it would be useful.   The Rotax would be a nice to have but I'm not sure on the cost /value equation on that one.   

Their other stuff is great but I see it more for the professional to do high quality carpentry work and needs the portability and top notch dust collection.  I want good dust collection but I don't need super portable road tools that can travel with a road warrior but maintain workshop level accuracy.   Just not what I'm doing.  

I was just more or less sharing my experience when setting up my shop(s) and how I focused more on the tools than what I wanted to build. Eric was right when he said that it had nothing to do with Festool itself but more with how I wanted to build furniture after it was all said and done. 

I failed to mention one Festool tool that actually saw a lot of use and that was my ETS 150/3. 

Last lesson, compromise is not always a good thing when setting up shop. This is a hobby, like your RC hobby if you think you are going to be happier with one tool over another than don't settle. The one exception is if your budget is really really limited and you won't be able squeeze any more money out anytime soon, compromises might have to be made. But than again to quote Eric, "you might want to find another hobby."

  • 2 months later...
  • Author

We closed on the house and got moved in on Halloween.  I had my sub-panel for the tools installed and since I was so close to Black Friday I decided to wait and see what deals were to be found.   Here is what I ended up buying or ordering this weekend:

Prices include any taxes or freight/lift gate charges.   

Rigid R4331 Planer     $100  steal of a deal, New in box, neighbor bought it, never used it, sold it to me when they were moving.

Sawstop PCS 3hp 52" with mobile base     $3,412
Grizzly G0513X2 w/ Cast Iron Trunnion and Resaw Fence 2 HP Bandsaw     $1050
Rockler HPL Router Table / Router Lift II / Free Porter Cable 1 3/4 HP Router / Stand / Casters/ $      $454.92


JET JCDC-3 230V 3 HP 1PH Cyclone Dust Collector $1495

House warming gift- JET SandSmart JWDS-1632 Drum Sander 

As of now, I held off on the drill press. 

Congrats Dave.  I think you made some great choices.

Sawstop and drum sander, but no jointer?

 

How do i teeech these keeeds?

  • Author
Just now, Pwk5017 said:

Sawstop and drum sander, but no jointer?

 

How do i teeech these keeeds?

I already had the jointer. 

Just now, TheOnlyDave said:

I already had the jointer. 

Phew, crisis averted.

That's some good deals there. But that little free router won't be great in the router table if you use bigger bits in it.

I agree with drzaius and you will in time end up with at least 5 routers before your done.

  • Author

I think you're both right on that one.  It's a very well reviewed router and for the price of free or -$50 of you count the black friday gift card draw it's hard to argue with that (honestly maybe a little more as they included the stand as part of the package and I don't think it was supposed to be).   The lift fits my 2 1/4 hp router perfectly so depending on how I end up using them I could swap the 1 3/4 for handheld and use the 2 1/4 for the router table. Eventually I assume I'll need to go to a 3HP router.  

On 9/17/2016 at 10:46 AM, drzaius said:

How about a pic of that heli?

Don't encourage him, he already lacks focus :D

  • Author
1 hour ago, gee-dub said:

Don't encourage him, he already lacks focus :D

going way back on this one,  the pic was right below him asking.  I have like 13 RC helicopters and 9 Planes. 

  • 5 months later...

My list of power tools

 

Do not wish to hijack TheonlyDaves thread, but it was a very useful discussion. Kind of a clearing house for a good place to start for a Noob. I know I'm reviving an old thread but i think this thread or an entire forum topic might be useful for those that are jumping in (myself included) and become confused by all the noise out there and everyone wanting you to buy their tools or system. While most all of us are restricted in some budgetary way, I'm going to post a list of tools I'm considering. Not necessarily a single all at one time purchase. Perhaps there are those that would like to comment on the entire list or a single tool. This can be done in general on the thread or if someone wants to get more specific they can PM me their experience or advice. 

 

Table saw:  G1023RLW w/7' rail ex & router table attached

                                 $1595.00

Jointer:  G0490xw $1350.00

Or.          G0495x    $2150.00

Router:  Bosch MRC23EVSK

                                  $325.00

Or           Festool 1400 EQ/edge guide

                                  $652.00

Planner:  Dewalt 735x w/ext

                                  $650.00

Bandsaw:  Laguna 1412 w/resaw fence

                                  $1230.00

Or               Laguna 14SUV w/resaw fence

                                  $1935.00

Spindal sander        $???

I realize there are some holes in this list but it seems like a place to start.  I also realize that at some point I may wish to upgrade some or all of these tools. (Provided I live that long)  a little joke but I'm no spring chicken  

Dust collection will be done with shop vacs and respirator for now, until I know layout for sure. (I can and will vent outside)

 

Of course there are others on a wish list and a few I already have. If this needs to be in a separate thread I apologize in advance. This forum has been a wealth of information for me with input from guys/gals who have actually used these tools and aren't just reviewing. 

 

Thanks to all who wish to help spend my money. As stated there is no particular time frame for any of this. My shop is not yet completed but getting closer. It will be somewhat climate controlled (heating/AC) and wired with 220v power. Lighting is somewhat up for grabs but leaning towards LED.

First projects will be shop cabinets, assembly table and work bench to give you an idea of where I'm at now.  In the future I see myself building primarily indoor/outdoor stuff.  Really like G&G and traditional Craftsmen style.

 

Thanks

Mike T

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.