Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Countertop Repair

Featured Replies

Just installed some solid oak counter tops. These counter tops were treated with butcher block oil. The directions said to apply one coat, wipe off excess, then wait a few days and do it again and then once more. We only got to do it once.

Then the the folks came to install the back splash. The back splash people created some problems. When doing the grout, some of the water they used to wipe the grout got onto the counter. The counters are now discolored in a lot of places. Pics of the discoloration below.

My theory and plan to fix:

Because the wood already had been treated with oil then the grout water could not have penetrated too deeply right? So I bought some of those mesh sanding pads for my orbital sander, the kind that don't clog very easily. Sand the counter tops till the discoloration is removed, then re-apply the butcher block oil.

Does this sounds reasonable? What am I missing? Is there a better way? 

IMG_20181207_130254.thumb.jpg.23a05eadadc9d7c205bb72e3c8c6c05b.jpg

IMG_20181207_130256.thumb.jpg.eb41f36edf03906147a07c71780b6476.jpg

IMG_20181207_130303.thumb.jpg.019b7772ddae7ecfb44f3e86058ec2ca.jpg

How long since the grout was done? You might give it a few days to see if it goes away, but that looks like more that a 'wet wood' stain. I think something in the grout has reacted with the tannins in the oak. Those stains can go deepish. The oil, while giving some superficial protection, won't stop liquids from soaking in if they sit on the surface for more than a few minutes.

I think you'll have to use something more aggressive than the abrasive pads. Start with 80 grit until the stains are gone & then work up through the grits. A card scraper will get the edges next to the tile.

I wouldn't use oak on a kitchen counter for this reason. If someone sets a cast iron pan on it & it is even a little damp then it will stain it black.

Good luck.

I agree give it time to dry but i doubt that's the whole story.

My second thought would be to rent a hardwood flooring edger. I'd try the ROS to start but if it's slow going and you start to put some waves in the surface I'd go for a more aggressive approach. The hardwood flooring edgers work FAST and their rental isn't all that expensive might save you the cost in time and frustration.

  • Author

Thanks for the replies guys. Good suggestions there.

A few days had gone by when those pictures were taken. It has been almost a week since the pictures were taken.

It would not be too difficult to un-install the counter tops to do the sanding. I think I may do that.

I think the solution they use to clean "grout haze" off newly installed tile is acidic.  I don't know what the implications of that are for your stains - maybe someone else here knows.

3 minutes ago, G Ragatz said:

I think the solution they use to clean "grout haze" off newly installed tile is acidic.  I don't know what the implications of that are for your stains - maybe someone else here knows.

Grout haze is just cleaned off with plain water, but the grout residue makes it alkaline, so that's probably what's messed with the oak.

38 minutes ago, drzaius said:

Grout haze is just cleaned off with plain water, but the grout residue makes it alkaline, so that's probably what's messed with the oak.

I think you right and i believe Ross posted something about using strong alkaline chemicals to "stain" the tanins in oak. I believe he used powdered lye drain cleaner. Isn't grout basically a portland cement?

Try whatever you decide on a small area first.  Good luck.

Cut the bottom grout line & remove top to sand is what I would do.  White Lexcel cleans up with mineral spirits, but I would mask off the refinished oak before I caulked it to the tile.

1 hour ago, Chestnut said:

Isn't grout basically a portland cement

Yep, a good part of it anyway.

  • Author
  • Popular Post

Thanks for the replies everyone. I have an update. Here is a picture of what I'm working with here:

IMG_20181214_075532.thumb.jpg.ae24e772221d50853bef41fc03e6cdc7.jpg

This is a commercial space so the sink is lowered to be ADA compliant. That makes it so that the counters are not all one big piece. Anyway, that left most section had some of the spots on it but it was the least bad of all of them.

I did not have to spend TOO much time sanding at 80 grit to get the the thing looking nice again. 

IMG_20181214_075544.thumb.jpg.3249fe04c308c31eb9e754cf1dcd9b16.jpg

As you can see it recovered pretty much completely. Which gives me hope for the other sections. The section in the corner is by far the worst so I hope it will not be too far gone. Even if I make it 50% better then I will be pretty happy. 

I knew when I picked these counters that they would get stained and/or damaged in time, but I did not expect them to get ruined before we even moved into the new space. I was pretty down about it. Feeling much better now.

Anyway, thanks again for the input guys.

I would pay close attention to the wood surrounding the sink and the counter ends above. They will hold up much better if kept oiled. Maybe every 6 -12 months, or more frequently if the sink area gets a lot of splashing. Drying up water that gets on the wood promptly helps a lot too. 

Trapped moisture on a clients maple butcherblock top around a bar/vegetable prep sink that rarely got oiled or dried after use started rot & black mold. Another clients maple counters got treated well and scrubbed with a ScotchBrite (gray) pad before re-oiling at least once a year and 20 + years later they still look good.

  • Author
29 minutes ago, wdwerker said:

I would pay close attention to the wood surrounding the sink and the counter ends above. They will hold up much better if kept oiled. Maybe every 6 -12 months, or more frequently if the sink area gets a lot of splashing. Drying up water that gets on the wood promptly helps a lot too. 

Trapped moisture on a clients maple butcherblock top around a bar/vegetable prep sink that rarely got oiled or dried after use started rot & black mold. Another clients maple counters got treated well and scrubbed with a ScotchBrite (gray) pad before re-oiling at least once a year and 20 + years later they still look good.

My plan is to oil them a lot. Maybe as aggressively as quarterly. My employees will be the ones using it, and while they are mostly all great folks there is that element of "It's just the work kitchen". 

Also "Another clients maple counters got treated well and scrubbed with a ScotchBrite (gray) pad before re-oiling at least once a year and 20 + years later they still look good." 20+ years?!?! Just how old ARE you? :blink:

2 hours ago, wdwerker said:

I would pay close attention to the wood surrounding the sink and the counter ends above. They will hold up much better if kept oiled. Maybe every 6 -12 months, or more frequently if the sink area gets a lot of splashing. Drying up water that gets on the wood promptly helps a lot too. 

Trapped moisture on a clients maple butcherblock top around a bar/vegetable prep sink that rarely got oiled or dried after use started rot & black mold. Another clients maple counters got treated well and scrubbed with a ScotchBrite (gray) pad before re-oiling at least once a year and 20 + years later they still look good.

A couple of years ago I did a wooden counter with an under mount sink :unsure: for my daughter's kitchen. They specifically did not want a film finish, just oil for a more natural wood look.

My solution was to coat the edge of the sink cutout, the are behind where the faucet sits, and about an inch around the other sides with clear epoxy. Not a heavy coat, just enough to soak into the wood. A heat gun helped things along here. The surfaces around the sink were then lightly sanded with 220, blending the epoxy edge in, & then the whole thing finished with a butcher block oil finish.

I can tell where the epoxy is, but only because I know it's there. It's very hard to notice. 2 years later it looks a good as the day it was finished.

Just turned 60. Been self employed for 40 years. Did remodeling & handyman stuff when I started  and focused on woodwork as I acquired enough machines to need to rent a space to work out of.

  • Author
5 minutes ago, wdwerker said:

Just turned 60. Been self employed for 40 years. Did remodeling & handyman stuff when I started  and focused on woodwork as I acquired enough machines to need to rent a space to work out of.

One of the main reasons I lover this forum so much.

Great folks like you willing to pass on your experience with the newer generation.

Thanks Steve.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.