Recommended Posts

Posted

I like my Steel City 50110 bandsaw. It's compact and cuts well. It aligns easily and precisely. Other than having a bed (and throat) that are not very large it does ok.

But as I rebuild our pack porch I had to cut through some 4" cedar. The saw really strains on a material this thick. It's fine on 2" and 3" stuff, with the right blade.  The saw is at that in-between size -- it will do a lot more than the little craft-type saws, but not as much as I had anticipated.

If resawing hefty stuff isn't in your task list then a mid-size unit might be acceptable.  If/when one gets to the point of needing to do a lot of resawing then this size a unit can be quickly outgrown. I may be there in about a year. (That gives me time to shop.)

 

  • Like 1
Posted

The good news is that your 10" saw can stick around as your quick-cut or curve-cut saw.  As for what's next, that's always based on things only you know.  Do you take the next step to a 14" machine or go to a 16" to 18" size saw?  I consider my 17" bandsaw to be a lot like my 8" jointer.  It isn't huge but, it is of a scale that I can fit in my home shop and does 90+% of what I need to do.

Think about what you have done, want to do and where you are taking your woodworking.  Then you'll have to choose a direction.  I'll toss out a couple, neither one is the end-all . . .

- Get a decent proven 14" cast iron machine.  The Grizzly 555's come in a variety of flavors and prices.  Lots of happy owners on all sorts of forums.  A used Delta in good shape could be a way to go but, the prices come near the new prices of low-price-point machines like the Grizzly's.

- Get a 16" to 18" saw.  Again the Grizzly G0513's come in a variety of models and prices but, I would also look at the Powermatics, Jets, Rikon's, etc. just to see where things are in the tier you are looking for.

For either a 14" or larger saw I would want 2HP at least if I were going to do any resawing.  The 14" saw could probably get by with a 1HP, the right blade and a maximum height of around 4".  I use a 14" Delta with a 1HP motor and resawing 6" height can be a test of patience.  My 17" saw is only a 2HP and I can saw at 10" - 12" in height with a feed rate of  about 1" per second.  If I don't care all that much about cut quality I can feed faster but, I find the time to deal with the rough result is about the same as cutting a bit slower and getting a better result . . . YMMV.

Tom is dead-on.  In cars, stereos and bandsaws there is rarely a substitute for raw power.

  • Like 2
Posted

I've had a 14" Delta bandsaw for over 25 years. I put a height kit on so it can resaw 12" (but not really well at that distance) I've resawn 10" on it successfully. Replaced the motor and upgraded the guides to ball bearing ones. It has served me well and I see no reason for a bigger one. I guess it all depends on what kind of projects you decide to tackle.

I'm not real familiar with the current saws available( and Delta is Chinese now and questionable) But it does seem like 14" is where serious tools start. 

  • Like 1
Posted
13 hours ago, gee-dub said:

The good news is that your 10" saw can stick around as your quick-cut or curve-cut saw.  As for what's next, that's always based on things only you know.  Do you take the next step to a 14" machine or go to a 16" to 18" size saw?  I consider my 17" bandsaw to be a lot like my 8" jointer.  It isn't huge but, it is of a scale that I can fit in my home shop and does 90+% of what I need to do.

Think about what you have done, want to do and where you are taking your woodworking.  Then you'll have to choose a direction.  I'll toss out a couple, neither one is the end-all . . .

- Get a decent proven 14" cast iron machine.  The Grizzly 555's come in a variety of flavors and prices.  Lots of happy owners on all sorts of forums.  A used Delta in good shape could be a way to go but, the prices come near the new prices of low-price-point machines like the Grizzly's.

 

I'm keeping my eye out for an old Delta cast iron 14". Chats with a couple of pros around here make those sound like the best value. One came up a month ago (never fails when I'm not in a position to buy) for about $250. There's usually a CL bargain like that once a year or so. I'll just have to jump quickly as they generally disappear within 2 days.

12 hours ago, wdwerker said:

I'm not real familiar with the current saws available( and Delta is Chinese now and questionable) But it does seem like 14" is where serious tools start. 

I guess if by "serious" one means "most durable and capable" or something along those lines then I agree. But I wonder if the 10" might do some things more conveniently than a heftier unit? It's portability and resulting convenience might have a place. But time will tell. Of course if I put a larger table on the 10" there are some things that it would do much better. It's tough to feed an 8' 2x4 over any band saw table -- it's a 2-person job -- but a larger table would have made it much easier to keep it in line.

Excursus: Perhaps we "shade tree" (weekend, evening, part-time) woodworkers have a different view of our tools than the full-time/production crowd. Seems the demands of one's livelihood makes a difference in the direction one takes. In that light, the fewer purchases the better, but sometimes more than one can't be helped. This has been an amateur's incremental educational process.

<rant on>Car stereos are worthless. Too much road noise. It's tough to enjoy Segovia or Herb Alpert over the rumble. That power stays at home.<rant off>

Posted

+1 on the Delta 14" and I have the riser block as well. Takes care of all my resawing needs.  I tried the cool blocks for the guides, took them off, put the stock steel guide blocks back on. Had better results resawing.  

-Ace-

Posted

For years, the only bandsaw I had was the exact same model that Steve has.  It's a Milwaukee/Delta metal/wood 14" that belonged to my Dad.  It has a riser on it, and every available upgrade, including a 1-1/2 hp Baldor.   It does everything a 14" bandsaw can be expected to do.

Then I had a job come up where we needed to resaw 10,000 lineal feet of Cypress, to make roof shingles out of.  It took the 14" about 20 to 30 seconds per two foot cut.   That wasn't going to work.

I found a 24" on ebay a couple of states away,   Once I had it set up, with a dedicated DC, and a big blade on it, it would make the same cut as fast as I could push the pieces through it, and the cut quality was WAY better than the fine tuned 14" could do even with a hundred and fifty dollar Resaw King on it.   I keep the big'un one set up for resawing.

The 14" keeps a 3/8" blade on it, and now only gets used to cut circles for column bases and capitals mostly.

I ended up getting a 12" to use up on the roof, which worked like a charm, and it gets the call for small stuff much more often than either of the other ones get used.   Although I made out with the 14" for decades, I don't want to part with any of them now.  The 14" will probably never get the call to resaw anything again.  It's nice not having to change blades, and adjust guides.

If I had to have only one, I think a 17" Grizzly is probably the best bang for the buck, and best all around hobby shop one is probably a MM16, but there are many choices and variations.  I wouldn't put the money I have in the 14" Delta again, and I got the saw for nothing.  I tried hundreds of dollars worth of blades, only to find out that the saw is the limit.

Posted
6 hours ago, collinb said:

<rant on>Car stereos are worthless. Too much road noise. It's tough to enjoy Segovia or Herb Alpert over the rumble. That power stays at home.<rant off>

I meant . . . cars . . . and . . . stereos . . . and . . . bandsaws  . . . not "car stereos"  :)

  I used to play in a funk band with a horn section.  To make Herb Alpert sound 'real', you need some horse power :)

  • Like 2
Posted
16 hours ago, gee-dub said:

I meant . . . cars . . . and . . . stereos . . . and . . . bandsaws  . . . not "car stereos"  :)

  I used to play in a funk band with a horn section.  To make Herb Alpert sound 'real', you need some horse power :)

(line 1) oops

(line 2) No. you just need to start with analog. LP or open reel.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 33 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined