Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Need Help ID of Lumber

Featured Replies

I discovered a single board in my stash of lumber and I am not sure what it is.  I jointed two sides.  It is really white and straight grained.  It is not birch, poplar, or maple ( I have samples of these in my shop).  The only wood that comes to mind is holly but I have never actually handled any holly.  So, any help is appreciated.  Thanks.  

Here are some pics:

IMG_4972.thumb.jpg.1ae6bfacd258e975756adf09733524cc.jpg

IMG_4970.thumb.jpg.7d0b9f348ba4de0b9f17e23aa0a83d14.jpg

IMG_4974.thumb.jpg.82b02313b283ed9796bd781548414d6b.jpg

IMG_4975.thumb.jpg.ef02946195f00bfab28e9e70d2a6ab4c.jpg

IMG_4976.thumb.jpg.f0b50c453b0fb2e9791bde885cbb7be8.jpg

Sand that end grain to 400 or so, and take another close up shot. Then send up the Bat Signal for@phinds.

 

To me, the grain looks cherry-ish, but the color is far too light. That fits what little I know about alder, but that isn't common in my area, so I have no personal experience with it. Does it seem pretty soft?

The fluted grain on the first pic looks a bit like butternut but I've never seen white butternut so I really doubt that's it. As highlander suggested, get a well cleaned up end grain shot.

How hard is it and how heavy is it?

Definitely not cherry unless it's completely sapwood end-to-end.  Doubt that.

Doesn't really have the right color for alder, IMO.

If I had a gun to my head I'd say poplar.  Soft maple a second choice.  Are you sure it's neither of those?

I agree it looks a lot like tulip poplar

  • Author
10 hours ago, phinds said:

How hard is it and how heavy is it?

Well, it is light relative to its size and it certainly not as heavy as poplar or maple.

 

6 hours ago, Eric. said:

I'll just ID the one that's obvious...bocote. :)

Well, I hate to tell you Eric but I also guessed that one also.  When I picked up the board at first, it was very heavy given its small size.  I thought it would be cocobolo or rosewood.  But, after planing it, turned out to be bocote.  Not sure how I will use it but I will wait for inspiration to hit me.

IMG_4980.thumb.jpg.920f765f306d4761d3651ebe1739164e.jpg

I am adding this pic to see if it helps.  You can see the board in question on the jointer.  I hope you can see how light / white the board is.  Bottom left is Prime Yellow poplar (in other words, light poplar without the usual ugly green colon) that clearly looks yellow compared to the white board.

 

 

Poplar comes in a rainbow of colors, Wade.  I still think it's poplar.  Is it fuzzy at all after machining?  Smell can also be a clue.  Cut into it and take a whiff.

  • Author
13 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Poplar comes in a rainbow of colors, Wade.  I still think it's poplar.  Is it fuzzy at all after machining?  Smell can also be a clue.  Cut into it and take a whiff.

What kind of smell shall I expect?  Can't say that I have any idea what poplar should smell like.

12 minutes ago, wnaziri said:

What kind of smell shall I expect?  Can't say that I have any idea what poplar should smell like.

Hmmm...I'd say...dirty socks with undertones of wet dog and hamster piss?  It's a potpourri.

Get that piece you know is poplar, hack it, smell it...then repeat with the unknown board.

  • Author
1 minute ago, Eric. said:

dirty socks with undertones of wet dog and hamster piss?

OK, we need know how you determined the smell of hamster piss.  We ALL have enquiring minds, you know.

When I cut mahogany, padauk, bubinga, walnut, cherry, zebrawood, etc, there is a usually a distinct and noticeable odor.  Cutting poplar did not seem to produce a noticeable aroma but I shall pay attention next time I am in the shop.

1 minute ago, wnaziri said:

OK, we need know how you determined the smell of hamster piss.  We ALL have enquiring minds, you know.

I had a hamster when I was a kid.  Kept him for about a month then gave him away when his cage needed cleaning.  Bye, buddy.

All species have a unique smell.  Some are subtler than others but they're all unique.  The perfumey exotics can be pretty close to each other sometimes but even they are distinct.  Purpleheart is soapy, padauk is sickening sweet like grandma's perfume, cocobolo is kind of peppery...and so on.  They all have a particular scent you can put your finger on after working with them for a while.

I could be cottonwood but that the same genus (Populus) as poplar.  End grain.  End grain.  End grain

 

  • Author
3 minutes ago, phinds said:

I could be cottonwood but that the same genus (Populus) as poplar.  End grain.  End grain.  End grain

 

I will go to my shop to get some nice pics of the end grain once I sand it down or plane it.

12 minutes ago, phinds said:

I could be cottonwood but that the same genus (Populus) as poplar.  End grain.  End grain.  End grain

 

My understanding is that the common poplar we usually have access to for woodworking is tulip poplar, which isn't actually a poplar at all.  Rather, it's in the magnolia family.  Whereas true poplars are in the willow family and are related to cottonwood and aspen.  But I think the really abundant stuff we typically get is usually tulip poplar, and misnamed as such.  Confusing.

Yep what we call poplar is actually tulip poplar. AKA"  Liriodendron tulipifera " I've got a small one in my front yard 3'diameter trunk and maybe 80-90 ft tall. They get big, real big !

Nuts. Yeah, my statement that cottonwood is in the same genus as poplar (by which I meant yellow poplar) was a Senior Moment. They DO look almost identical, but still ...

15 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Whereas true poplars are in the willow family and are related to cottonwood and aspen.

I was going to say it could be Aspen maybe, but how does a guy in N. Carolina have a random piece of Aspen laying around? It's not common lumber even here.

I have a piece of Aspen branch I could put up for comparison, but I too think the wood in question is Poplar.

 

  • Author

I went to my shop just to do this. I sanded it and planed a bit to be sure.  Wiped with some mineral spirits to remove dust here is a pic with my iPhone.

Having never owned or played with a hamster, or ever having a desire to do so, I could almost smell murine urine in the wood (reminder from the days in the lab with rats / mice).  So, perhaps, poplar is it and it happens to be rather white-ish.

 IMG_4983.thumb.jpg.07638ad9393fc20d86ed8360db25909f.jpg

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.