Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Setting up my dust collector

Featured Replies

I'm in the process of getting my shop set up and was just given a Shop Fox 1.5HP, dual port dust collector with 1 micron bags, some 4" hoses and a bunch of blast gates. I'm still trying to understand the best way to manage dust in the shop (dust collectors, dust extractors, separators, filters, microns !?!?!?!?!?!). I was just reading about cyclone dust separators. Is this something I should consider adding on to my collector as a first step in managing dust? Any advice on how to get the most from my dust separator would be very appreciated? Here's a link to the exact model I have.  http://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/product_200481385_200481385

Thanks again for any help you can offer!!!

I'm not the authority here on the subject, but I can pick at some of the low hanging fruit.

The filter bags aren't great, period.  If venting outside isn't an option, you'll want a good canister filter eventually.  They're pricey at about $150, but they'll filter out much smaller particles than the bags will while retaining the most suction.

The 1.5 HP DC isn't going to have crazy power, so if you are running ducting keep it as short as possible.  Use as little flex hose as possible, as it will eat CFM like candy and reduce performance.

I certainly suggest a cyclone.  It will help prolong your filter life by keeping the heavier chips and particles away from it.  It'll also keep chips out of the DC's impeller.

Here is a picture of my setup.  It isn't perfect, it isn't as efficient as it probably could be (that flex hose between the fan and the filter is no bueno, but I didn't have much of an option)  The cyclone it's self was a poor choice, if doing it over I would have gone with a super dust deputy because the SDD has a larger outlet at the bottom.  This one clogs too easily with planer chips.  I do not have fixed duct work, I have one of those Rockler expandable 20+ foot flex hoses that I drag from machine to machine.  I do this mainly because I'm not 100% sure with my tool placement yet.

 

IMAG0287.jpg

First thing to do is type dust collection in the forum search and you will get a complete history of discussions and recommendations from other members.  There is a lot of info on here!  I would then think about what you want to achieve with a DC system.  The range of options will cost somewhere between $100 and $10,000+!  The system you have is good for hooking up to individual machines and sucking up sawdust and shavings.  As mentioned the first thing I would do is replace the bag filter with a good canister filter like the the ones from Wynn.  At this point you will be filtering out the visible fine dust from the air.  The issue you now have is that expensive filter will plug quickly with the sawdust and fine dust and your system will become very inefficient.  If you are ok with moving your system to different machines and cleaning your filter often then you are good to go.  The next evolution is to modify your system to a 2 stage system by adding a cyclone separator which will separate 99% of the shavings and sawdust to a waste bin and only fine dust will enter your filter resulting way less cleaning of your filter.  The next evolution would be a central stationary system with ducting going to each machine and blast gates to only allow suction at one machine at a time.  A 1-1/2 hp system is pretty small for a central ducted system but lots of people have achieved satisfactory results with short runs of 4" PVC duct and minimizing the amount of flex duct going to each machine.  If you can vent your fines outside (eliminate the canister filter) that will be the best option to keep the suction power of your blower at its optimum level.  A good central system really requires a blower with a 3-5hp motor.  With all these options you will still need to wear a good respirator to prevent breathing the micro fine dust you will be blasting into the air!  If you want to achieve utopia and eliminate the micro dust at your big machines you are looking at the big $'s with 7" smooth wall ducting, 5hp blowers and machine mods to get larger than 4" ports and the list goes on and on!  Even at this point you will need a respirator for hand tool operations!  I know this is way more than what you asked for but the DC rabbit hole is a huge topic to venture into!

Many here have said this, but I'll repeat and summarize:

Dust collection is about particulates. It's about cleanliness; it's not about health. For health protection, wear a respirator mask. A good one. Always They're about $35 at Home Depot.

 

First off - welcome to the forum!

Second...good luck with your DC improvements.  It's great that you're making it part of your initial shop setup it's important.

I have to say the advice/comments above are spot on - at least from my experience with my situation.  I don't have any experience with THAT particular DC, but my system is also a 1.5HP system (Delta). I use it as a 'central' DC, piped in to all my machines.  I have minimal flex ducting, and have run 4" smoothwall PVC pipe to each of my machines (tablesaw, Bandsaw, jointer, planer) keeping all bends/elbows to a minimum where I could.  I replaced the stock 1.0micron bag with a canister type filter - I went with a filter from Wynn and I think this was a big improvement in airflow for my system.  To help keep the filter clear, I added a Super Dust Deputy and a small fiber drum underneath (I want a larger one but am constrained by ceiling height in my basement).  I did need to work on modifications on 2 of my tools to make the collection better - I added under-the-table collection to my bandsaw, and I had to cover up a lot of the points of leakage on my jointer to try to focus the airflow where it did the most good.  I also have an air cleaner mounted on the ceiling which I usually turn on as I walk out of the shop, and although its filters do accumulate some dust I believe most of it is from sanding.  

Overall, I think the system works well.  Even with what I think is a decent DC system, I still use a respirator (at least most of the time).  Of course, if budget allows (for either of us) upgrading to a more powerful unit and 6" ducting would make for a far better system.  But if you're set on using the smaller one for now, then there's no reason you can't make it into a workable DC system for a small shop.

 

 

Keep in mind that a cyclone reduces efficiency...and so do filters.  I have a 2HP ducted system with a cyclone, but I vent the fines directly out of the shop to make up for the lost efficiency from the cyclone (no filter).  It picks up the mess but doesn't make the air safe to breathe.  A 1.5HP ducted system with a cyclone and a filter...ehh...you're pushing it.  It'll be pretty mediocre in the CFM department at that point.  Even my 2HP vented outside is really not enough power.  Those little toy DC units are really designed to be hooked up machine-to-machine.  Adjust your expectations if you try to use it where a 5HP unit is realistically needed.

 

 

Eric - what do you run for ducting?  Have you ever done an SP loss calculation on your ductwork?

57 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Keep in mind that a cyclone reduces efficiency...and so do filters.

They most definitely do.  Without any real measurements, I can say that replacing my stock bag filter with a canister filter made for a pretty good improvement in airflow.  I, unfortunately, didn't really pay attention before/after installing the Super Dust Deputy.  Has anyone ever seen SP loss numbers for the SDD or for filters?  Or for machines, for that matter?  I did a SP loss calculation for my ducting, and I have the SP curve for my DC (done as a review by Wood mag, I recall).....what I don't have to complete the picture are the SP numbers for the machines or the cyclone (although I'm willing to assume the loss from the SDD is offset by the improvement with the new filter).

I'm toying with the idea of either buying some airflow measuring devices, or making a shop-made manometer to track my DC performance.  I'd also love to move to 5" pipe from the 4" I have now (my DC has a 5" port).

 

1 hour ago, Jfitz said:

Eric - what do you run for ducting?  Have you ever done an SP loss calculation on your ductwork?

 

I have 4" S&D PVC throughout.  Very small sections of flex hose to connect to machines, Lee Valley blast gates.  The SDD has a 5" inlet so I could have used 5" for the main, but it's not readily available so I said screw it and used 4".  What I lose in CFM I gain in velocity, and since my system is not really a "fines capturing animal," efficiently pulling the bulk of the larger waste is my main goal and the increased velocity helps with that.

I've never done any measurements on SP loss or CFM or anything.  Until I buy a real system (which I may or may not ever do), I just don't really care what the numbers are.  I know I'm not safe without a respirator and that's all I need to know.

  • Author

Wow...thanks everyone for the responses. I have been a High School wood shop teacher for 16 years and didn't really become concerned with dust collection until I purchased my house in April of this year and started setting up my own shop for a small business in my garage.

Keeping my mess to a minimum is a minor concern but my health is my biggest concern. Especially because I am in a wood shop all day for my full-time job. My research and your responses lead me to believe that there's really no setup that will be perfect enough to go respirator free? I have been working with a respirator some of the time but I guess I need to become more diligent with it. Its just so cumbersome.

Also, I took the advice from several of the above response and just bought a trash can separator cover and will be calling Wynn tomorrow for a canister filter that will fit my unit. Thanks again for the help. It seems that this forum will be a great resource for continual upgrades. 

Yeah wearing a respirator sucks, but you're not safe without it in almost any shop...even one with a big 5HP collector and excellent filters.  The problem is the inefficiency at the tool ports.  Most hobbyist/small pro type machines are just poorly designed for DC, so without heavy modifications - and sometimes even then it's not good enough - collection is just piss poor.  The table saw and bandsaw are two of the biggest culprits.  You could have hurricane-force sucking power but if it's a foot or 18 inches away from where the dust is being made...some of it is gonna escape, no way around it.

I pick my battles with the respirator.  I hate it too.  I try to wear it whenever I spend a significant amount of time at the table saw or bandsaw.  I try to always wear it when hand sanding, which IMO is the biggest danger.  I'm a little casual about it when jointing and planing (naively so, probably) because those machines don't tend to create quite as much fine dust.

But the reality is, all tools create fine dust, and simply being in your shop is kicking up fine dust that already exists.  So if you're truly worried about your health, the only real strategy is to wear your respirator all the time.  Especially for someone like you, who spends five full days a week in a dusty shop.  Hobbyists can be slightly more casual about it, since we're not living in dusty conditions for but an evening or two a week, plus Sundays.

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.