Recommended Posts

Posted

I generally try to avoid plumbing work, but I'm in the process of swapping out a cracked above cabinet sink for a new one and I need to hook up the drain to P-trap. The plumbing is chrome plated brass, 1 1/4" diameter and it uses slip joints and compression joint at the connection the actual drain. The slip joints all came with squared off round rubber washers. They have no taper. Is that washer supposed to somehow cram into the gap between the inner and outer pipe walls?, or does it just stay at the end and get squished down by the nut as it tightens? Do I need different washers? 

Also, no benefit from PTFE tape or pipe dope, right, because the water isn't going through the threads anyways, or am I missing something?

I really don't want to call a plumber if I can avoid it, but right now it leaks through these joints when I turn the water on for a test. 

Any assistance is much appreciated.

 

mtn-slipjointextensiontube.jpg

Posted

Okay I'm cautiously optimistic (no leaks after running hot and cold for a few minutes each) I solved the issue, I believe the problem was running too much pipe into the sleeve, which was then stopping the washer from cinching in as tight as necessary. 

Just answering my own question to close the loop in case someone else has a similar question. Also there seem to be a lot fewer online resources for chrome plated plumbing than PVC. 

Also, I'll keep an eye on things for the next week or so. If any leaks, I'll bring in the pros. 

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Glad you figured it out.  I just got in, and am probably one of the few left with experience using this stuff.  Most plumbers stopped using it back in the mid '80s, before the internet.   You did it right.  The trick is not too much pressure, or you can easily roll up the washer, and no other tape or compound needed.

Posted
20 minutes ago, Tom King said:

Glad you figured it out.  I just got in, and am probably one of the few left with experience using this stuff.  Most plumbers stopped using it back in the mid '80s, before the internet.   You did it right.  The trick is not too much pressure, or you can easily roll up the washer, and no other tape or compound needed.

Say what? I see it all the time. 

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
13 minutes ago, C Shaffer said:

Say what? I see it all the time. 

Is it mostly used for presentation purposes because it looks nicer than PVC?

Edited by Isaac
typo
Posted
8 minutes ago, K Cooper said:

This topic went down the drain fast

don't you have something better to do Coop? get back out in the shop or better yet grab a stogie and watch the sun go down with Sharon:)

  • Like 1
Posted

I guess maybe it's a local thing, so the world I see has few of those.  I don't know about the small city near here, but anyone out in the country has well water that is slightly acidic.  That type of drain, or rather the trap part, only lasts a few years around here.  Lowes and Home Depot don't even have it in stock, and plumbing suppliers look at you funny if you ask for it.

Back when that was all that was available, everyone kept a bucket under the trap, because it wasn't a question of "if", but "when".

For some reason, the water if good for health, and teeth.  I hadn't been to a dentist in over 30 years, but my Wife made an appointment.  They said my teeth didn't need cleaning.  My 101 year old Mother still has all her teeth, and has never had a cavity.

  • Like 1
Posted
2 hours ago, Isaac said:

Is it mostly used for presentation purposes because it looks nicer than PVC?

It matches the urinal chrome. I am in schools and a four square home region. When they go, they get replaced in kind quite often. To @Tom King‘s point, much around here is chromed copper. Still unsure why chromed brass would fail quickly?

  • Like 1
Posted

I should clarify, I think the pipe I had is Chromed brass, but I really don't know, maybe it is copper inside there. Although I don't live in the city proper anymore, I do know that the city of Chicago requires a lot of sweated copper pipe in applications where other jurisdictions commonly use PVC and PEX.  

Posted

Our issue is number one on this list.  No unusual amount of sulfur.  The water all comes out of granite rock cracks, and is low ph.  Plastic piping eliminates staining, and pipe corrosion.  I installed copper water lines in our house, but took it all out after about ten years because I got tired of having to fix it.  The water tastes great, and only shows evidence of providing good health.  It also runs out of the ground every few hundred yards not far from the lake.

http://www.cleanwaterstore.com/blog/top-9-causes-of-copper-corrosion-in-home-piping-systems/

Posted

In the future take those square rubber washers and throw them as far over your left shoulder as you can. Their crap. Buy a few extra nylon tapered washers. 

You don't 'need' pipe dope but a little won't hurt. Sometimes it can make the difference between a little seeper and no leaks. Whenever you see the really fine threads like on a lavatory (aka bathroom) tailpiece use teflon pipe dope (not tape)..they are notorious for leaks. 

Chrome plated brass traps are about as common as a ham sammich where I come from. You can buy them in different ga. The ones at home depot are probably paper thin...20ga maybe. Plumbing supply houses have 18ga.

Also, to answer your question...PVC traps are not better unless they are sched 40 glue. I'd recommend against PVC slip joint anything. You can just use plain brass if its hidden in a cabinet and save a few pennies though.

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.